so ive thought about this angle and honestly,in my head,it makes 10x more logical sense than the monks. we know josh and nick argued the night before josh vanished. we know from one of the maur house dorm friends that the argument was about katie. then josh goes to a party where he knows nick and katie arent there.
but it eats away at him that his ex and nick might be hooking up. so he leaves the party early to go and confront them. we are led to believe witnesses see josh leave and see him walking towards the bridge (this sentence is just my opinion)
this article:
Who Killed Josh Guimond? seems to suggest nick did drive and had a car on the night. (from the above article:
''But from the quote given above, we know Nick drove to Katie’s. He had a vehicle on campus. It is unlikely Josh’s car was used to dispose of his own body since people seemed to think it had not been moved'')
my belief is nick must have owned a car based on that reasoning.the sheriffs said the drive is a 7-10 minute drive,so nick leaving katies at 1-1.30am is even more suspicious because nick would have been home around 1.10-1.40am.
what you said in the last line, i made bold because it has given me an idea. nick driving back to campus. josh walking back to maur house. what happens if nick and josh met up and drove off campus. the argument continues and escalated to the point of no return and nick did something,then drove back to campus and key carded in (again,just my logical thought)
and then when nick says joshs car hadnt moved....well thats because it hadnt....but nicks had.nick had plausable deniability because he had moved his car.....to visit katies. which now begs the question, was nicks car ever searched? did any cctv cameras (off campus) see nicks car? i think the sheriffs were so focused on the damn lakes they forgot to do basic police work and didnt even remove joshs computer from the dorm room. this is just my own personal thoughts but i feel like this scenario is much more likely than monks and would explain nicks timeline being off
if nick did leave at 1am then thats 1 hour 42 minutes unaccounted for. and for anyone who thinks that isnt enough time to murder someone,look at this
(if anyone is extremely sensitive to seeing someone in a choke hold for demonstration dont watch).its approx 10 secs to choke someone unconscious. 1 hour 42 is more than enough to strangle/dispose of a body in the middle of the night (my objective opinion)