MA - Sandra Birchmore, Stoughton, 4 Feb 2021 *former police officer arrested*

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
My question is, aside from SB and KR, what other local cases have piqued the Feds interest?

I'm not sure about local police forces, but here's a run down of some investigations involving the State Police.

 
Canton Police weren't responsible for phone data extraction. That was the Mass State Police, more specifically Trooper Nicholas Guarino, who testified in the Read trial as a phone forensics expert. And yet he "missed" almost 33,000 texts from Farwell that the FBI found using Cellebrite. Guarino is supposed to be an expert in Cellebrite extractions.

Sandra's death didn't appear as a typical hanging. She was in a seated position. I wouldn't have any idea how to pull that off myself, and it seems unlikely she did any pre-research as she seemed very happy in the weeks before her death. Video also shows her preparing for the next day by going out regularly to clean snow off her car that afternoon and evening. There was a load of laundry in the washing machine. She was texting co-workers about school the next day. Not the sorts of things suicidal people do. And this was all known to investigators.

Not to mention, Farwell, his twin brother, and Robert Devine who started the Explorers program in town, all lost their jobs in 2022 for having sex with Sandra. Massive red flag. 'Lies, deceit, and treachery,' Investigation finds 3 former Stoughton police officers had inappropriate relationship with young woman

Investigators cannot be given a pass because suicide rates went up during the pandemic. There were red flags literally everywhere, not the least of which included Farwell's visit caught on video. Birchmore's friends say her phone was attached to her and she texted constantly. And yet minutes before he departs, she's silenced forever.

The State Police in Massachusetts are tasked with investigating non-natural deaths, including homicides and suicides. They absolutely should know what they are doing here.
Whoah ... missed the Nicholas Guarino potentially dodgy phone forensics commonality. Thanks for explicating this
 
I'm going with she's still with him.
Strange that no info about her has been reported.
OMG! I just thought especially of the child that was born the next morning.
You know those photos of the smiling new daddy with their newborns soon after birth that just about every family has.
They have to live with their daddy was arrested for killing their half brother or sister the night before.
SCREAM!
I just saw this when I searched MF online




The Case
@thecasepodcast
Follow

Matthew Farwell less than a day after Sandra Birchmore was found dead.
Image

10:31 PM · Sep 3, 2024
·
71K
Views
 
I'm not sure about local police forces, but here's a run down of some investigations involving the State Police.


And the irony.... Guess who was driving a gravel hauler (with a CDL) on the day he was arrested in Revere? Yup, MF!
 
And the irony.... Guess who was driving a gravel hauler (with a CDL) on the day he was arrested in Revere? Yup, MF!

And one of the arrested state troopers was from, you guessed it, Stoughton.

 
I don't think this has been posted here before. It's the Stoughton Police Report investigation into the three officers in their department who had "inappropriate" relations with Sandra. I remain stunned that the State Police still did nothing with this, forcing the FBI's hand.

 
SCREAM!
I just saw this when I searched MF online




The Case
@thecasepodcast
Follow

Matthew Farwell less than a day after Sandra Birchmore was found dead.
Image

10:31 PM · Sep 3, 2024
·
71K
Views
Is it just me, but for some reason those eyes don’t seem to IMO convey the joy of a new father? Holding a newly born infant?

With what is now known about this individual, perhaps there is a reason for that? MOO
 
I don't think this has been posted here before. It's the Stoughton Police Report investigation into the three officers in their department who had "inappropriate" relations with Sandra. I remain stunned that the State Police still did nothing with this, forcing the FBI's hand.


I read through the report. It's thorough and pretty damning. The report was completed in August 2022, over two years ago. Right on the bottom of the penultimate page it says "I recommend the Norfolk County District Attorney receive a copy of this report". There was plenty of evidence to convict all three men of statutory rape, but instead the report was buried. I think we all know if these men were civilians, they would have been tried and convicted by now.

This is exactly what is meant by a "culture of corruption".
1725486273369.png
 
Is it just me, but for some reason those eyes don’t seem to IMO convey the joy of a new father? Holding a newly born infant?

With what is now known about this individual, perhaps there is a reason for that? MOO
Nope.
Like you can hear what's running through his mind.
IMO:
He probably didn't even have time to shower between (accused of) killing his unborn child and holding his wife's hand while she was in labor and then holding his newborn.
 
Is it just me, but for some reason those eyes don’t seem to IMO convey the joy of a new father? Holding a newly born infant?

