My husband, a former military officer and service academy grad, says someone can wash out for not being physically or psychologically fit, e.g., under pressure they evidence psychological issues. He concurs that it's too late if someone just thinks, "oh, don't like this, I quit." He says it's more unpleasant to quit than to be kicked out. According to someone he knows who is involved in recruiting, something like 2/3 are excluded during the initial work-up before they ever enlist, so he's sort of surprised that this guy made it through. He says that the characteristics of someone with his criminal record would be a poor predictor of success in the military and so would be a poor prospect during the recruiting process...
I am not sure how to quote yet but Oceanblueeyes makes a good point on the dogs. I just watched a news special where dog owners were on telling about their dogs ability to protect the family. The news station then put hidden cameras in the home and had a fake "prowler" break in. The dogs, all various breeds, all acted either scared, curious,or oblivious. To the shock of one home owner his German Shepard even brought his ball to the "prowler" to play. But none reacted violently.
I don't think he dropped out on his own. It isn't uncommon for many recruits to fail to pass muster in the grueling 13 weeks of training at Marine Corps boot camp. It is the toughest to complete of all armed services. Many recruits who want to be Marines never become one because they never make it at boot camp.
Its much more than being just physically fit and even though he seems muscular now doesn't mean he was back then. I honestly don't think he was tough enough to be a Marine. Either that or he would not adhere to the rules and discipline which is another thing that will get a recruit tossed to the curb and sent home.
IMO
I know they look at criminal and medical records to see if there are any issues in the past but I wonder if Wint had any records because he was an immigrant?
Hello blueeyes,
Former Marine here and I know some things have changed. Back in my time with the draft lottery and sometimes a felon entering about the only way out would be for a medical injury or psychiatric diag. I sure it happens on rare occasion but they'll also set people back for retraining or ship them off to motivation platoon to move mounds of sand. (an attitude check) If someone is having trouble on a force march they expect others in the platoon to get them through it.
My gut feeling is he had a personality flaw and was just not compatible in getting along with others. The Marines will get a person in shape, many hundreds and thousands of bends and thrust with pushups can be done in 13 weeks. I saw two dropouts due to medical reasons (a drill instructor injured a recruit by putting a boot in his back doing push-ups.
Times have changed though but I don't think too much.
Semper Fi
I don't know about his past records, but my husband was saying that if someone subsequently developed the criminal record that Wint has, that usually they would show character/personality traits (dishonesty, impulsivity, lack of self control, etc.) even before committing any crimes that would come out during initial evaluation and make that person a poor prospect. Of course, no screening process works with 100% certainty.
Another thought: how does one get Honorably Discharged if one was never a Marine?
Can you get HD'd from boot camp? It doesn't make sense to me.
I'm not sure what screening process is done prior to Marine boot camp. With the recent military base murders in the past few years, I think the debate had to do with the fact that if there is screening, it is very minimal.
I've long held the opinion that our escalating crime rates, prison populations and cases of domestic violence are tied to the elimination of the mandatory draft. Too many teenagers are not being required to learn to follow the rules or to engage in self-discipline but that is another topic altogether.
JMO
Well, I'd ask my husband, but he's getting pretty upset by my intense interest in this case. :silenced:
I won't let that stop me from guessing that you have to get "discharged" (honorably or dishonorably) after you've signed on the dotted line, which would be prior to bootcamp.
Hello blueeyes,
Former Marine here and I know some things have changed. Back in my time with the draft lottery and sometimes a felon entering about the only way out would be for a medical injury or psychiatric diag. I sure it happens on rare occasion but they'll also set people back for retraining or ship them off to motivation platoon to move mounds of sand. (an attitude check) If someone is having trouble on a force march they expect others in the platoon to get them through it.
My gut feeling is he had a personality flaw and was just not compatible in getting along with others. The Marines will get a person in shape, many hundreds and thousands of bends and thrust with pushups can be done in 13 weeks. I saw two dropouts due to medical reasons (a drill instructor injured a recruit by putting a boot in his back doing push-ups.
Times have changed though but I don't think too much.
Semper Fi
I've heard of Honorable under medical conditions, it's a bit different than just dropping out but we'd need to see the record.
Another thought: how does one get Honorably Discharged if one was never a Marine?
Can you get HD'd from boot camp? It doesn't make sense to me.
I came across this long thread of a debate that SS was having with others. It's just interesting to see how passionate he was about martial arts and incredibly intelligent.
https://groups.google.com/forum/m/#!msg/fa.iaido/68-lA-Kt5q4/DBwPd6QWWHgJ
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Hopefully his prison mates will assure that he gets capitol punishment when they find out how he tortured a 10-y.o. kid. Despite the bulked up photos of DW from his facebook, he is a small person, 5'7" 150#. He won't be Mr. tough guy for long in prison.
In the video posted by TexMex (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/arti...olice-say.html), as noted by TexMex (sorry don't know gender, I guess I could use LE convention and call TexMex "IT") at around 58s you get a view of the shoes. They actually look like Timberlands to me!
In the Porsche-fire video, on the other hand, the shoes look like dark-colored running shoes with white soles to me.
But that is not him at 58 secs in that video. at the time of his arrest, he did not have on a dark hoodie.
![]()