But in front of a jury Wednesday during his family members’ trial, a shackled and soft-spoken Nicholas Rivera testified only about seeing his father hosing off a cart outside hours after Montalvo had gone missing on Oct. 21, 2019.
Prosecutors say Montalvo’s DNA was found on the cart. Jurors, though, didn’t hear about Nicholas Rivera’s earlier claim, which had been
undermined by a DNA report that determined blood found on the garage floor did not belong to Montalvo or her husband.
Once a person of interest in Montalvo’s killing, Nicholas Rivera is currently incarcerated, facing a decade in prison after taking a plea deal in August on multiple child *advertiser censored*-related charges.
Angel Rivera’s attorney asked Nicholas Rivera on the witness stand if he saw what his father was washing off the cart.
“No, I did not,” he responded.
The jury heard testimony Wednesday from several witnesses at the Osceola courthouse in the trial against Otero-Rivera, 33, and his 64-year-old father, Angel Rivera.
Both men, who have pleaded not guilty, are charged with second-degree murder, abuse of a body and evidence tampering in Montalvo’s death. Prosecutors have argued Montalvo’s husband and father-in-law wanted to make her “disappear” because they desired custody of the couple’s shared son.
In an audio recording heard by jurors, Otero-Rivera told a detective he didn’t know why his estranged wife would suddenly leave their son in the care of Otero-Rivera’s parents.
“I just don’t understand why she would do that … and to leave her son?” Otero-Rivera said to Osceola County Sheriff’s Office Det. Cole Miller on the recording.
Brother-in-law testifies at trial for killing of Nicole Montalvo