NC - Shaniya Davis, 5, Fayetteville, 10 Nov 2009 - Allegedly sold by mother #17

Welcome to Websleuths!
Click to learn how to make a missing person's thread

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves

New Posts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dr.Fessel said:
The trafficking could have happened in the days before her death.
Click to expand...


Yes, exactly. Which means she wasn't involved in the kidnapping perpetrated by McNeill. Two unrelated crimes. Which changes the whole picture.
 
songline said:
The post I replied to said he took her to the hotel, did his thing, bathed her and then took her our of the hotel.
SO to that I wonder why he would have bothered to bath her if he was planning to harm her even more.
I have no clue what may have happened I just think Antoinette did harm her child. the father was negligent.
and the Human trafficking part of this case will hopefully cut our losses in half - will it clear it up NO. but maybe it will curb it. this case should put more LE on the force, more jobs are required to get more...this is horrific and huge....I was reading that we lose 200-300,000 children a year to this sex slave trade. :furious:
Click to expand...

songline, it makes me cry to no end. They're not even able to make a dent in it! It's so disheartening.
 
MomofBoys said:
Is it possible the information about AD selling her came from Coe, and that cooperation is one of the reasons he was cleared and released so quickly? It seemed almost abrupt to me. If Coe and McNeill are singing the same song in that respect, with MAM denying the actual rape/murder, then maybe AD was poly'd or they're holding her based on the word of two witnesses with corroborating stories?
Click to expand...

I believe this was MAM's story when he was first arrested. He admitted only to taking her but not kidnapping (meaning he had mom's permission).
 
passionflower said:
I can't find a link in this mess, but IIRC it was in a news article about clothing being found in park after the blanket was found and it was undies.
Then all she had on was the T sleepshirt.......bare legs no shoes etc in photo by elavator.
It's been mentioned several times.
Click to expand...

Thanks, I must have missed that. I hadn't heard it before at all. Wish we could find a link!
 
jnTexas said:
IMO they will drop the kidnapping charge once they file murder and rape charges. They did not know at the time Mom handed her over.
Click to expand...

Kidnapping can also be defined by intent.
Removing/detaining a person for intent of nefarious activities.
You can lure an adult away under false pretenses and end up with a kidnapping charge. Momster cannot consent to have her child taken for the intent of raping her.... so it could be a legal interpretation, or it could be removed later. I think you will see it stand though.

Whether momster said he could take her and rape or not, he took a child from her home with the intent to commit a crime. I believe that will fulfill the kidnapping requirement on either side of the table.
 
NG is on Joy Bahar show now! HLN again.......maybe she will talk more about Shaniya.
 
CharlestonGal said:
I'm confused about what exactly it is that AD did. MAM's warrant plainly states that he took Shaniya, a minor under the age of 16, without permission from her parent. Given that MAM did not have AD's permission to take Shaniya, then what exactly is AD's role in this? Her charges and his charges are completely contradictory. Either she trafficked Shaniya to him or she didn't. If she did, he couldn't be charged with kidnapping because AD gave her to him. Yet he is charged with taking her without the permission of AD. AD's part in this thing is not clear and until it is I really can't form an opinion about felony murder charges for AD.
Click to expand...

Along w 911 call, this is one reason I speculated in the past that while AD may have even admitted selling her daughter to MAM to be raped, perhaps not necessarily to take Shaniya anywhere(?) Theoretically therefore I suppose she could be guilty of trafficking and prostituting and he of kidnapping her child w/out permission (?) But I am feeling more confident now that they actually have AD on video handing her over to MAM--in which case a little hard to claim he was "kidnapping." :rolleyes:
 
NG talking about child prositution.....found a 12 year old made up like a 30 year old woman.
It happens ALLOT in USA!!!
 
kiki the parrot said:
Along w 911 call, this is one reason I speculated in the past that while AD may have even admitted selling her daughter to MAM to be raped, perhaps not necessarily to take Shaniya anywhere(?) Theoretically therefore I suppose she could be guilty of trafficking and prostituting and he of kidnapping her child w/out permission (?) But I am feeling more confident now that they actually have AD on video handing her over to MAM--in which case a little hard to claim he was "kidnapping." :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Exactly. The problem I have with that though is that if AD handed her over voluntarily, why did she call 911? That doesn't fit with a voluntary handoff. A lot of pieces are missing right now.
 
Must go and relax, get a wine maybe and come back when I'm not so mad!
May Shaniya get JUSTICE all the way tomorrow!!! (everyone who hurt her!)
I see a few more arrests on little things involved after her burial. IMO
 
Wow I don't think Joy has ever really watched Nancy's show? Nancy was talking to her like she does defense attorneys for a few minutes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

DNASolves

Who is Fairfield County Jane Doe (1993)?

Members online

... and 117 more.
Total: 1,796 (members: 118, guests: 1,678)

Online statistics

Members online
118
Guests online
1,678
Total visitors
1,796
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
605,866
Messages
18,193,913
Members
233,615
Latest member
AtroRed
Back
Top