KY KY - Shively, WhtFem 20-40, UP74, distinctive narrow nose, Jul'05

[MadMcGoo]

Possible Matches:

1. Mary Jane Croft VanGilder, Mary Jane, Mary Jane
2. Lea Anna Allen (DLC is September 1980 per a family member)
3. Stacey Lynn Balas
4. Vicky Lynn Vukelich (Courtesy of Melt71)

Another one added to the list of exclusions, bringing the total to 93 (including the duplicates)

MP1987 Amber Cates 04/11/2004 Maury TN
MP6161 Amy Haueter 01/15/2005 Jefferson KY
MP11194 Angelia Hilbert 06/03/1989 Jefferson KY
MP38062 Barbara Wooden 10/23/1998 Hamilton TN
MP292 Becky Marzo 12/12/2003 Milwaukee WI
MP10665 Belinda Blaniar 06/21/1996 Westmoreland PA
MP1363 Bobbi Campbell 12/30/1994 Salt Lake UT
MP1134 Brandy Wilson 06/04/2002 Clinton IN (X2)
MP1045 Brookley Louks 06/24/2002 Johnson IN (X2)
MP28907 Carey Jones 05/01/2005 Sarasota FL
MP6907 Carolyn Martin 08/31/1981 Oakland MI
MP365 Carrie Polega 10/14/2003 Marinette WI
MP1904 Christine Jarrett 1991 Howard MD (removed from NamUs)
MP95 Christine Lott 03/25/2004 Bonner ID (removed from NamUs)
MP1372 Clarissa Culberson 08/28/1996 Clinton OH
MP8161 Claudia Shepherd 08/13/2001 Pasco FL
MP16945 Colleen Voitik McHugh 1994 Will IL (removed from NamUs)
MP806 Danielle Imbo 02/19/2005 Philadelphia PA
MP1716 Dawn Haines 01/01/1995 Hardin KY
MP2694 Debbie Escalante 08/21/1989 -- NM (X2)
MP10288 Deborah Overbaugh 07/13/1992 Ulster NY
MP8988 Debra Lucas 09/26/2010 Jefferson KY
MP17088 Denise Fraley 09/12/1982 Linn IA
MP10555 Denise Pflum 03/28/1986 Fayette IN
MP2524 Diane Kennedy 12/31/1996 Haywood NC
MP9336 Donda Martino 06/30/1994 Hamilton TN
MP7282 Donna Cupido 10/21/2004 Colbert AL
MP2632 Donna Rigsby 06/28/2003 Talladega AL
MP74 Elizabeth Maggard 07/04/1984 Campbell KY
MP8614 Ellabeth Lodermeier 03/06/1974 Minnehaha SD
MP10496 Gloria Korzon 03/06/1981 Bucks PA
MP1100 Hazel Klug 05/20/1986 Henrico VA
MP52 Heather Teague 08/26/1995 Henderson KY
MP945 Hope Curry 11/11/2000 Virginia Beach VA
MP23 Janet March 08/15/1996 Davidson TN (X2)
MP1193 Janeth Rowe 03/02/1997 Fairfax VA
MP8530 Janis Sanders 08/05/1975 Berrien MI
MP630 Jennifer Wilkerson 07/13/2004 Lubbock TX
MP12190 Jennifer Wilmer 09/13/1993 Trinity CA
MP53 Jennifer Wix 03/25/2004 Robertson TN
MP29548 Jeri Duvall 06/08/1990 Will IL
MP402 Jodi Huisentruit 06/26/1995 Cerro Gordo IA
MP1764 Joyce Crider 10/28/2002 Fayette KY (X2)
MP20328 Julie Brumfield-Gann 09/12/1994 St. Tammany LA
MP10654 Julie Johnson 03/01/1991 Howard IN
MP1118 Karen Smith 12/27/2000 Marion IN
MP2956 Karen Spencer 12/29/1989 Clermont OH
MP2349 Karen Steed 11/25/1997 Calhoun AL
MP299 Kerry O'Brien-Krueger 12/06/1989 Racine WI
MP11480 Lavonne Miller 12/06/1997 Greene AR
MP286 Lisa Shuttleworth 09/04/2003 Aiken SC
MP2386 Lynn Bandringa 05/29/1967 San Bernardino CA
MP5616 Margaret Warrington 02/24/1997 Kenton KY
MP8058 Mary Pike 04/01/1994 Clark NV
MP1698 Melanie Flynn 02/26/1977 Fayette KY
MP5308 Melinda Creech 09/05/1979 Madison IN
MP400 Melissa Hasley 10/18/2002 Polk IA
MP1829 Michelle Lokker 06/07/2003 Allegan MI
MP2224 Michelle Collins 07/6/2004 Laurel KY
MP9787 Mindy Arnett 08/14/2002 Mackinac MI
MP793 Molly Dattilo 07/06/2004 Marion IN (X2)
MP625 Nelda Hardwick 10/14/1993 Calcasieu LA
MP607 Nina Herron 05/14/2005 Bernalillo NM
MP1137 Pamela Golden 07/22/1993 Pulaski AR
MP2238 Patricia Calloway 03/03/1993 Ohio KY
MP974 Patricia Schmidt 06/04/1985 Henrico VA
MP80 Patsy Nonemaker 12/31/1999 Bullitt KY
MP1141 Rachel Good 10/18/2003 Rockingham VA
MP2707 Robin Abrams 10/04/1990 Will IL
MP1734 Rose West 09/10/1991 Green KY
MP192 Sandra Jacobson 11/16/1996 Burleigh ND
MP763 Sandra Baker 05/25/2000 Mercer PA
MP23766 Salena Tackett 01/30/2003 Sumner TN
MP1091 Sharon Apgar 11/18/1999 Clermont OH
MP746 Sharon Shechter 12/09/2001 Monroe NY
MP1717 Sharon Sons 10/27/1993 Fayette KY
MP8679 Shelia Carver 06/16/1998 Oconee SC (X2)
MP1727 Sonya Bradley 10/11/2002 Lyon KY
MP9510 Stephanie Banks 02/13/2004 Clark KY
MP23648 Susan Riedling 03/31/1986 Bullitt KY
MP2026 Tabitha Tuders 04/29/2003 Davidson TN
MP759 Theresa Waldron 01/10/2005 Schenectady NY
MP2413 Tiffany Sessions 02/09/1989 Alachua FL
MP9510 Stephanie Banks 02/13/2004 Clark KY
MP7025 Tricia Reitler 03/29/1993 Grant IN
MP9861 ?

