GUILTY NY - Evanna Tranberg-Bennett, 12, died, parents failed to get her medical care, 6 Dec 2019 Probation

[sedona2000]

He said he was living there "on and off for five years" and was there the night Evanna "was killed by EMT" but suddenly..... his posts have disappeared..... after someone on the community page said she was contacting the TB attorney. TB attorney will have several billable hours after the nonsense the family caused the last few days.

He said he was living there "on and off for five years" and was there the night Evanna "was killed by EMT" but suddenly..... his posts have disappeared..... after someone on the community page said she was contacting the TB attorney. TB attorney will have several billable hours after the nonsense the family caused the last few days.

Are you referring to the Uncle/"sort of brother" of Heidi or the man who appeared out of thin air a few days ago who claims to have lived with the family on and off for 5 years? This same man also suddenly vanished from social media when the TB attorney was contacted. And then their writing style changed. Take screen shots. They are deleting everything. But the truth cannot be long hidden.

 

[MsBetsy]

He said he was living there "on and off for five years" and was there the night Evanna "was killed by EMT" but suddenly..... his posts have disappeared..... after someone on the community page said she was contacting the TB attorney. TB attorney will have several billable hours after the nonsense the family caused the last few days.

The whole page is gone now, or at least for me it was.

 

[shotgun09]

Bilateral pneumonia with significant alveolar damage says to me..very very sick child. Her oxygenation saturation was more than likely (IMO) in the 80's ( normal is 95-99 ) for some time before she finally collapsed. Had she been to a doctor or clinic in the days or weeks prior, oxygen levels could have been monitored, medicines given to reduce inflammation, and abx given to battle an infection...

But she (Evanna) was " stubborn" and "stuffing her face" ......in the parlor...and poor Steve was so sick...and somebody else's baby was teething....and they couldn't find a ride... ( By the way what super duper family of 15 do you know, doesn't have one reliable vehicle?)...and their super duper doctor is across the state line and we had to make an appt ..and he doesn't keep good records....and it was snowing... Just stop with the nonsense Please!!

Poor Evanna, she was so ignored

And bring on the Justice for Evanna!

 

[Jane_Fox]

He said he was living there "on and off for five years" and was there the night Evanna "was killed by EMT" but suddenly..... his posts have disappeared..... after someone on the community page said she was contacting the TB attorney. TB attorney will have several billable hours after the nonsense the family caused the last few days.

No... Im replying to the parts stated about an uncle living in the house. An uncle did not live in the house. I responded also and it did not disappear because of saying they were contacting the attorney as the post stayed up another 11 hours with many exchanges.

 

[Jane_Fox]

Tranberg Bennett “key witness” who lives in the house has gone dark. It’s plausible that the “key witness” in fact were not aware of the account being used while they were gone over the Thanksgiving holiday- so many months of credibility issues based off posts by them. I do not agree with the comnent on WS that it was a burner account. They were linked to their family posts & that was addressed in his lengthy community post with outrage coming from the Tranberg Bennett family on his behalf.

The posts made by the “Key Witness” are gone....because the dude came back from NYC & got on his FB again (at their home) saw what they were doing & had a missed message from his sister trying to alert him as well- Thats not MoO

 

[Jane_Fox]

Are you referring to the Uncle/"sort of brother" of Heidi or the man who appeared out of thin air a few days ago who claims to have lived with the family on and off for 5 years? This same man also suddenly vanished from social media when the TB attorney was contacted. And then their writing style changed. Take screen shots. They are deleting everything. But the truth cannot be long hidden.

I originally quoted your own post...first sentenced you said re dying uncle makes 9 living there. He dis not live in the house. if i am wrong please link me where, but the evidence they shared were text exchanges w the dying uncle & an attempt to say that is why Petra was searching those symptoms. Yes “key witness” lived there. uncke didnt. Screenshots aren’t allowed in here however-just saying

 

[MsBetsy]

The posts made by the “Key Witness” are gone....because the dude came back from NYC & got on his FB again (at their home) saw what they were doing & had a missed message from his sister trying to alert him as well- Thats not MoO

This is getting more confusing by the minute. What Dude? The witness? Is he the same person the family was referring to when they said the DSS Commissioner went to his house and told him not to testify?

Who is his sister? Or is the dude a family member? I can no longer see any posts because it says the page was broken or removed.

 

[Lilibet]

This is getting more confusing by the minute. What Dude? The witness? Is he the same person the family was referring to when they said the DSS Commissioner went to his house and told him not to testify?

Who is his sister? Or is the dude a family member? I can no longer see any posts because it says the page was broken or removed.

These two pages are open. Is there another one?

Chatham Community Board

Tranberg-Bennett Family

 

[Lusitana]

I agree. I don’t see much value in throwing out additional possibilities of additional health issues when there has been no evidence or “pseudo” evidence anywhere. A jury debating guilt or innocence should stick on topic as we should unless one can point to something stated regarding Lupus in relation to this crime.
****Focusing on the facts needed for guilt or innocence seems best-Did they know before hand she was in need? would a reasonable person act & choose as they did or was this reckless? Did they show indifference even when knowing Evanna Tranberg Bennett needed urgent medical care?

If Evanna had Lupus or any other chronic disease that further proves there was obvious neglect, as in, she was not getting proper medical attention.

If this poor child had a chronic disease, which it appears she did, there’s absolutely no way she didn’t display any symptoms. They ignored her and she died, the fact that she might have suffered with a chronic disease, Lupus or whatever else, only makes it even more obvious that her health was neglected for a LONG time.

It’s relevant to the discussion.

