rkendmar
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2019
- Messages
- 828
- Reaction score
- 7,377
This is an issue I personally go back and forth on. I hope this is okay to post here, if not I'm sure it will be deleted. People have autonomy - they get to make their own decisions even if they are bad ones. There are very specific criteria that let the police or a hospital detain someone against their will. Danger to oneself or others. I've seen a lot of anger toward the police in this story. And I understand it. It's possible this whole thing could have been prevented if someone had just done something different. But at the same time, what grounds would they have had to keep her at the police station or take her to the hospital against her will? Then we would be talking about unlawful detainment. I'm sure, that as a social worker Marina would know how to answer the screening questions that would prevent them from holding her there if she didn't want to be held. It's a terrible situation, and I so hope it has a good outcome. I just think that adults have the right to make their own choices, even when they are bad ones.
I strongly agree that competent adults have the right to make their own decisions, even bad decisions.
IMO, the issue was if Marina was capable of making decisions in her confused and disoriented state.
Marina, reportedly, was in an accident and left the scene but later returned.
She was confused and it is unclear if she was actually tested for alcohol.
Someone who is confused after an accident should be assessed by medical personnel and receive a CT, the person should be monitored for, at least, 24 hours.
A slow brain bleed could ultimately result in death.