 

[Mindy71]

Possible Matches:

1. Mary Jane Croft VanGilder, Mary Jane, Mary Jane
2. Lea Anna Allen (DLC is September 1980 per a family member)
3. Stacey Lynn Balas
4. Vicky Lynn Vukelich (Courtesy of Melt71)

Another one added to the list of exclusions, bringing the total to 93 (including the duplicates)

Mary Jane croft vangilder doesn't match. The years are off. My grandmother was born in 1911. I wish there was a possibility so our family could have closure. It's hard not knowing.

 

[MadMcGoo]

Mary Jane croft vangilder doesn't match. The years are off. My grandmother was born in 1911. I wish there was a possibility so our family could have closure. It's hard not knowing.

Thank you for your response!

I understand the not know, and it’s very difficult. I truly hope there is some resolve in your grandmother’s case soon. My thoughts are with you and your family!

 

[Ozoner]

Mary Jane croft vangilder doesn't match. The years are off. My grandmother was born in 1911. I wish there was a possibility so our family could have closure. It's hard not knowing.

Did anyone in your family ever confront your grandfather about your grandmother's disappearance in order to try to get him to confess?

 

[Mindy71]

Did anyone in your family ever confront your grandfather about your grandmother's disappearance in order to try to get him to confess?

No. Noone thought he had anything to do with.

 

[MadMcGoo]

Mary Lou Combs – The Charley Project

I’ve not seen Mary Lou’s case before. Most everything fits, although there is some distance between where Mary Lou was last seen and where Shively JD was discovered. She did disappear with her vehicle though which has not been located either.

Her hair is listed as being gray, but it appears to be “graying” in her photos; her natural hair color being light brownish. Her nose looks narrow to me but possibly deviated to one side? I’m not sure if that would be visible on the UID.

 

[carbuff]

https://www.namus.gov/MissingPersons/Case#/326/details
Debra Marie Melo – The Charley Project

Debra Melo?

Missing from Massachusetts in June 2000, husband a suspect but had 1-3 days after she was missing to have disposed of her body.

I tried to include a side by side but couldn't get it to work...

 

[Alleykins]

https://www.namus.gov/MissingPersons/Case#/326/details
Debra Marie Melo – The Charley Project

Debra Melo?

Missing from Massachusetts in June 2000, husband a suspect but had 1-3 days after she was missing to have disposed of her body.

I tried to include a side by side but couldn't get it to work...

Her nose definitely qualifies as a slim nose

 

[Alleykins]

Are there any rule outs for Debra already?