With what is now known about this individual, perhaps there is a reason for that? MOO
Monstroussssssssss those eyes I felt immediately. Who took the picture and had to see that look in his eyes, ughhh.
 
Is it just me, but for some reason those eyes don’t seem to IMO convey the joy of a new father? Holding a newly born infant?

With what is now known about this individual, perhaps there is a reason for that? MOO
I wonder what his wife is thinking about now?

Where was she at 9 something pm the night before when SB/baby were murdered?
Did MF meet her at home or the hospital?
Was he late and made excuses?
What was his mood when they met, during labor?

If this goes to trial will the prosecution want to bring in any evidence they may have between MF and his wife the day of the murder and after it before they hooked up for the labor?
Text messages/calls.
Will the prosecutor subpoena the wife?

So far she's been lucky, the press has left her alone and none dug into her life/past.
Like those articles from "Heavy" and the 5 things they report on a person.
 
I'm so happy that this case was reevaluated and ruled a homicide resulting in Farwell's arrest. There should be charges against the two other officers too for statutory rape. I had completely given up on this case being pursued further and so happy I was wrong. I hopped back on the thread when I saw officer arrested. This article is so damning. Glad LE found the texts. Praying for justice for Sandra.
 
I'm so happy that this case was reevaluated and ruled a homicide resulting in Farwell's arrest. There should be charges against the two other officers too for statutory rape. I had completely given up on this case being pursued further and so happy I was wrong. I hopped back on the thread when I saw officer arrested. This article is so damning. Glad LE found the texts. Praying for justice for Sandra.
I just saw your "Registered Nurse" and thought of the nurses who attended MF's wife in maternity and crossed paths with MF.
Assuming she didn't have a home birth.
 
The crime would be MF raping her at 15.
From there you go back to when he met SB at 12 and forward to whatever timeline SB and her therapist were on.
I can't let the therapist go and highly doubt anything will come of it as far as an in-depth investigation by the FBI or an outside investigation.
I understand. That's what I was providing reference to. The therapist should've gone to LE BUT at the same time do we think LE would've done anything considering LE was involved
 
I understand. That's what I was providing reference to. The therapist should've gone to LE BUT at the same time do we think LE would've done anything considering LE was involved
Being a mandated reporter is their legal responsibility, not what is or isn't done with the info.
Awhile back I posted that after giving it some thought about the call to LE that went nowhere and considering that it was about a cop and
IMO:
getting in touch with a known or highly recommended defense attorney would be the smartest and safest way to get advice on who to report it to.
The attorney could also know who they feel could be trusted to make sure the info wasn't buried.
Turning in a cop is scary beyond words and there could be a way to do it anonymously.

For years none of SB's relatives or adults surrounding her reported anything to anyone.
From media reporting it took a friend of SB's to call the cops and supposedly it was about money owed them by SB and not about the abuse and violence at the hands of MF?

Anyone know if therapists/shrinks can clean up their records about sessions with their clients?
That is if they're stupid enough to document info that they know damn well they should report and don't.
 
Last edited:
I understand. That's what I was providing reference to. The therapist should've gone to LE BUT at the same time do we think LE would've done anything considering LE was involved

The therapist could not have gone to LE unless they knew Sandra had sex with any of these men before she was sixteen. Patient confidentiality must be maintained. And I wouldn't be surprised if Sandra never did rat any of these guys out. The only reason we even know Matthew Farwell raped her at 15 is because they reminisced about it in texts much later on. With Farwell sad that it didn't happen earlier. :mad:
 
I don't think this has been posted here before. It's the Stoughton Police Report investigation into the three officers in their department who had "inappropriate" relations with Sandra. I remain stunned that the State Police still did nothing with this, forcing the FBI's hand.


Thanks for posting the link and sorry that the Exhibits are not available. I'm deeply saddened by SB's shortened, tragic life.

I've read been reading the WDC and subsequent filings by the defendants and there are references to this linked IA report but as expected, the defendants to the lawsuit protested by filing several Motions to "claw-back" the discovery (IA report & Exhibits). Given the FBI criminal investigation was being conducted parallel to the time the WDC was filed on Dec 22, 2022 and still pending, the Motions to exclude the IA data were generally granted -- citing the protection of the on-going FBI criminal investigation. MOO
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
83
Guests online
172
Total visitors
255

Forum statistics

Threads
609,014
Messages
18,248,492
Members
234,523
Latest member
MN-Girl
Back
Top