GUILTY FL - Cherish Perrywinkle, 8, Jacksonville, 21 June 2013 #5 *GRAPHIC CONTENT*

[Jax49]

I have a question...

When Valerie Rao was testifying (the medical examiner) and they were showing all of those pictures of Charish's genitals... did Donald get to watch that? I just keep thinking to myself, "He is enjoying the heck out of himself right now..."

PLEASE tell me he didn't get to see those pictures.

He could have but he turned away (per tweets at the time).

ETA: I do think he enjoyed the trial. Especially the testimony of his victim from the 90's.

moo

 

[Tortoise]

I have a question...

When Valerie Rao was testifying (the medical examiner) and they were showing all of those pictures of Charish's genitals... did Donald get to watch that? I just keep thinking to myself, "He is enjoying the heck out of himself right now..."

PLEASE tell me he didn't get to see those pictures.

I read he turned his back to the monitor. Probably advised by his counsel to do so.

 

[Bravo]

It seems like ages ago we heard the horror from the M.E. To think we could possibly have a verdict by this time tomorrow.......

 

[Blef]

It seems like ages ago we heard the horror from the M.E. To think we could possibly have a verdict by this time tomorrow.......

The sooner the better. Justice is coming for you Cherish my darling

 

[Bravo]

There is a quote from one of my fave movies that keeps popping into my head. Steel Magnolias. "He is evil and must be destroyed" :facepalm:

 

[pukasonqo2]

i am looking forward to jaliek rainwalker’s moment of justice to come
for some reason, both jaliek and cherish cases got me; i am not dismissing other cases as being less worthy of justice or attention but these 2 kids got my heart in pieces


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[YESorNO]

Here are the tweets from court today:

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
3h3 hours ago
#DonaldSmith - Today is day 2 of the penalty phase. Smith's son, Donald Smith, Jr. expected to testify. The defense plans to call 7 witnesses in addition to the 4 yesterday. #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
We are missing 4 jurors so court is delayed a bit. Getting all 12 jurors and 4 alternates here on time has been a recurring issue @FCN2go #DonaldSmith

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
Defense will call a total of 5 witnesses today. Donald Smith Jr, son of #DonaldSmith, is expected to be the final witness, and will testify via Skype @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
The first defense witness today is Dr. Joseph Wu, expert in the field of neuropsychiatry #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
2h2 hours ago
First witness of the day in the #DonaldSmith trial: Joseph Wu he's the first witness of the day. Did an MRI scan of Smith's brain.

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
2h2 hours ago
Dr. Wu says an X-ray of Smith's head or brain is primitive technology -- therefore unreliable #DonaldSmith

First Coast News@FCN2go
2h2 hours ago
Dr. Wu says an MRI has a lot of newer advanced capabilities #DonaldSmith

First Coast News@FCN2go
2h2 hours ago
Dr. Wu says an EEG is 'cave man' technology. In other words, defense is using the best technology they have #DonaldSmith

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2h2 hours ago
Wu will go over 4 different types of MRI imaging. #DonaldSmith @ActionNewsJax

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
Dr Wu testifying about brain imaging abnormalities that occurred in utero as well as degenerative brain diseases that lead to "catastrophic impulse impairment." #DonaldSmith listens intently @FCN2go

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2h2 hours ago
#DonaldSmith has an “abnormal increase of white matter in his brain .”Dr. Wu says this can lead to lifelong problems in social interaction, developing human relationships, and experiencing empathy.

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
Wu is using the same scans testified to yesterday, speaking about the specific impact the findings would have on behavior #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
"They have problems with empathy" Dr Wu says of brains with excessive white matter. #DonaldSmith has almost 50 percent more than normal in one hemisphere of his brain. Found in just 6 out of 1000 ppl @FCN2go

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2h2 hours ago
Dr. Wu says people with increased white matter can become fixated on something, and can become consumed with something. Wu calls it a lifelong developmental disorder. #DonaldSmith @ActionNewsJax

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
Wu: Some of the characteristics of #DonaldSmith's brain would show a tendency to become fixated on something, which could include pedophilia. Says it is not a choice #CherishPerrywinkle

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
2h2 hours ago
Dr Joseph Wu is explaining the brain's wiring and how it relates to catastrophic impulse impairment and fixation @ #DonaldSmith

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
2h2 hours ago
#DonaldSmith looks visibly upset while Dr. Wu discusses his diminished brain capacity

