Gerard Baden Clay's murder appeal

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

New Posts

Status
Not open for further replies.
He had motive (so much motive), opportunity - and he hid the body. He lied about his actions. If it was a genuine accidental death, he could have called the police and faced the music. He wouldn't be any worse off than he is now!!
 
Leonie Mellor Verified account ‏@leoniemellor now1 minute ago

1/2 Justice Keane to defence: "A mere confrontation with his wife that doesn't result in her death ..."2/2Justice Keane to defence: "... doesn't get him out of the corner he has painted himself into." #badenclay @abcnews
 
How do we think this going so far? The defence seemed to get hammered - or is that to be expected?
 
Marlina Whop Verified account ‏@MarlinaWhop now50 seconds ago

BREAKING
High Court reserves decision @katrinablowers #Badenclay @7NewsQueensland

David Murray Verified account ‏@TheMurrayD now55 seconds ago

Court reserves its decision #badencla
 
If there was any sense, they'd be back in 10 minutes telling GBC to enjoy the rest of his MURDER sentence.
 
ADJOURNED TILL TOMOROW

Leonie Mellor Verified account ‏@leoniemellor now1 minute ago

#badenclay #HighCourt appeal adjourned til tomorrow for pronouncement of orders. Decision reserved. @abcnews

:crossfingers:
 
High Court case over

The Court has reserved its decision on whether to re-instate Baden-Clay's murder conviction.

Baden-Clay's defence barrister closed his case after being peppered with questions about his client's evidence at trial.

Baden-Clay denied having anything to do with Allison's death at trial.

Justice Keane continually pointed out Baden-Clay's evidence was "inconsistent with the hypothesis of innocence of murder".

"Only an altercation that results in her death solves his problem," he said.

Justice Virginia Bell asked why it was not open to the jury to consider that the lies Baden-Clay told on the stand about the scratches on his face and his conduct afterwards were inconsistent with an accidental death. - Melanie Petrinec@MelaniePetrinic
 
Fantastic reporting, Fuskier. Thank you so much!!

:tyou::tyou::tyou:
 
Fuskier said:
Kim Stephens ‏@kimbo_stephens now33 seconds ago

"It's not open for the defence to raise at appeal some other factual basis that was expressly denied at trial": Sofronoff #badenclay
Click to expand...

This is the crux of it, for me!!! Spot on.
 
What actually happens tomorrow? How do you guys think this went? God I hope it is reinstated.
 
I thought there would not be an outcome from this until Christmas. It might be an easy one to wrap up. I think there is something weird going on with the wigs at Queensland Law. The new, outspoken leader of the Law Society is Bill Potts. He used to take on all the unsavoury people to defend - druggos, weapons etc, when he was here on the Gold Coast. He spoke out in support of the 3 judges who lowered the charge to manslaughter. This worries me. If this goes pear-shaped this time, I think I will start up a petition to the Minister.
 
Allison Baden-Clay's sister says the family remains determined to "achieve justice" and has been overwhelmed by community support.


Vanessa Fowler said the process continued to be a "very long and challenging road" but she thanked the High Court for hearing the case and the Department of Public Prosecution for its tireless work.


"Together, we will now await an outcome," she said, outside court.


"Since the decision of the appeals court to overturn the murder conviction last year, we have been overwhelmed by the incredible support we have witnessed for Allison and our family.


"It continues to be a very long and challenging road, however we, Allison's family and friends, are determined to achieve justice for Allison."
 
Fuskier said:
Thanks BreakingNews. Can you expand on the name of those witnesses for us WS please?
Click to expand...

Witnesses were Nigel BC father; Olivia sister; of our course the biggest actor of all time GBC starred as himself. It was just so weird that Nigel and Olivia used the exact same words to describe certain aspects. But the best witness of all was dear Mrs Dickey. She made reference to what the BC family were really like. "Oh, they once invited us for afternoon tea. We had to sit outside on the footpath. That's the only time we socialised with them." She was so open, honest and honourable. We cheered at the end of her testimony, but of course we later got into trouble for it. She deserved a standing ovation. GBC probably deserved a standing ovation also, but for very different reasons. His testimony didn't help his cause at all. When talking about himself he could go on and on and on. But as soon as Allison's name was mentioned he'd bow his head and simply say as few words as possible. He hardly even called her by name. He referred to her as 'my wife'. Just like 'my car'. Another chattel.
 
Fuskier said:
You're welcome Oz Jen. :grouphug:to all here today.

:crossfingers: till tomorow.
Click to expand...

Thank you, Fusky.
Cautiously hopeful. At least all the right questions were being asked.
[emoji258]
 
BreakingNews said:
I thought there would not be an outcome from this until Christmas. It might be an easy one to wrap up. I think there is something weird going on with the wigs at Queensland Law. The new, outspoken leader of the Law Society is Bill Potts. He used to take on all the unsavoury people to defend - druggos, weapons etc, when he was here on the Gold Coast. He spoke out in support of the 3 judges who lowered the charge to manslaughter. This worries me. If this goes pear-shaped this time, I think I will start up a petition to the Minister.
Click to expand...

Let's hope the High Court puts these frisky upstarts right back in their boxes, Breaking!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

DNASolves

Who is Escambia County John Doe (1989)?

Members online

... and 143 more.
Total: 1,356 (members: 144, guests: 1,212)

Online statistics

Members online
144
Guests online
1,212
Total visitors
1,356
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
599,299
Messages
18,094,101
Members
230,841
Latest member
FastRayne
Back
Top