I agree that given all that Barry had, he never should have taken their homes. I think he did set out to take over the company, and not give them their fair share. Then when he found out at least two of the older brothers had truly fallen on hard times ( drug addiction etc. ) he did a certain amount by giving them money for rehab, homes, cottages, etc. but this was probably really " peanuts " for Barry. Don't forget the Shermans were public figures in the Canadian, and Jewish Philanthropic, as well as Political worlds. In a very pragmatic way he may have just been protecting the Sherman name. It all backfired with the lawsuits started by " the orphans " . The fight got ugly, and Barry with all his money had the advantage. He could have been more benevolent, letting them have what he had already given them, and just walked away, but he, perhaps by nature, fought to win, like he did in the hundreds of Big Pharma lawsuits he waged over the years. The end result is that they all appear in a bad light, greedy, grasping, vengeful, fighting over money, but then, that is the way of the world. IMO