Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023 #4

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Anyone have any thoughts on The Killing Season documentary/Episode 3/timestamp 12:24?
If this was already discussed, please ignore me.
I don't hear the lisp at all. I wonder when RH lost those teeth.
Which one is it?
"The Killing Season" is an immersive series that follows documentarians Joshua Zeman and Rachel Mills as they investigate one of the most bizarre unsolved serial killer cases of our time: the deaths of 10 sex workers discovered on Gilgo Beach, Long Island.
 
Last edited:
Dr. Johanna Ellerup, Heuermann’s sister-in-law, seemed to put the blame on herself as she grappled with reality in an interview with NBC News.

“My ego has great difficulty processing the idea that I looked Rex in the eye and was unable to discern any murderous intentions,” Ellerup said.

“I vacillate between desperately wanting my niece and nephew’s life returned to its previous state, intact, without a father accused of being a serial killer, to being pleased and secure in knowing that someone is in custody.”
 
Which one is it?
"The Killing Season" is an immersive series that follows documentarians Joshua Zeman and Rachel Mills as they investigate one of the most bizarre unsolved serial killer cases of our time: the deaths of 10 sex workers discovered on Gilgo Beach, Long Island.
actually i can access it, thanks. Mountain Lion linked an episode yesterday.. Gonna go feast now. Thanks for reminding me
 
Dr. Johanna Ellerup, Heuermann’s sister-in-law, seemed to put the blame on herself as she grappled with reality in an interview with NBC News.
What ridiculous and insensitive reporting.

I don't think she was blaming herself for what he allegedly did.
He seemed to have everyone fooled.

She is not resonsible for what he did.
 
it may have just taken him a day to kill and dispose of each woman. His family was absent for a longer period of time.
How did he spend the rest of that time and did he travel at all during her absence?
 
News reports on Heuermann’s arrest brought back memories for former Erie County Undersheriff Richard T. Donovan and his former administrative assistant, Marilynn Calhoun-Allen.

In interviews with The Buffalo News, they both recalled the anguished calls they received in 2009 from Lynn Barthelemy, the missing woman’s mother, after her daughter vanished.

Lynn Barthelemy was “extremely upset, very frustrated” and convinced that something terrible had happened to her daughter, but she said police agencies were skeptical because her daughter had worked as a prostitute, Donovan recalled.

“She told me she had called the New York City police and other police agencies and nobody would take her seriously. Nobody would even take a missing person’s report,” Calhoun-Allen said. “I told her, my boss was out to lunch, and that he’d call her when he got back. She said, ‘No, he won’t. Nobody calls me back.’ I told her, ‘He will.’ ”

Barthelemy’s mother was “crying and sobbing, and it really hurt me to hear that,” Calhoun-Allen said. “I’m a mom, too, and I could only try to imagine what she was going through.”

Attorney Steven M. Cohen, who represented the Barthelemy family, told The News in 2011 that New York City police had a policy at the time of not investigating missing persons for 10 days and that because Barthelemy worked as a “hooker,” detectives would not be assigned to the case.

Donovan remembers talking to Barthelemy’s mother and quickly realizing that her fears were genuine. “I was our liaison with NYPD and I had some friends in their Intelligence Unit,” the retired undersheriff said. “I called them, and to their credit, they took it very seriously, and immediately contacted the mother.”
 
News reports on Heuermann’s arrest brought back memories for former Erie County Undersheriff Richard T. Donovan and his former administrative assistant, Marilynn Calhoun-Allen.

In interviews with The Buffalo News, they both recalled the anguished calls they received in 2009 from Lynn Barthelemy, the missing woman’s mother, after her daughter vanished.

Lynn Barthelemy was “extremely upset, very frustrated” and convinced that something terrible had happened to her daughter, but she said police agencies were skeptical because her daughter had worked as a prostitute, Donovan recalled.

“She told me she had called the New York City police and other police agencies and nobody would take her seriously. Nobody would even take a missing person’s report,” Calhoun-Allen said. “I told her, my boss was out to lunch, and that he’d call her when he got back. She said, ‘No, he won’t. Nobody calls me back.’ I told her, ‘He will.’ ”

Barthelemy’s mother was “crying and sobbing, and it really hurt me to hear that,” Calhoun-Allen said. “I’m a mom, too, and I could only try to imagine what she was going through.”

Attorney Steven M. Cohen, who represented the Barthelemy family, told The News in 2011 that New York City police had a policy at the time of not investigating missing persons for 10 days and that because Barthelemy worked as a “hooker,” detectives would not be assigned to the case.

Donovan remembers talking to Barthelemy’s mother and quickly realizing that her fears were genuine. “I was our liaison with NYPD and I had some friends in their Intelligence Unit,” the retired undersheriff said. “I called them, and to their credit, they took it very seriously, and immediately contacted the mother.”
That makes me so sad that she said, "Nobody calls me back." Man, that is simply heartbreaking she experienced that reality in her time of need.

jmo
 
Ray said: "There exists, of course, the real question of whether or not he's killed others that are undiscovered."

There would have been no motive to stop killing in 2010, Ray said.