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
Dr testifies that #DonaldSmith's brain has same enlarged amygdala found in neglected Romanian orphans. "Mr. Smith has a history of being emotionally neglected." His mother also suffered some "insult" while pregnant, possibly exposed to environmental toxin like #Roundup @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
Wu: #DonaldSmith's brain has characteristics that can lead to abnormal sexual preferences #CherishPerrywinkle

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2h2 hours ago
Dr. Wu says #DonaldSmith has a right side brain injury, this can result in hypersexuality or alter sexual orientation toward children. "It can cause a neurological shift toward children." @ActionNewsJax

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
Dr testifies #DonaldSmith also has right sided brain injury associated with "aberrations in sexual object preference associated with an increase in pedophilic orientation" @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
Wu: High white matter hypointensities is associated with greater degree of repetitive behavior and fixation. #DonaldSmith had abnormally high amount #CherishPerrywinkle

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2h2 hours ago
MRI diffusion tension imaging of #DonaldSmith brain. Dr. Wu says there are "areas of abnormal decreases in cables that connect right side and left side of the brain." @ActionNewsJax

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
Likelihood of someone with #DonaldSmith's FA abnormality without a brain injury is 3.8 out of 100 trillion With 12 billion people on earth, the likelihood of it occurring in another human is essentially zero. Doc says it shows evidence of significant head injury @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
Wu: Another abnormality with #DonaldSmith's brain is incredibly rare among normal brains, but common among those with traumatic brain injury #CherishPerrywinkle

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2h2 hours ago
"He has had significant injuries, when he was 20 he hit an oak tree, and flipped his car, and when he was 9 when he was riding his bike." #DonaldSmith @ActionNewsJax

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2h2 hours ago
Why are we focusing so much on traumatic brain injury? Wu says it correlates with behaviors #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
2h2 hours ago
People with Traumatic Brain Injuries likelier to show antisocial behaviors, get addicted to drugs and have impulse control, Dr Wu testifies #DonaldSmith

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
1h1 hour ago
Dr Wu is suggesting that a bike accident when #DonaldSmith was a youngster and a serious car crash in 1976 has had an impact on his brain and actions.
Traumatic Brain Injuries can damage impulse control.

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
1h1 hour ago
Wu says #DonaldSmith suffered multiple brain injuries, and it can unleash a cascade of events, with a progressive decline over time. "Brain injury can result in anti social behavior." @ActionNewsJax
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

anne schindler@schindy
1h1 hour ago
Chronic Traumatic Encephalophathy (#CTE) causes profound behavioral and cognitive deficits. This is the injury that plagues the #NFL Doc Wu says #DonaldSmith suffered bike accident at 9 that could have caused it @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
1h1 hour ago
PET scans respond to the presence of sugar. Unlike an MRI which can offer images of a cadaver or coma victim, Dr Wu says the PET requires active brain activity @FCN2go #ScienceDay #DonaldSmith

anne schindler@schindy
1h1 hour ago
Also, Dr is talking way too fast for court reporter. And me. Judge asks him to take a breath between each slide. He says he's testified before and knows he talks too fast. "I get excited," @FCN2go #DonaldSmith

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
1h1 hour ago
#DonaldSmith laughs as Dr. Wu admits he talks too fast. @ActionNewsJax

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

anne schindler@schindy
1h1 hour ago
Dr Wu says #DonaldSmith was raped by two male inmates in 1997 and molested by 2 older boys when he was a child @FCN2go

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
1h1 hour ago
Dr. Wu says #DonaldSmith was abused by his parents, he was sexually abused when he was 8. He was raped by 2 men in 1997 at the Duval County Jail. @ActionNewsJax

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
1h1 hour ago
#DonaldSmith was abused, according to Dr Wu

anne schindler@schindy
1h1 hour ago
Dr Wu conclusions: "A perfect storm of miswiring of his brain" Dr Wu testifies, along with neglect and sexual abuse led to the #DonaldSmith of today. @FCN2go @NewsShelby

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
1h1 hour ago
Wu: #DonaldSmith was at the "center of a perfect storm" of multiple brain factors and a history of trauma, which combine for a "catastrophic failure in impulse control". #CherishPerrywinkle
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
45m45 minutes ago
On cross examination, Wu confirms he is not licensed to practice medicine in Florida, but has worked on many Florida cases #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
45m45 minutes ago
Dr. Wu is being paid between $10,000 and $20,000 for his work in the #DonaldSmith case. @ActionNewsJax

anne schindler@schindy
43m43 minutes ago
"every time you’ve been retained by a defense to look at someone’s brain you've found something wrong" Prosecutor Caliel challenges Dr Wu #DonaldSmith @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
43m43 minutes ago
State: Every time you've looked at an inmate in the state of Florida, you've found something wrong? Wu: Yes, but that's because the people who seek him out generally suffer these problems. #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
40m40 minutes ago
Asst State Attorney Mark Caliel: Not everyone who suffers a traumatic brain injury suffers impulse control issues, right? Wu: yes. #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
39m39 minutes ago
“Not everyone who gets into a car accident becomes a pedophile. Not everyone who gets in a car accident becomes a drug addict." Caliel says about #DonaldSmith @FCN2go

