first, ms McCall called janelles home at 10:30 and was informed by janelle’s sister that neither Janelle nor Stacy was there. Yet Janelle says that she WAS home until 12:30, calling dozens of times to no avail. THEN, after this alleged inital 12:30 trip, Janelle gets back and finds out that Stacy has been busted for not staying at her (janelles house). So Janelle calls me McCall back, but does NOT tell her she has just come from the Delmar house. We know this because ms McCall says at this points she thinks the girls are still sleeping and that’s why they don’t answer the phone. This wrongful assumption was the reason the McCall’s headed to the lake instead of being concerned. So why didn’t janelle just tell her? She already knew Stacy stayed there so why not mention that hey, I just got back and there was broken glass and cars and keys and purses all there, etc? Why in the world would you keep this to yourself no matter where you thought they were? Instead she gives Janice the phone number and acts like she hasn’t been there.
Next, Janelle’s first story is that she wasn’t concerned. Ok. But then we know she calls adina who IS concerned and I’m sure told her so. The day goes on and Janelle goes back to the home at 3:30 and experiences two “obscene” phone calls while there and leaves crying in the backseat according to her new story dropped a year later. Yet, none of this is revealed to the police that night. Not the 3:30 visit, not the obscene phone calls, and she STILL doesn’t call anyone at this point even though now she says (a year later) than indeed she is worried at this point and was “crying in the backseat.”
No one apparently calls anyone until msmccall is finally informed by adina’s mother sometime after 7:30 (probably a while after 7:30 considering she doesn’t arrive until 9) that the purses and cars and keys are all there. And we don’t get the full story from Janelle even now because according to janelle she only went to the home at 12:30, 3:30 and 7:30, yet when ms McCall arrives at 9 no one is there (she says the house was completely dark, she stumbled in to find a light, and only afterward people started pouring into the house. So that brings us to FOUR trips to the home, not two, two obscene calls that surely to god would have been reported by any person with a single brain cell, and an admission that she was indeed worried by at least 4 but no phone calls to get help even though Stacy’s cover was long blown.
Please explain these inconsistencies with more than just “being tired” or “forgetful” or “being a teen.”
I’ll say once more- I don’t think janelle and Mike physically hurt or abducted the women but I think they are hiding something. And I don’t think having a quick romp in the house is the reason. Nor do I think the kids and their parents had a house party at Sherrill’s because “that’s what people did back then”.
