Caylee Anthony Drowned In Family Pool Theory

[Ssejors]

GA & CA would've NEVER covered up an accidental death. If she died in the pool, the police would've been called, CA wouldn't have been trying to reach KC nor post anything on her myspace. Clearly, Casey is a big liar and she isn't fooling anyone!

I think you hit the nail on the head with this.


If GA and CA knew that Caylee was gone, drown in the pool. and GA helped ICA cover it up... then WHY would CA spend almost a month trying to track ICA down? Why the 3 911 calls and all the commotion to have ICA arrested to find out what happened to Caylee. The only reason i can fathom is if CA wasnt in on it and GA and ICA were the only ones to know.
BUT here is my big but! I dont think GA can hide anything from CA. I think if GA knows.. then CA knows. I think there is a lot CA knows that GA doesnt but GA is a simple man who cant hide much. and I think hiding the death of and the dead body of her precious Grandchild is NOT something GA and ICA could get past CA. She wanted the baby found! and frankly, if it wasnt for Cindy Anthony, would we have found Caylee? She's not my favorite player in all of this, Mrs. CA, But I have to be thankful that she pushed and pushed and made call after call and finally called the police. GA and ICA did not cover this up and hide it from CA.... ICA covered her A$$ and tried to hide this from her parents. End of story. Even if Caylee's death was from negligence or murder, this was Casey and Casey alone.

 

[SWGAL]

What blows my mind, is how did Kronk get Caylee's body? Did he drive around in Casey's car until he dumped her body in the wooded area? Oh, please Biaz!

 

[Ssejors]

I was saying to my SO last night that Baez's opening statement and AHA moment would have been plausible as an accidental drowning covered up by ICA as a means of Ugly coping because of years of sexual abuse IF HE HAD STOPPED AT THAT! But he didn't. He went on to accuse RK of stealing and hiding Caylee's body, DR. Vass who just wants to make a million bucks, the fbi for contaminating evidence, the Psychic lady for butting her nose in, blah blah blah...

It's like when yer kid lies and it starts out good, but they just keep adding more and more and more details to the story till it becomes non plausible.


And on top of all that, as people have already mentioned here... Why would it take 3 YEARS in a Jail cell to finally admit to an accident. Yuri and the boys made it clear that IF THIS WAS AN ACCIDENT... TELL US NOW cause it will be easier on everyone to know the truth.. but.. B@77s to the wall Casey wont EVER admit guilt. Even if it was an accident..


Do you see why the whole Ladder issue has come up? So that ICA doesnt even have to be responsible for the ACCIDENT. She wasnt a mother who was tired and fell asleep at a bad time. She wasnt a mother too preoccupied with Facebook. She was a good mother. CINDY LEFT THE LADDER ON THE POOL. Once again... NOT ICA's FAULT!

 

[SoCalSleuth]

If it was premeditated, there would have been a burial or disposal spot already designated. So if the murder weapon is tape, was there signs that Caylees hands were tied up so she couldnt rip it off?

Actually, that is not true. It is common for murderers to plan everything BUT what they are going to do with the body afterwards. Also, premeditation can occur in a second.

 

[akashana]

Not likely, Mr Baez is telling the story that his client told him, he has no obilgation to protect George, if she says he put his penis in her mouth then it is Mr Baez's job to let the jurors know about it.


If this was any other girl making such a claim everyone here would be ready to lynch the father but because its Casey Anthony it cant be true.

MY BOLD

For me, it's a little like the story of the boy who cried wolf. We have seen lie after lie, really one falsehood after another, issue from her lips. She lied about her father's state of health, the state of her parents' marriage, made up a job she supposedly went to and a nanny who allegedly watched her child, her ability to get "red carpet tickets" to the Batman premier, the whole Sports Authority fiasco, that she attended college, the whole money-stealing thing with her family members and friend . . . Given the totality of KC's lies about almost (if not all) aspects of her life, I simply cannot accept that George and/or Lee molested her without any other corroborating evidence.

 

[wallflower67]

Until Caylee was found with duct tape on her mouth, i believed it was a pool accident that Casey badly covered up when she couldn't get a hold of her parents (the flurry of phone calls.)