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
35m35 minutes ago
Dr Wu is being cross examined by Mark Caliel. He is grilling him. Wu has never met Smith.
"Not everyone who gets in a car accident becomes a pedophile, correct?" Caliel asked in #DonaldSmith

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
34m34 minutes ago
Wu says he "can't directly answer" whether he knows if #DonaldSmith acted on impulse control or conscious choice the night of the murder of #CherishPerrywinkle. He hasn't spoken to Smith.

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
30m30 minutes ago
"Correct," Wu said. Wu is a neuropsychiatrist from California.
Question remains: Was #DonaldSmith decision to rape and kill Cherish a result of lack of impulse control? Does the jury care?
Life or death.

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
30m30 minutes ago
During redirect, Wu testifies that a conscious decision can be influenced by lack of impulse control because of damage. "Difficult to draw precise line", risk factors. #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
23m23 minutes ago
Doctor Joseph Sesta, a neuropsychologist, is now testifying for the defense #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
19m19 minutes ago
Neuropsychologist Dr Joseph John Sesta testifies he spent 5.3 hours examining #DonaldSmith. Says MRIs and PET scans are like "popping the hood" to examine the brain. He compares his exam to "taking the brain for a test drive" @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
12m12 minutes ago
"There is brain injury ... mild to moderate" Dr Sesta testifies #DonaldSmith "He does not have normal brain function" Smith listens. @FCN2go

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
11m11 minutes ago
Dr Sesta said #DonaldSmith was exaggerating when asked to check through a list of psychiatric complaints ( 15 minute) but was not malingering during the other 5 hours of the exam which tested his reasoning, motor function, attention skills.

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
11m11 minutes ago
Sesta: Neuroimaging validated my functional assessment of #DonaldSmith- that he had brain injury of a mild to moderate severity #CherishPerrywinkle

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
9m9 minutes ago
Dr. Sesta in courtroom testifying, "To be honest..." laughs "to be honest I'm under oath." #DonaldSmith

stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
9m9 minutes ago
Sesta does not agree with other testimony that #DonaldSmith could be suffering CTE. Not sure what caused his brain trauma, atrophy. #CherishPerrywinkle

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
8m8 minutes ago
Dr. Sesta: I tell my students, as a Neuroscientist - get used to saying, "I don't know" #DonaldSmith

anne schindler@schindy
5m5 minutes ago
"We'd expect him to be a cold emotionless person" Dr Setsta testifies #DonaldSmith @FCN2go Smith listens.

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
4m4 minutes ago
Sesta: #DonaldSmith's brain shows that behaviorally, he can step on the gas, but has problems hitting the brakes. #CherishPerrywinkle

First Coast News@FCN2go
3m3 minutes ago
Dr. Sesta At one one point we have to ask, how can someone do something like this?
"No question, #DonaldSmith does not have a normal human brain."

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
3m3 minutes ago
Sesta: #DonaldSmith knew what he was doing when he murdered #CherishPerrywinkle. People wonder how someone can do something like this to someone else- Smith's brain is not normal. Prevents him from controlling his behavior.

anne schindler@schindy
50m50 minutes ago
"The great tragedy" is that #DonaldSmith was recommended for confinement "and then he was released" says Dr Sesta @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
46m46 minutes ago
Sesta says #DonaldSmith's attempted kidnapping of a 13-year-old showed "severe difficulty in behavioral control" #CherishPerrywinkle

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
46m46 minutes ago
Dr. Sesta says #DonaldSmith showed signs of being a 'flasher' but once he meets a 13-year-old victim who refused to get in his van, he gets out and chances her
"This shows the lack of impulse control. He could not disengage in this little girl." -Sesta

anne schindler@schindy
45m45 minutes ago
"I don't know of any behavior that screams of behavior control more than chasing children down the street in broad daylight to take them back to you van" Dr Sesta testifies #DonaldSmith @FCN2go