I originally quoted your own post...first sentenced you said re dying uncle makes 9 living there. He dis not live in the house. if i am wrong please link me where, but the evidence they shared were text exchanges w the dying uncle & an attempt to say that is why Petra was searching those symptoms. Yes “key witness” lived there. uncke didnt. Screenshots aren’t allowed in here however-just saying

The supposed uncle did not live there. He visited, stayed for a period of time, not sure how long.

But the wording used by the family suggested he was just visiting, not actually living there.

SC, the person who posted here and that has been posting on the Facebook group claims he lived in the Tranberg-Bennett house for 5 years on and off.

It would be interesting to know how many people were actually staying at the house around the time Evanna passed away.

 

[shotgun09]

These two pages are open. Is there another one?

Chatham Community Board

Tranberg-Bennett Family

Those are the two that I have been following, however I think we are discussing the fact that the large posts of SC, (the witness who suddenly appeared) as well as all the comments following seemed to have gone ' poof ' on both the Community Board as well as the TB Family page. Mysterious...... The TB Family has taken all mention of him off their pages and pages of posts also.

 

[Lilibet]

Those are the two that I have been following, however I think we are discussing the fact that the large posts of SC, (the witness who suddenly appeared) as well as all the comments following seemed to have gone ' poof ' on both the Community Board as well as the TB Family page. Mysterious...... The TB Family has taken all mention of him off their pages and pages of posts also.

Thanks. I noticed the purge of SC. I must have misunderstood regarding the actual pages or maybe @MsBetsy was referring to others.

 

[MsMarple]

These two pages are open. Is there another one?

Chatham Community Board

Tranberg-Bennett Family

Another minor family FB:
Tranberg Bennett
And the family's business/not business because they don't follow a macrobiotic diet:
House Of Macrobiotics

 

[MsBetsy]

These two pages are open. Is there another one?

Chatham Community Board

Tranberg-Bennett Family

Thanks! I don't know why it wouldn't work before. Those are the only two I'm aware of. I was trying to figure out what was being discussed about the deleted posts but now I'm so tired I don't think I can read anymore.

 

[Jane_Fox]

Thanks! I don't know why it wouldn't work before. Those are the only two I'm aware of. I was trying to figure out what was being discussed about the deleted posts but now I'm so tired I don't think I can read anymore.

There are others speaking re: Tranberg Bennett case, but they may not be avail to public view- (As well as newer comments on old news sources on FB or other areas family cannot control) Also Ive noted that anyone likely having “liked” ANYTHING (even without commenting) which is NOT the narrative they want... that FB person is also often blocked by them.Attempt a keyword search in FB or view the shares from their posts & a few public will surface.

 

[Jane_Fox]

Another minor family FB:
Tranberg Bennett
And the family's business/not business because they don't follow a macrobiotic diet:
House Of Macrobiotics

True... however that Tranberg Bennett Url link is NOT to a page but acting as a personal profile- which means that if one is blocked one cannot see (a page may block an individual but they will STILL be able to see just not interact- hope that makes sense?!)

 

[MsBetsy]

Thanks. I noticed the purge of SC. I must have misunderstood regarding the actual pages or maybe @MsBetsy was referring to others.

Yes, I was asking about the community page. Every single comment that was there earlier in the day seems to be gone now.

 

[Jane_Fox]

Yes, I was asking about the community page. Every single comment that was there earlier in the day seems to be gone now.

On FB when one DEACTIVATES there profile it is temporary but every post or comment ever made AND anything UNDER theirs eill disappear until reactivating

 

[CrimeAway]

I feel very sad that young Evanna died. I also feel for her younger relatives, who are must be experiencing a lot of uncertainty.

I hope that the authorities have done a thorough medical assessment of the other minor children, including looking at vitamin and mineral levels (and not just a standard CBC).

I support any family that seeks to feed a more wholesome and nutritious diet than the "Standard American Diet" (SAD). However, anytime an individual, especially a parent decides to limit/switch/drastically change the availability of major food groups, IMO, they have the RESPONSIBILITY to research any possible negative consequences, CONSULT with a QUALIFIED, licensed medical professional, and do blood tests at least once a year to monitor for any deficiencies or issues (Again, IMO).

Of course, Evanna's diet (candies not withstanding), may not even be central to this case, but my opinion on dietary differences would be the same.
I would think it even more pertinent if a sibling, or close family member had had previous nutrient deficiency.

Adequate macro nutrients (proteins, fats and carbohydrates), as well as micro nutrients (vitamins, minerals etc.), are very important to both physical and mental health. In fact, it is very interesting (IMO) to look at research on how nutrient deficiency can impact mental health, as well as physical.

I hope that all the facts can come out in court, that those charged have a fair trial, that her younger relatives are safe and cherished, and most importantly, that Evanna gets justice, and laid to rest with dignity.

 

[Sillybilly]

I honestly don't understand how someone who lost a child due to gross neglect can lay their head on the pillow every night and pretend they didn't do anything wrong.

IMO and based on personal experience, even parents who have had absolutely nothing to do with the death of their child can spend the rest of their lives wishing they had done something different.

 

[lozzalozlos]

Please accept my most sincere sympathy when your son entered and left this world 18 years ago. I can not imagine the pain.

No doubt each birthday has to be difficult, but there's no doubt your sweet son is with you always.

So unfortunate that Evana was not given the attention and concern or care.

Thank you, I think this is why I struggle with these child cases, some I cant even read. The TB family dont help themselves by blocking anyone that has a valid question, they delete comments and only keep those in favour of their unusual choices