SimplyCass
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2020
- Messages
- 1,157
- Reaction score
- 8,388
Yeah, there are just things here and there about this case that makes it seem more like foul play for me. While plates off cars do get stolen sometimes (so I've heard), who would be traipsing through a narrow forested area that's right next to a YMCA? And they just happened upon a vehicle and just happened to also be a plate thief? And if it seems like a clear-cut case of self-harm, why is the FBI involved and asking for tips? If it was self-harm, why not go to nearby Starved Rock, a 15-minute drive away (which I'm sorry to say I've heard is a somewhat popular self-harm spot because of its beautiful, quiet nature with the same river running by it)? Why bother changing out of his clothes?
Maybe someone can verify this for me, but I've heard that most self-harm attempts tend to be really impulsive and rash. While well-thought out attempts do happen, they are more rare. Wouldn't it be really strange for Jelani to drive for an hour, hide his car, take off his plates, dispose of them, change out of his clothes, and walk 25 minutes to the river? That is a lot of thought and a long time that doesn't add up to what commonly happens. I could be wrong, please correct me if I am!
No, you're right. Jumping from a bridge is an extremely impulsive decision and people who survive jumps have said that they regretted it the instant that they jumped. According to this 2003 NYT article, some potential jumpers from the Brooklyn Bridge had changed their minds by the time they got there (due to traffic).
However, foul play seems really unlikely as well. I've always focused on the fact that there was no reported pings or electronic footprint from JJ after the dispensary. I have not known/seen a case of foul play where the phone was turned off like that.
Robbery seems an unlikely motive since dispensaries only allow 1 oz. to be bought (and the dispensary itself would be much more attractive to rob).
Carjacking seems unlikely because the car was left in a wooded area not really that far away. Because of the missing plates, I mentioned the Toni Sharpless case - but in that case, an anonymous letter writer claimed he/she had been paid $5,000 to drive Toni's car to a chop shop and was allowed to keep the plates. The plates are missing, but the car was abandoned, not at a chop shop or anything.
In the absence of other evidence I am (reluctantly) inclined to believe self harm than foul play.