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

anne schindler@schindy
43m43 minutes ago
"The sad part is we had him... and we let him go" Sesta testifes referencing the Jimmy Ryce confinement that #DonaldSmith was released from @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
41m41 minutes ago
Sesta described Smith chasing victim Kerri-Anne Buck down the street in 1992 "something literally out of every child's nightmare." He adds, "his pedophilia is strong" #DonaldSmith @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
38m38 minutes ago
Sesta says #DonaldSmith tried to get a book that talked about different diagnoses and symptoms, presumably to fake his own disorder- "This is what psychopaths do" #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
37m37 minutes ago
"he's real charming, he's well read, he’s well spoken" Dr Sesta testifies. #DonaldSmith "most certainly ... would be considered a psychopath" @FCN2go
----------------------------

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
31m31 minutes ago
Caliel on cross-examination: #DonaldSmith couldn't control his pedophilic urge, but he killed #CherishPerrywinkle to avoid capture. Sesta: I agree, "he's not dumb".

anne schindler@schindy
31m31 minutes ago
Sesta testifies #DonaldSmith killed Cherish because "there's no way to impose that kind of anatomical trauma to a little girl & expect it to go undetected. you cant expect to do what he did to Cherish and get away with it. the only thing he could do is take her life" @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
16m16 minutes ago
“At some point you have to ask yourself: how does one human being do this to another? And how can we sleep at night? One thing I can say is his brain is certainly not normal...there is no question that #DonaldSmith does not have a normal human brain” @FCN2go

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
5m5 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith - The penalty phase will resume at 1:15.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
5m5 minutes ago
Substantial debate right now because a juror has asked the Judge if he/she can ask a witness a question. State opposes, says can't start that this late in the proceeding. Defense supports, says jurors should have all the info they can. #DonaldSmith #CherishPerrywinkle

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
52s53 seconds ago
#DonaldSmith - Court is back in session. A jury asked if they could ask questions during this phase. The judge says yes.

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
7m7 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith - The defense calls a prison expert, James Aiken. He has worked in the prison system for over 40 years.

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
2m2 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith - The prison expert began to talk about being in charge of executions. That prompted a long sidebar and the jury has now been sent out.

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
1m1 minute ago
#DonaldSmith - The prosecution objected when the defense expert said he was involved in the Prison Rape Elimination Act.

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
35s36 seconds ago
#DonaldSmith - We heard earlier that Smith was raped previously in prison.

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
53s53 seconds ago
#DonaldSmith - Defense now asking Aiken questions without the jury present .

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
9m9 minutes ago
The jury in the #DonaldSmith case has just left the court room while attorneys and the judge hash out the testimony of James Aiken. It seems he was going to talk about what it would be like for Smith if he was among the general population -- possibly subjected to rape himself.

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
9m9 minutes ago
Aiken says #DonaldSmith's vulnerability level is high in prison, because of his age nature of the offense. @ActionNewsJax

anne schindler@schindy
8m8 minutes ago
defense witness Mr. Aiken speaking in proffer, outside of earshot of jurors. about "The convict code" and how it might affect a sex offender like #DonaldSmith "his vulnerability level is very high' .. he is a prime target"

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
7m7 minutes ago
Aiken "We have to separate him from the rest of the population.” Aiken says #DonaldSmith needs to be protected in prison, because some of the other prisoners "hate" inmates with this type of record. @ActionNewsJax

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
6m6 minutes ago
Aiken says #DonaldSmith should be separated from other inmates -- they frown on individuals with Smith's criminal background.
They call it KOS. Kill on site.

anne schindler@schindy
6m6 minutes ago
KOS -- kill on site. "this is a child killer" the lowest level and people will take you out just on that general principal, Aiken testifies @FCN2go #DonaldSmith

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
6m6 minutes ago
"His vulnerability is very high," Aiken said.
"...They frown and that is a very light word on individuals with that type of background ( pedophile/child killer)." "In terms of prison hierarchy, Smith would be among the lowest ( and most vulnerable)" #DonaldSmith

anne schindler@schindy
4m4 minutes ago
Prosecutors say it's inappropriate to introduce testimony about what might happen to #Donaldsmith in prison as mitigating @FCN2go Def attorneys say 'anything' jurors deem mitigating is mitigation

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
1m1 minute ago
Life or death for #DonaldSmith. Smith has told his mom, according to recorded jail conversations that he wants death because he is afraid of being raped if he is in the general population. A death sentence would keep Smith from the general population as he would be in isolation