But the duct tape, and the internet searches for choroform and neck breaking make me think she had to be thinking of killing someone. Though I actually think she was going to kill her parents.

 

[katydid23]

Not likely, Mr Baez is telling the story that his client told him, he has no obilgation to protect George, if she says he put his penis in her mouth then it is Mr Baez's job to let the jurors know about it.


If this was any other girl making such a claim everyone here would be ready to lynch the father but because its Casey Anthony it cant be true.

Please consider the REASONS, the factual reasons, many of us do not believe her claims. For example:

- She wrote about the memories of Lee possibly pulling her bra up at night. And in those letters she also said " I also have vague feeling that my father MIGHT HAVE come into my room at night when I was younger but It might have been a dream--I don't know."

SHE SAID THAT JUST A COUPLE OF MONTHS AGO---So how is she suddenly accusing her Dad of years of constant sexual abuse now????????????

There is ZERO evidence that she was ever afraid of her father. She continued to return to the home to steal gas and frozen food and she never left the area.

She talked back to him during the jail house videos on many occasions AND she also praised him as a WONDERFUL FATHER AND GRANDFATHER.

She allowed him to care for her child and bathe her and tuck her in at night.


So, Could you PLEASE stop accusing us of UNFAIRLY discounting her accusations.

 

[RR473]

I've been thinking about this all day and I just cannot understand why JB convoluted the accident story by putting George in it. I can see some jurors believing a scared 22 year old panicking after discovering her daughter drowned in the swimming pool. Not saying that is what happened, but I can see making it into a somewhat believable story to promote reasonable doubt. But putting George in the story just doesn't make sense. Why wouldn't he call 911? Report it as an accident? Why would he dispose of the body on his own and not well enough not to be found by a meter reader? Casey motives for covering it up could be made believable, but not George. He said "Why didn't George call 911?" "We'll never know." So why even put him in the story to begin with???

Agreed and considering JB's performance yesterday, I have the impression that he is pretty incompetent.


ETA: But that's also a very hopeless task.

 

[The Farm]

What gives with the little pouty mouth on Casey for the past two days.

Is she pissed because these people that are facing her will be the ones to judge her?

She can see their faces, we can't.

 

[USARDOG]

He can't do that. It HAD to come from his client.

Not sure where you got the idea that he "can't do that." He most certainly can and has, IMO. There is not proof whatsoever that there is even one shred of truth in the claims of either molestation or that GA participated in the cover up. ICA never related to anyone that she was molested prior to her arrest. She had no problem with GA baby sitting Caylee alone... Do you really believe a woman who was molested since she was 8 would leave her own daughter along the the man who had molested her?? Lastly, it would be easy enough to prove where GA was that afternoon JB claims he found Caylee in the pool, I'm thinking the state will track his cell phone pings and prove he was no were near the house at the time in question. IMO, there is not a single word of truth in these accusations, and JB has no obligation during opening statements to stick to the facts. Oh, and IMO, a guilty client will seldom tell his attorney the truth about the crime, it just makes them more difficult to defend.

 

[6stringer]

or tells her brother that calling them was a waste, a huge waste.

again, this is one of the things that interests me. her mental "Psych". you could fill a page or ten up with things she did, or things she said. in the end, she has major mental illnesses. maybe she did just throw her entire family under the bus...um, if that doesnt hint at mental illness then I dont know what does.

 

[Patty G]

IMO, if the story doesn't make sense, then it is not true!

 

[Woe.be.gone]

There was talk that Lee had ordered a new filter for the Anthony pool not long after June 16. If the DT has the goods on that, that would be something factual that may lend to the credibility of their story.

 

[carole]

What blows my mind, is how did Kronk get Caylee's body? Did he drive around in Casey's car until he dumped her body in the wooded area? Oh, please Biaz!

I don't believe George had anything to do with Caylee's death, but he certainly, as a former police officer, would not have left her body anywhere it would have been found, by anyone, ever. Certainly not on Suburban Drive just around the corner from his house. And why would Kronk leave it there, he would have just called the police to the place where he found it first, he would't have moved it.

