Don't worry I'm not going anywhere - I am just posting a little bit less, letting people catch up on the last 3-4 pages and seeing where we go from here. I agree that the room does sound somewhat "staged".
I like your theory and where you're going with it. And I can add to it.. "credit cards or even his coat when he went missing, the weather was very bad at the time and there were no belongings at all missing from his room" (Source:
FindJoshua).
So if we break this down, we've got:
- Josh missing.
- Credit cards, coat, glasses, contacts, wallet, car keys still in Josh's room.
- TV on.
- Music playing and skipping in the night (Source: SimplyVanished).
- Josh's car not moved.
For someone to go into Josh's dorm room, they'd need to keycard in. Nick didn't keycard in until after 2:42am. I'd be interested to know if the music continued playing or pausing or skipping or whatever it was doing that night. I need to go back and listen to the podcast again.
Either way, Greg gets back to Maur House at 3am. "
Greg gets back from the card party at around 3:00 am Sunday morning. He doesn't live on the same floor as Josh and Nick, so he isn't sure whether Josh was there or not. One of the other roommates had been gone for the entire weekend, and it is unclear whether the remaining two were on campus or not during that time period." - Source (
Uncovered).
I find the times suspicious as heck! Until now, I didn't know Greg got back at 3am. So Katie says Nick left around 1am, Nick key cards in at 2:42am, then Greg gets back from the card party 18 mins after Nick, at 3am?
I've never seen this quote before, but: "Guimond’s mother, Lisa Cheney, tells producers she suspects her son died, possibly by accident, at the St. John’s campus party in question. Cheney suspects that other students ultimately covered up her son’s death." (Source:
Oxygen)
This brings me RIGHT back to my poker party overdose theory!!!
Josh accidentally dies somehow (potentially drug overdose, or after a spiked drink etc) and Josh's friends call up Nick and then Nick keycards in at 2:42am and Greg 18 mins later at 3am.
Those friends
have to know more. I'm really, really buying into the staged room theory now. Let me think about this some more and I'll post back later.