If you agree or disagree with the verdict, let us know why

[imagirlgeek]

She did actually work at Universal up until shortly after Caylee's birth. I believe she lied about the nanny so she didn't have to leave Caylee with George. And, she was living at home up until the death, then she left the home she lived at for most of her life. She left her parents with no warning. I think that's a different behavior then the past.

Yes, but she never went back, and she told everyone she had. She got up and got dressed, wore a badge with her picture on it from Universal, and pretended to have this job. She invited her friends to events on several occasions in order to perpetuate the lie and make it believable, but it always fell through because the events were always 'sold out' which made it impossible for her to get them in. When questioned by friends about not being at work, she lied and said she had the flexibility to work from home, that her work was emailed to her. She even made up a lie about going to school to get a certificate in Event Coordinating to make it more believable.

She made up a lie about having a Nanny because her friend, Lauren, who had been watching Caylee for free, found out she had been using her for free babysitting so she could go hang out with friends. After that, Jesse Grund watched her 1 day a week and his mom watched her another 2 days a week, but that was supposed to be temporary and they were putting pressure on her to find someone permanent. And then 'Zanny' was created.

She left home because GA and CA would absolutely question where Caylee was, not to mention she was staying with Tony. She sure couldn't claim to be out of town for work if she was still at home. And she couldn't claim to be in Jacksonville if she was hanging out at the house. She always had an excuse for why she wasn't coming home and why Caylee couldn't talk to her grandparents. And if she wasn't in all those places she told her mother she was, there would be no excuse for Caylee not to be with her.

She lied about graduating high school, up until a few days before the ceremony, when she HAD to tell her mom that she didn't have enough credits. She lied about being pregnant until it was so obvious to everyone that she was, and absolutely couldn't get away with it anymore.

I really could go on and on, listing out the lies that came out of this girl's mouth, but I'll stop here for now. At the end of the day, KC lied everytime she screwed up, and she lied a lot of the time when she hadn't screwed up...before, during, and after Caylee died.

 

[WillChgo]

You still have not proven that although all these people had access to that stuff, it was only Casey that did it.

We've already learned that lying does not equal guilt.

The additional evidence that Casey did it was that Caylee's decomposing body was in Casey's car.

 

[dvdman]

Like the prosecution stated she had the motive and would be the only one who gained something from her death. What did her mother,father or brother have to gain from Caylee's death? They were all heartbroken. It doesn't make sense. Oh and please don't tell me she was good mother. We all know that we try to look and act our BEST in pictures and videos so her playing with Caylee or smiling means nothing.

You still have not proven that although all these people had access to that stuff, it was only Casey that did it.

We've already learned that lying does not equal guilt.

 

[kidz110]

All the items found at the crimes scene, the garbage bags, the laundry bag, and the now INFAMOUS duct tape were all be traced back to the Anthony's house..
Casey wasn't the only one to have access to all them.
Four people had access to all those items.
TWO had better access because they knew where the key to the locked shed was kept, which was where George kept the duct tape.

George and Cindy had access and also knew where the shed key was kept hidden FROM CASEY.
Lee had access all the items except the duct tape.
Casey had access to all the items except the duct tape.

Casey was able to break into the shed...that's how she stole the gas cans and that's how she had access to the duct tape.

But, according to testimony, FICA was the only one with access to the car during that time frame and the last person seen with an alive Caylee.

 

[cityslick]

Well here's the problem - we don't have to prove it, and neither did the state. You've just proven one of our major objections as to how this jury came to their verdict.

We have to use common sense to discover who had the need for it. Who out of GA, CA and FCA was most likely to tell a lie, not face the responsibility of Caylee's death, regardless of murder or accident. Who was Caylee's only legal guardian, and had sole responsibility for her welfare? Who had a history of habitual lying and habitual history of not providing care for Caylee out of the three? And who was most likely to not make the 911 call? And whose behavior drastically changed immediately after Caylee died? Hmmmm....I wonder....:waitasec:...

I disagree, you have to prove that it was Casey that murdered her daughter at the exclusion of everyone else. That is the way the law works, you may not like it but there it is. You do actually have to prove that Casey is responsible for killing her daughter. Saying 'well, because she lied about all this stuff' doesn't cut it in a court of law.

 

[logicalgirl]

I meant "working" in a sarcastic way when mentioning FCA. She told her parents she was still "working" at Universal.

Right....got it! I just read some so much "misinformation" in this thread I automatically responded. Apologies....

 

[eleni777]

Well I don't think they ever thought in their worst nightmare she was capable of harming her own daughter. I'm sure they waited as long as possible before calling the authorities knowing that was they did she was going to be in trouble for lying. In her parents are only guilty of covering for her more then they probably should have and I'm sure that eats at them everyday.

hmmmm,
Lee's question to Casey in one of their conversations:

"Is this like last time?"

He knew. They ALL knew what she was capable of.

jmo

 

[cityslick]

The additional evidence that Casey did it was that Caylee's decomposing body was in Casey's car.

And you proved that Casey was the only one who could of done that because she only had access to the car, correct?

