Really? why does there profession come into play when you are giving them access to your records? Drs, nurses, and lawyers can sign the form as a friend not as their job role. If they aren't your Dr, Nurse, or lawyer that confidentiality shouldn't apply. It should just be the HIPAA. Example, my cousin is a lawyer. If I delegated, she wouldn't have keep things in confidence because there is no client/attorney privilege. Just like dr/patient confidentiality. Maybe I misunderstood you.
That is where in the beginning that would be a question of what is the legal culpability. It may be cleared up now and I won't pretend to know for sure. When it was first put into place if I said a patient has a wife who is a nurse and signs permission for her to have access to his medical records, the question was there.....that person was legally under HIPAA but were they with a relative. Doesn't apply here regardless but a good question if that got fixed and answered.
Kind of the we have to pass the law to see how it works.
IMO. Think we are going off course and I guess I steered it that way. Will just say if wife made a statement about his mental health, in this case I would take with a couple pounds of salt.