Excellent video!
MOO
I may be mistaken, but I felt led to believe in the various things I had read pertaining to him being at the YMCA on December 11th, 2012, that it was common for him to run to the YMCA from his house on days he would go there.
If that is the case, then I would imagine that he normally would run from from his house, heading North towards Chenango Lake, and then head South-West on County Road 31 to Cooley Lake Road, down to 23 and run towards Norwich that route.
This route would equal in distance, roughly a quarter marathon in distance, meaning that if he ran it to and from the YMCA, he would roughly have ran a half a marathon distance in a day.
Factoring his ego, and his wanton need for attention, they tell me that he would attempt to stick to main roads to be seen by people (especially women that might ask him to flex for them, or to do his one-kneed "I'm king of the world" pose).
My guess would be that if he ditched the van in the parking lot of Plank Road Manor, he could very well have ran through the woods to the soccer field.
I think he would have went south though, heading down Canasawacta Street, which runs parallel to Broad Street.
Running down Canasawacta Street...
I believe Pleasant Street/SR 23 would be out of the question. I don't think that he would chance running past or near the church, out of fear of being seen or recognized.
It's possible that he may have wanted it to appear that he's running his normal route though, so it's possible that he could have ran towards Broad Street on Cortland Street (the same street and intersection that OffRoadRunner comes out to Broad Street on, across from the Methodist Church), and ran to the YMCA from there.
Henry Street doesn't come out to Broad Street, but ends in the back parking lot of the Howard Johnson Hotel. There is an alley way between Howard Johnson and the gas station on the corner of Cortland Street (site of the clothing drop box), that could have also been utilized in getting to the YMCA.
It's also possible he ran to Fair Street, and then came out to Broad Street there, which would end out right there with the YMCA and Mechanic Street to the left and across the street.
Any of these ways are possible.