 

[logicalgirl]

I disagree, you have to prove that it was Casey that murdered her daughter at the exclusion of everyone else. That is the way the law works, you may not like it but there it is. You do actually have to prove that Casey is responsible for killing her daughter. Saying 'well, because she lied about all this stuff' doesn't cut it in a court of law.

Lies? a NG verdict based only on her lies? To base a verdict on? I was expecting the jury to use the same common sense the Peterson jury did.

Oh I understand both the law and the scientific evidence and I am also able to use reason.....

No worries, those who believed in CFCA's innocence got their verdict..

 

[annalia]

I disagree, you have to prove that it was Casey that murdered her daughter at the exclusion of everyone else. That is the way the law works, you may not like it but there it is. You do actually have to prove that Casey is responsible for killing her daughter. Saying 'well, because she lied about all this stuff' doesn't cut it in a court of law.

My bolding

Yes it does, when you add it together with everything else. It's being able to put it all together, which this jury wasn't willing to do, they wanted a CSI or Law and Order moment all neatly tied up on a bow for them. Everyone else was excluded, except for the imaginary theories thrown out as evidence by the DT that the jury bought without anything to support it. I think they would have bought aliens coming down as reasonable doubt.

Suspects actions and lies always factor in. Maybe not murder 1 but definitely guilty of at least one of the lesser charges.

JMHO

 

[Leah0107]

I don't remember any evidence that supported 'anyone' else being responsible for Caylee's death. Everyone's access to evidence, as well as actions, attitude and behavior surrounding the death was taken into account and nothing pointed to anyone but FCA. And had she been innocent she most certainly had plenty of time to point the finger at someone other than herself and her imaginary nanny.

 

[onewick]

She did actually work at Universal up until shortly after Caylee's birth. I believe she lied about the nanny so she didn't have to leave Caylee with George. And, she was living at home up until the death, then she left the home she lived at for most of her life. She left her parents with no warning. I think that's a different behavior then the past.

So this scenario is.... She lied so she didn't have to leave Caylee with GA?? I have a relative easy fix for that:

Actually work, get out of the molestor's home and take care & responsibility for her child!!!

 

[Leah0107]

1st. There was no evidence that I recall that said that she made didn't want to leave Caylee with George.

2nd. Could be that she didn't return home after Caylee died cause, umm' she couldn't explain why here daughter wasn't with her. Sounds far-fetched I know, but work with me here.

 

[onewick]

Actually, the judge allowed evidence into trial supporting the drowning, which I have posted a few times in this thread.

My suspicions of GA are actually based on facts, it is a fact that he has lied throughout this whole investigation. It is a fact that he has been evasive on somethings and very forthcoming on other things.

And, I disagree that a majority of my posts are based on opinions or theories. In fact, I've posted many links to back up what evidence I was pointing out (or links to show other post's evidence, etc).

Please list the lies GA told throughout the investigation.
Please list Casey's (the mother of this innocent child, I might add) lies throughout.

Then let's compare????

 

[MsMacGyver]

I believe that if in a mock trial a man would have been tried the jury would have convicted.
ie: Scott Peterson trial..Lacy and Connor murder...where, when, how?

 

[cityslick]

Please list the lies GA told throughout the investigation.
Please list Casey's (the mother of this innocent child, I might add) lies throughout.

Then let's compare????

Do you think GA is the only one that ever told the truth in the family? Why do you think that?

 

[kelian36]

Like the prosecution stated she had the motive and would be the only one who gained something from her death. What did her mother,father or brother have to gain from Caylee's death? They were all heartbroken. It doesn't make sense. Oh and please don't tell me she was good mother. We all know that we try to look and act our BEST in pictures and videos so her playing with Caylee or smiling means nothing.

Common sense imo, dvdman. :seeya:

 

[kelian36]

Do you think GA is the only one that ever told the truth in the family? Why do you think that?

Maybe-----------
Cause LA and CA lied on the stand. :waitasec:

 

[kelian36]

JB was nitpicking at trivial things to make it seem GA was lying on purpose. As I said before, I challenge anyone to go back 2 years and remember everything that was happening in a very traumatic setting. I bet 99% of you can't and if you could remember some detail, it might not be consistent to what actually happened 2 years ago.

If GA would have said I had black underwear on during his depo and at trial he changed his answer to red, does that make him a liar ? Or someone who thinks he remembers, but really doesn't.

I hope, someday, George hires a good lawyer and sues baez for defamation of character and libel.

 

[kelian36]

I disagree, you have to prove that it was Casey that murdered her daughter at the exclusion of everyone else. That is the way the law works, you may not like it but there it is. You do actually have to prove that Casey is responsible for killing her daughter. Saying 'well, because she lied about all this stuff' doesn't cut it in a court of law.

For the umteenthousandth time, the state proved their case. The jurors were inept and either ignored the choices they had or didn't understand the choices they had. The jurors wanted to do home...it was 4th of July weekend.
THAT JURY DID NOT CARE ABOUT A PROPER VERDICT. NOR DID THEY CARE THAT CAYLEE GOT JUSTICE.