I think most of us agree with psychiatrist that described the parents actions as malicious and cruel and ill add traumatizing for boy and most likely the other children- they both need to be held accountable.
With that being said, there’s much that we don’t know, we’ve only heard from the Prosecution and for me personally along with others who have commented, I’m concerned with the proper care of the boy associated with claims of tendency for violent behavior and reported trauma connected to abandonment issues with his abortion. There’s really two issues here, one the parents responsibility for protection and care of a child and the other is the mental health of the boy.
The parents may argue (and fail miserably) that their actions were not as punishment but protection for the boy and other family members as well as the community in response to the risk of his violent behaviors but they obviously crossed the line with the verbal and physical abuse along with the neglect in his living conditions. There’s obviously issues regarding the parents methods of not providing support in a positive manner in fostering a loving relationship and an overall caring family environment. With us not knowing certain details of his mental health issues and the complete history of his behavior, it’s difficult to have a clear understanding of the seriousness of the risks involved. He seems extremely intelligent with his testimony during trial proceedings and some have questioned whether possibility of indication in his ability of manipulation. The fact he’s adopted shouldn’t be but it’s a factor in my mistrust of the parents’ intentions (too many foster and adoption failures, like the twins in Bakersfield CA) so it may cloud my judgment and make it more difficult to understand their actions plus the fact I’m not a parent having been unable to have a child so I lack the experience of parenting and caring for a child with mental health issues. Maybe we’ll learn more as the defense presents their case.
My posts keep getting longer and longer in this case, I hate child abuse cases.
Edit: Sorry, this was meant as a stand alone comment and not a reply to your comments, my iPhone is wacky.