OH - Pike County: 8 people from one family dead as police hunt for killer(s) #10

[Ann99]

Why would you even go in, if you already knew that 4 were dead at the other 2 residences? JMO

I think I would go in, hoping to find them OK, alive.

 

[creepcrusher]

Why would you even go in, if you already knew that 4 were dead at the other 2 residences? JMO

Probably thought the women and teenagers couldn't possibly be targeted like the men were. Plus Dana was his sister.

 

[cady]

And your not going to share?

ADT did share......it was at the Union Hill scene. Did not say who. JMO

 

[creepcrusher]

Seems like a lot of us are having this case stick with us into our subconscious thoughts. I'm totally on board with stepping away before bedtime. This case is not how I should be ending my nights.

My husband has got to be so annoyed with me. I'm constantly on my phone.

 

[rsd1200]

I'm going to have to go back and relisten and reread everything. These threads have messed me up in the head. LOL from my understanding of what was said by the AG and family. We know where KR,CRsr,DR, and GR were found. The rest we don't really know. If HR had just gotten home with a csection she could have been at one of the other houses or someone could have been up there with her since mom worked late. Or CRjr could have crashed at dads or his brothers. There may have been more than 4 properties searched in the first 2 days. From my recollection that was how I understood it. So I'm not sure the 2 outdoor grow ops were located at any of the 4 scenes. It's possible just one or both of the young ones were growing and the older ones didn't know. If they didn't hunt this year there would be know need to traipse all over the property. We don't know that dogs were missing. We just know they weren't outside which led BM to go inside. And that may not have been unusual. They may have been indoor outdoor dogs. I think I'm gonna step back and look at this all over. I still haven't thrown IJ out of the equation, he was selling that one car on FB. Uugh another car. I guess I need to see if he sold more.

I remember seeing at least one Coonhound, tied to a run, outside, at the very beginning on one of the news reports. I never understood why everyone was worried about the dogs. Was that reported somewhere in the paper that they were missing? I just figured she dropped in to see why FR was home, maybe see if they were sick or something, found they were dead, (maybe thought it was a murder suicide) and grabbed the kids and ran to CR1's and then found that horror, then called her Dad, then the cops. She probably tried to call her sister while waiting for her Dad and when she didn't answer then they started getting worried and went to her house.

 

[cady]

Probably thought the women and teenagers couldn't possibly be targeted like the men were. Plus Dana was his sister.

Possibly, but if he already knew that the kids at Frankies house were not victims, then even if he presumed that Dana's kids were also dead, what about the infant? As I said, it just bugs me. JMO

 

[Ann99]

Any ideas on who held all the money for the various enterprises?
One person?
Or divided among the Men?
Hidden in numerous places on the properties?
In the Bank?

 

[sallye818]

Video at link, much more info from one of a # of companies that hauled.

He says he and another worker helped tow five of a total of 18 vehicles away from the Rhoden property where eight members of the family were shot to death nearly two weeks ago.

http://myfox28columbus.com/news/local/up-to-18-vehicles-towed-from-pike-county-massacre-property

Neace said the cars were various makes and models with some missing parts such as engines.

He says investigators would not specify why specific vehicles were selected. He estimates a total of 40 vehicles were scattered in and around the property. He's not sure why the family had so many.

BBM, I know all these cars and parts MIGHT signify something illegal, but around here, "family junkyards" are common. People keep all types and pieces of cars/trucks just for spare parts and to "fix up" clunkers. My BIL has 20+ "junk cars" and he's always intending to "fix 'em up" but it never seems to happen, LOL. And if they were derby racing, doesn't sound all that unusual to me. But we shall see, all in good time.

 

[kbpirate]

I have about 5 different theories that I can make a solid argument for! You guys are amazing with your sleuthing. I just found this website while researching this case.

Dana was my age.I have a 20 year old son that I had when I was 17. The thought of both of the Hannahs there with their babies. The thought of what Hannah Gilley's mother is going through. It breaks my heart.

There are so many twists and turns in this case. The person or persons that did this had to be covered in blood. They couldn't have done it and not have to clean up and get rid of evidence. When were they killed?

 

[K.L.Puyallup]

My husband has got to be so annoyed with me. I'm constantly on my phone.

We should make a support group for them.

 

[K.L.Puyallup]

(delete)

 

[WVWoman]

My husband has got to be so annoyed with me. I'm constantly on my phone.

My husband drives a truck and is gone ..but when he talks to me he will ask anything thing new about the murders today? He has no clue how much of my time this has consumed!

 

[rsd1200]

It's still hinky to me. If it's true that BJ called her brother and Dad before calling 911, I get that. They were close to the scene. But I'm sure that given what she told them, they came ARMED. JMO And we really don't know the timeline of that.

I'd have definitely arrived armed and it couldn't have taken LM long to get there. According to records he lives on the same road. 1.5 miles away.

 

[mrssmith23]

I'm going through Hanna's profile, and I'm having trouble figuring out who the father of her baby is. There seem to be two men who, at various times, think the baby is theirs?

Can't be discussed.

 

[24Roses]

YOU ARE RIGHT!! Yes, he would have. This makes me think that he was killed first. JMO

IMO-Kenneth was killed 1st because who would go & kill him after killing 7 other people. I would think their exit of the area would want to be very fast. Unless of course there were multiple killers at multiple locations as some of you suspect.

 

[K.L.Puyallup]

Can't be discussed.

Oh, thanks for the heads up. I deleted my comment.
I guess there's no way to really talk about it without falling into the suspicion hole.

 

[creepcrusher]

My husband drives a truck and is gone ..but when he talks to me he will ask anything thing new about the murders today? He has no clue how much of my time this has consumed!

Lol. When my husband talks to me I have him repeat himself because I'm so wrapped up in all these theories and this case that it's all I think about. Poor guy. He asks me about it too, but I can tell he's getting irritated.

 

[Mmaaix]

I'm going through Hanna's profile, and I'm having trouble figuring out who the father of her baby is. There seem to be two men who, at various times, think the baby is theirs?

There are several rumors about this that have sparked quite a bit of drama. HR has 2 kids the older one was with family on the day of the murders. Because of the rules I cannot get into the logistics of it all.

 

[cujenn81]

(delete)

Deleted

 

[OccamsRazor]

Just as I expected, all of my predictions and theories about this case are being confirmed. Does anyone else have any questions? I am open for business and accept most forms of payment.