Law & Crime Network @LawCrimeNetwork
5m5 minutes ago
Law & Crime Network Retweeted Jenese Harris
#DonaldSmith
Jenese Harris‏ @WJXTJenese
Donald Smith penalty phase: Judge Cooper says nothing about this testimony so far is relevant. Cooper: "I don't see how it is relevant to mitigation at all." Cooper wants a short recess and will review if the testimony is appropriate in a penalty phase. @wjxt4

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
5m5 minutes ago
Brief recess as judge considers arguments, case law on this testimony. Aiken is supposed to speak about protection #DonaldSmith would need in prison because of the nature of the offense. Question is whether that is relevant for mitigation. #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
4m4 minutes ago
Fascinating legal dispute. Def attorney wants to tell jurors about harm that could come to #DonaldSmith if he is sent to prison. Prosecutors say that's not for them to consider. Judge appears to agree but has taken a 15 minute recess to mull it over @FCN2go

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
3m3 minutes ago
Judge appears to agree with state that a jury hearing what could happen to #DonaldSmith if he is given a life term and not the death penalty is not appropriate for a jury to hear ( rape/stabbings/....) Taking a 15 minute recess while what appears to be case law is reviewed.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
2m2 minutes ago
Judge Mallory Cooper rules that Aiken's testimony will not be allowed to cover what could happen to #DonaldSmith in prison or what kind of security he would need #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
2m2 minutes ago
JUDGE: Aiken will not be allowed to testify about what might happen to #DonaldSmith in prison or what extra security would be needed to protect him from violent assault @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
2m2 minutes ago
This witness has helped implement the Prison Rape Elimination Act, which was unanimously approved by Congress under GW Bush https://www.bjs.gov/index.cfm?ty=tp&tid=20 … @FCN2go #donaldSmith

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
1m1 minute ago
Aiken reviewed criminal, and psychological history of #DonaldSmith he classifies Smith as someone who would need maximum security. @ActionNewsJax

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
1m1 minute ago
Aiken is testifying as an expert in prison security and classification. Has reviewed #DonaldSmith's criminal history, socialization. #CherishPerrywinkle

First Coast News@FCN2go
59s59 seconds ago
Aiken: The older the inmate is, the more vulnerable the inmate becomes #DonaldSmith

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
1m1 minute ago
Aiken would classify #DonaldSmith as needing a high security prison setting, but a low risk to other inmates and staff because of his age and previous incarceration history #CherishPerrywinkle

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
3m3 minutes ago
Mr Aiken was allowed to testify that #DonaldSmith would not be a threat to other inmates or staff if sentenced to a life behind bars. *That's it
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

anne schindler@schindy
3m3 minutes ago
Aiken is excused and Brooke Butler, mitigation specialist is up. She is expected to testify about #DonaldSmith's childhood and history @FCN2go

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
1m1 minute ago
#DonaldSmith - Mitigation specialist, Dr. Brooke Butler now up for the defense.

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
1m1 minute ago
Brooke Butler a mitigation specialist has just taken the stand. She is a mitigation specialist and helped the defense team of #DonaldSmith pick the jury that 1) found Smith guilty of killing Cherish and now 2) will decide life or death

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
1m1 minute ago
Dr. Brooke Butler is next to take the stand. Became involved in the case back in 2014 -- she's a mitigation specialist #DonaldSmith

First Coast News@FCN2go
4m4 minutes ago
Butler received her degrees from UNF
She is not licensed in the state of Florida, because her field does not do that
#DonaldSmith

First Coast News@FCN2go
1m1 minute ago
Mitigation specialist is a member of the defense team that is responsible for researching the biological factors that can impact the way a client perceives the world, makes decisions etc... #DonaldSmith

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
55s55 seconds ago
Butler spent a lot of time with #DonaldSmith meeting with him for over 100 hours. @ActionNewsJax

anne schindler@schindy
2m2 minutes ago
Brooke Butler says it's her job to synthesize #DonaldSmith's life "in order to create or narrate" his life history. "it's never to provide an explanation for their behavior,
it’s never to provide excuses, it's never to provide justification" @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
50s51 seconds ago
"Don" is what Brooke Butler says she and other that know him call #DonaldSmith @FCN2go

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
1m1 minute ago
#DonaldSmith - Part of Dr. Butler's job is to speak with as many family members/friends as she can. She said she had a difficult time with this case. Mother passed away, father has dementia. She attempted to reach approx 50 people.

anne schindler@schindy
2m2 minutes ago
"His guilt was incontrovertible. We knew he was never going to contest whether he was guilty" Butler says of #DonaldSmith @FCN2go She says she reviewed DCF records, school records and did in person interviews with family

Jenese Harris@WJXTJenese
1m1 minute ago
#DonaldSmith penalty phase: Dr Brooke Butler says she spend over 100 hours working with Smith, researched and interviewed people who knew Smith. Butler says Smith never denied killing Cherish. @wjxt4
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[alexwood]

Thank you, YESorNO for all the updates to today's session.