Baez is grasping at straws IMO. And not very well, at that.

 

[carole]

IMO, if the story doesn't make sense, then it is not true!

Occam's razor. JB has obviously never heard of it.

[ame="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor"]Occam's razor - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia@@AMEPARAM@@/wiki/File:Sunlight_over_Earth_as_seen_by_STS-29_crew_-_GPN-2003-00025.jpg" class="image"><img alt="" src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a4/Sunlight_over_Earth_as_seen_by_STS-29_crew_-_GPN-2003-00025.jpg/200px-Sunlight_over_Earth_as_seen_by_STS-29_crew_-_GPN-2003-00025.jpg"@@AMEPARAM@@commons/thumb/a/a4/Sunlight_over_Earth_as_seen_by_STS-29_crew_-_GPN-2003-00025.jpg/200px-Sunlight_over_Earth_as_seen_by_STS-29_crew_-_GPN-2003-00025.jpg[/ame]

 

[IRule254]

"Neck breaking", "household weapons", "self-defense"........

I still believe there were to be other victims, besides Caylee, and now the only way Casey can get to them are these horrendous accusations.

Caylee may have drowned in the swimming pool (or the bathtub for that matter), however, the duct tape indicates she didn't unless it was applied before her head was held underwater by her mother.

MOO

Forgive me if this has already been asked but I do NOT remember her googleing "self defense". Wow, IMO she was gonna take out her parents and claim self defense. :no:

I do think Caylee did drown in that pool but not accidentally.

 

[Beatrice]

I always felt the duct tape was Casey's attempt at making Caylee's disappearance/death look like a kidnapping/abduction.

Adding: The heart sticker that possibly matches the ones at the home.
The stickers Casey called "ugly"

The prosecution is claiming Caylee died as a result of a drowning & the duct tape was an afterthought.

 

[KMouse]

He can't do that. It HAD to come from his client.

Ethically he can't. However I think the defense is the accident that has snowballed out of control. They cooked up this story and have retold it enough between themselves that they believe it.

If you were a lawyer and your client was looking at the death penalty wouldn't you strongly suggest to them that they confess to an accident and take a deal? Why would you as a lawyer take the chance of sinking your client? You are not acting in your client's best interest if you do something that stupid.

 

[Linda7NJ]

Not sure where you got the idea that he "can't do that." He most certainly can and has, IMO. There is not proof whatsoever that there is even one shred of truth in the claims of either molestation or that GA participated in the cover up. ICA never related to anyone that she was molested prior to her arrest. She had no problem with GA baby sitting Caylee alone... Do you really believe a woman who was molested since she was 8 would leave her own daughter along the the man who had molested her?? Lastly, it would be easy enough to prove where GA was that afternoon JB claims he found Caylee in the pool, I'm thinking the state will track his cell phone pings and prove he was no were near the house at the time in question. IMO, there is not a single word of truth in these accusations, and JB has no obligation during opening statements to stick to the facts. Oh, and IMO, a guilty client will seldom tell his attorney the truth about the crime, it just makes them more difficult to defend.

BBM
What I am saying is Jose did not pull the story about a 13 yr old Casey with her dad's penis in her mouth or George having a dead Caylee in his arms when Casey learned that she accidentially drowned and George agreed to help conceal the crime only to turn around and frame her... straight outta his butt. Those words had to come from Casey.

I never claimed it was the truth. Jose can not fabricate stories like that, he would be disbarred. Jose is working with what Casey told him on those two subjects

 

[Oakley]

I loved the part when JB said that Cindy told YM about the ladder being out by the pool and JB doesn't understand why this wasn't investigated. He said the police didn't look into it, didn't do any forensics, nothing. But why would they??? YOUR client told them Caylee was kidnapped by the nanny...why in the world would they do forensics on, I don't even know what, the pool ladder? Silly YM probably assumed if Caylee accidently drowned in the family pool someone would surely call 911, so better to go with the nanny kidnapped her like her own mother was telling him.

BBM I don't believe it wasn't investigated.