 

[victoriarobinson642]

https://i.imgur.com/nLcdDbL.jpg
I made a very, very quick reconstruction of SJD because I think she deserves a better one than the clay version. Some liberties were taken with eye color, hairstyle, and clothing.

 

[MadMcGoo]

Yes, I’d say that qualifies as a distinctive narrow nose...very much so. Debra has 3 UIDs on her list of exclusions - this one is not one of them. I think Debra is a definite possibility!

 

[carbuff]

Debbie's WS thread MA - MA - Debbie Melo, 30, Weymouth, 20 June 2000

 

[MadMcGoo]

Recently added to NamUs...reminded me of our girl.
https://www.namus.gov/MissingPersons/Case#/71096

ETA: link - additional info.
Help Us Find: Rosa Maria Shipley

Edited again to add: https://seguintoday.com/2018/12/12/spd-still-seeking-clues-for-unsolved-missing-persons-cases/

Reading the articles again, I’m not sure if the lead received in 2017 about her being in Utah means that she was possibly seen there in 2017 or it’s referring to the police report taken from her back in 1998.

In May of 2017 there was a potential lead Shipley may have been in Salt Lake City, Utah.

"We drove all night, I would not stop, I think it took us 25 hours to get to Utah, "Juarez went on to say.

While there was no sign of Shipley, her family says when they contact police in Utah they were told back in 1998 there was a report taken from a Rosa Maria Shipley outside of a woman's shelter.

"That someone had mugged her and took her purse, took her bag and her bag has some of her information, " Juarez said.

 

[MadMcGoo]

I completely forgot to thank you Victoria for doing the reconstruction!! As always, wonderful job! <3

 

[Bit of hope]

https://i.imgur.com/nLcdDbL.jpg
I made a very, very quick reconstruction of SJD because I think she deserves a better one than the clay version. Some liberties were taken with eye color, hairstyle, and clothing.

I like it Vic.

 

[Bit of hope]

Recently added to NamUs...reminded me of our girl.
https://www.namus.gov/MissingPersons/Case#/71096

ETA: link - additional info.
Help Us Find: Rosa Maria Shipley

Edited again to add: https://seguintoday.com/2018/12/12/spd-still-seeking-clues-for-unsolved-missing-persons-cases/

Reading the articles again, I’m not sure if the lead received in 2017 about her being in Utah means that she was possibly seen there in 2017 or it’s referring to the police report taken from her back in 1998.

This is another picture of her, snipped from the video. You can see her nose much better. It's distinctive.

 

[MadMcGoo]

This is another picture of her, snipped from the video. You can see her nose much better. It's distinctive.

View attachment 252613

Oh wow! Yah... my side my side machine isn’t working lol... but they have similar facial bone structure (that doesn’t sound like the right terminology ) IMO.

ETA: I know records indicate that dental records are available for the UID, but I wish there was some sort of description....seems like that might be something to help in our searches.

 

[chaddylex]

Oh wow! Yah... my side my side machine isn’t working lol... but they have similar facial bone structure (that doesn’t sound like the right terminology ) IMO.

ETA: I know records indicate that dental records are available for the UID, but I wish there was some sort of description....seems like that might be something to help in our searches.

I definitely see a resemblance. Back when NamUs first came out, we were able to see dentals of the UID if they were available and we could see if DNA was on file.

 

[dotr]

I'm still looking into Lisa Ann Pierce. I don't think a thread has been started for her.

Apparently, she had three children at the time of her disappearance - and they are looking for her - per the link below:

Born 1990-1999 Alabama GS Adoption Registry

ETA:
I saw this info but haven't verified.

Lisa Ann Pierce was last seen on November 6, 2000 in Mobile, Alabama at 12:35pm.
She is 5'3, 93lbs with shoulder length brown hair and bangs that cover her forehead, she has hazel eyes, crooked front teeth, and a tattoo on her right ankle of the letters RS.
Circumstances surrounding her disappearance are unclear and she has not been seen or heard from.
She was born in 1973 in St. Tammany Parish, Bogalusa, Louisiana as Lisa Ann Humphrey and may be using this last name now.

If you have any information about her whereabouts, please contact Detective Sgt, Erika Stuart at 251-208-1826.

Just started thread, fresh appeal..
AL - AL, Lisa Ann Pierce, 27, Mobile, 6 November 2000

 

[Melt71]

@MadMcGoo or others, any update to the exclusion list since it was last posted in April 2020? I'm interested to see if my submit Vikki Vukelich has been ruled out (sent in 12 months ago tomorrow).

@othram here you have a very motivated LE with almost 100 ruleouts for this UID, but still unable to identify her. Might be worth a discussion as they are putting a lot of time (=money) and effort into this case.