 

[YESorNO]

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
43s43 seconds ago
Dr. Butler interviewed several of #DonaldSmith's family members; including father in Ga and his son, Donald Smith Jr.

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
3m3 minutes ago
As part of her research, Butler interviewed #DonaldSmith's biological father in GA, a half-sister he hadn't met, his son, former childhood friends, and more. Went through wide range of records #CherishPerrywinkle

Meilin Tompkins@MeilinTompkins
2m2 minutes ago
Expert witness was asked to NOT call #DonaldSmith "Don"

anne schindler@schindy
2m2 minutes ago
Dr Butler was just told not to refer to defendant as "Don." She says #DonaldSmith was a preemie, his mother was 17 years old, his father was 18. "They were teenage sweethearts" @FCN2go

First Coast News@FCN2go
51s52 seconds ago
#DonaldSmith's biological father was 18 years old when Smith was born.
Smith's mother did not receive proper pre-natal care.

First Coast News@FCN2go
34s35 seconds ago
Expert witness will refer to #DonaldSmith's mother as Mrs. Moore
Says his mother's family would live above their means.

anne schindler@schindy
1m1 minute ago
#DonaldSmith's childhood "was abusive, emotionally devoid of affection" Brooke Butler testifies @FCN2go

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
43s43 seconds ago
#DonaldSmith did not know his biological father until he was 9. @ActionNewsJax

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
1m1 minute ago
Butler: #DonaldSmith's early years were in a home that "was abusive, emotionally devoid of affection". Smith didn't know who his father was until he was 9y/o, thought his grandfather was his father for awhile. Didn't meet his father until he was 49y/o #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
1m1 minute ago
"His first memory is of being taken from his grandparents home grabbing at the doorframe trying to stay there" Brooke Butler testifies #DonaldSmith @FCN2go

anne schindler@schindy
3m3 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith "experienced a lot of verbal abuse physical abuse" Brooke Butler testifies. One time he locked Smith out of a hotel room, would push him away. His adoptive father "terrified" him & said things that were sexually inappropriate @FCN2go

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
3m3 minutes ago
Butler: #DonaldSmith's first step father was physically and verbally abusive, provided financially but not emotionally, was jealous of bond between Smith and his mother #CherishPerrywinkle

Law & Crime Network@LawCrimeNetwork
2m2 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith - Smith appears to be having the first noticeable signs of emotion as the mitigation specialist talks about his abusive childhood.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

[YESorNO]

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
5m5 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith looking pretty uncomfortable as Brooke Butler talks about his early years. He was friendless, and his step-dad was abusive, she said.

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
4m4 minutes ago
#DonaldSmith very fidgety while Butler testifies about Smith's childhood. She says he "Never fit in." @ActionNewsJax

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
4m4 minutes ago
Butler: #DonaldSmith moved a lot because of his stepfather's work. Was "always the new kid", often bullied. #CherishPerrywinkle

anne schindler@schindy
2m2 minutes ago
Smith was sexually molested by 2 neighborhood boys and witnessed them molesting other girls. He was wetting the bed, stopped eating, grew anxious Butler testifies. He soon began having access to drugs. Smith seems intently focused on this testimony @FCN2go #DonaldSmith

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
2m2 minutes ago
Butler says #DonaldSmith experimented with several drugs at a younger age including cocaine. @ActionNewsJax

Stephanie Brown@SBrownReports
1m1 minute ago
Butler: #DonaldSmith's mother divorced, they moved to Jacksonville, she married a psychiatrist. Smith "began to access those medications". Later expanded to cocaine, LSD, and many others #CherishPerrywinkle

Bridgette Matter@bridgetteANjax
49s49 seconds ago
#DonaldSmith was admitted to Shands for cocaine poisoning. @ActionNewsJax

Eileen Kelley@reporterkell
3m3 minutes ago
Brooke Butler said #DonaldSmith was sexually molested by 2 neighborhood boys when he was young. She said he began to self medicate with his a step dad's psychiatric drugs ( his mom was married 3 times by the time he was pre teen). He then went on to drink, smoke pot do PCP
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------