"There was nobody after him that he knew of," he said. "So between 2010 and now he wasn't aware of anybody chasing him where he would have to hide[…] all he had to do was stay away from the Gilgo Beach area once the police became involved and dump his bodies elsewhere."

Heuermann "should be on the radar as for the others, and as for anybody else that might have disappeared," Ray said. "That's fairly clear. That's why the police seem to be going to the other locations and looking about in the other locations on his property that he owns."

"Here we have, they're all sex workers, they all have virtually the same appearance, they could be sisters of one another," he said. "And they're found like an extended cemetery along Ocean Parkway. Shannan's on one side of the road, the others are on the other."
 
News reports on Heuermann’s arrest brought back memories for former Erie County Undersheriff Richard T. Donovan and his former administrative assistant, Marilynn Calhoun-Allen.

In interviews with The Buffalo News, they both recalled the anguished calls they received in 2009 from Lynn Barthelemy, the missing woman’s mother, after her daughter vanished.

Lynn Barthelemy was “extremely upset, very frustrated” and convinced that something terrible had happened to her daughter, but she said police agencies were skeptical because her daughter had worked as a prostitute, Donovan recalled.

“She told me she had called the New York City police and other police agencies and nobody would take her seriously. Nobody would even take a missing person’s report,” Calhoun-Allen said. “I told her, my boss was out to lunch, and that he’d call her when he got back. She said, ‘No, he won’t. Nobody calls me back.’ I told her, ‘He will.’ ”

Barthelemy’s mother was “crying and sobbing, and it really hurt me to hear that,” Calhoun-Allen said. “I’m a mom, too, and I could only try to imagine what she was going through.”

Attorney Steven M. Cohen, who represented the Barthelemy family, told The News in 2011 that New York City police had a policy at the time of not investigating missing persons for 10 days and that because Barthelemy worked as a “hooker,” detectives would not be assigned to the case.

Donovan remembers talking to Barthelemy’s mother and quickly realizing that her fears were genuine. “I was our liaison with NYPD and I had some friends in their Intelligence Unit,” the retired undersheriff said. “I called them, and to their credit, they took it very seriously, and immediately contacted the mother.”
He probably visited the girls' home towns after they were murdered and watched their relatives suffer imo
 
I’ve been searching around. I’m startled at the number of serial killers not yet caught…


I don’t think this one and the other women linked have been solved either: *edited to ask if Rex was ever near Waterbury, CT, where all these women were from:
 
Last edited:
I’d bet that they were in his search history as well whether they are in fact his victims or not.

I think LE is being super tight-lipped and not releasing the majority of his search history for good reason. Exactly what that reason is, I don’t know, but they are playing their hand close and so far, they seem to really know what they’re doing. As much as I’m absolutely chomping at the bit for more info, I know it’ll come out when the time is right.
I am sure there is a lot of information that has not been released such as the reason a medical examiner was at the storage unit they searched. Also, I really wonder what the photographs were of that were shown to the wife to cause her to say, “It is what it is.”
 
I am sure there is a lot of information that has not been released such as the reason a medical examiner was at the storage unit they searched. Also, I really wonder what the photographs were of that were shown to the wife to cause her to say, “It is what it is.”
I've been thinking about that too. I wonder if it is a simple as photos of him being arrested on 5th Ave. Another officer could've texted the officers at the house to show the arrest was completed, and they showed the wife.

jmo
 
I just go based off of facts we have gotten from law enforcement. No other suspects have been announced. The only person claiming they believe another party (a female in fact) was involved is I believe the attorney for Shannon Gilbert and Jessica Taylor's families, which I am aware it is probably an unpopular opinion, however those murders have not been tied to RH at this point in time. Only 3 and possibly a 4th murder are tied to RH at this point.

So my unpopular (probably very unpopular) opinion is that I do not understand why people keep trying to tie other suspects into this when the facts we have received so far point to a lone serial killer. Is it just because some people have felt they had a "suspect" early on and don't want to let go of their suspicions of that person?
Maybe because so far, RH has only been charged with 3 of the murders. Add that to the fact that from very early on in this case to current, officials in LI and professors of psychology have yet to settle on one vs more than one killer in this case. You argue that you follow the facts but so far there is no evidence to link the remaining bodies to the gb4 except location. I for one, do not believe the remaining victims are his. They could however belong to an already caught SK that was also working in the area.
 
Police investigating the Gilgo Beach murders, 2010
Screenshot-2023-07-21-161232.png

At a time when Americans are drowning in cynicism and low expectations, local, state, and federal officials worked together to go after a “demon” — as Harrison called him — who apparently thought that because his victims were “escorts,” he could get away with it. He didn’t count on the good guys. He didn’t even know they were there.
 
Gilgo Beach is where the young vulnerable girls were left, raped, tortured, and dead. But where did he do this to them?????? Not on that beach. In his house????? No one could hear screams? How’d he get them all to his house? At hotels? He must have been a mess leaving. Does anyone know? Thanks. I love the research abilities some of you have, truly amazing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
142
Guests online
1,631
Total visitors
1,773

Forum statistics

Threads
602,893
Messages
18,148,572
Members
231,580
Latest member
noizewarr
Back
Top