Omaha double murder

DNA Solves
DNA Solves
DNA Solves
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dundee slaying victim's dad: 'Keep this case alive'
BY JOHN FERAK
WORLD-HERALD STAFF WRITER



Omaha police say last year's horrific double slaying in the historic Dundee neighborhood remains "very much an active investigation." The FBI is assisting, and a $25,000 reward has been offered.




Tom HunterBut a mystery man seen in the neighborhood the day of the killings has vanished, and the families of the two victims are frustrated that no significant leads have panned out.

Tom Hunter, 11, and family housecleaner Shirlee Sherman were fatally stabbed in the Hunter family home one afternoon last March. Now, in his first interview, the father of the slain boy shares his fears that the case is at a standstill, and describes how painful it is each time he and his wife return to their now-empty home.

"Somehow we, the families, as well as the public, need to keep the pressure on to keep this case alive," said Dr. William Hunter III. "It is just killing us as a family, not knowing who and why."

This is the extent of what is online. The article was very good, had pictures of the family and of the victims. Of interest is that the police are saying Ms Sherman had over $800 in her purse but that was due to her getting paid by cleaning clients and collecting cash for some rental property earlier that day. There are details of how the dad discovered the bodies, said the boy was 'covered in blood'. The police are reminding readers of the reward and are posting web addresses and phone numbers for Crime stoppers.
The Hunters seem still blown away- they are still trying to fathom what happened. He mentioned there is nothing in their backgrounds he is aware of that could have triggered this.
 
I'm still inclined to think this was something between the boy and the killer. The housekeeper just happened to be there. Was it someone the boy knew from sports, school, the internet, church, scouts or a social organization?

I presume since the police say Ms. Sherman had over $800 in her purse that it was still there when they found her dead.
 
Tapu,

I sent an email to the news director at WOWT about their deletion and not posting messages from our members, here's the reply:

"Dear -----, Thanks for writing. Submitted comments are not published for a variety of reasons. Many of those concerning the Dundee murder investigation have been deleted because the authors have made allegations without basis or claiming facts that are untrue. We have to be very careful in what we allow to be published. Several members of the group Websleuths have made comments with incorrect info, including how the victims were killed. We cannot publish erroneous info, rumors, etc. We are not trying to stifle discussion on these boards, only to keep things as truthful as possible without slanderous, violent, obscene or hateful talk. Sincerely, Mark Schneider Web Producer, WOWT"

How about it, anyone in this group post anything that sounds like what they are saying??
This is a laugh, I can right now go to their news board and find any number of posted comments that are rumors and slanderous. What makes this case such a sacred cow??
By the way today's story was in the World Herald, WOWT is the local NBC TV affaliate. I am not going to pursue this with them for now but if anyone else wants to go ahead, I'd love it.
 
The web site of the OWH now has the full story posted, here it is:

Dundee slaying victim's dad: 'Keep this case alive'
BY JOHN FERAK
WORLD-HERALD STAFF WRITER



• Can you help?

RELATED

• Can you help?
Dr. William Hunter III had just one hint that something was amiss when he arrived home from work last March 13: His housecleaner's white Ford Taurus was parked in the driveway.




Tom HunterShirlee Sherman usually finished work about 4:30 p.m., so Hunter wondered for a moment why she still was there an hour and 15 minutes later. With his wife, Dr. Claire Hunter, out of town, Bill Hunter planned to spend the evening with his 11-year-old son, Tom.

Hunter had no idea of the horrific discovery he was about to make.

Moments after he walked in the back door, Hunter stopped to take off his coat. As he reached toward the coat rack, he saw Sherman's body slumped on the floor of a hallway.

The doctor yelled for his son. Tom didn't answer. Hunter ran downstairs, where he found his son's Xbox game system on pause. Hunter then ran back upstairs and into the dining room, where he found his son's body sprawled on the floor, covered with blood.

Tom and Sherman had both been fatally stabbed.

Last week, Hunter gave his first interview. He told The World-Herald he fears that the nearly year-old investigation has reached a standstill, and he wants to encourage people to share any information they might have with police. The family of Sherman, who had worked for the Hunters for about two years, shared similar concerns.

"Somehow we, the families, as well as the public, need to keep the pressure on to keep this case alive," said Hunter, 64. "It is just killing us as a family, not knowing who and why."

The daytime slayings jolted the historic Dundee neighborhood and the Omaha community. The stabbings claimed the lives of a sixth-grader at King Science and Technology Magnet Center and a 57-year-old woman who was a mother and grandmother.

Despite following up on hundreds of leads, authorities have made no arrests.

Omaha Police Lt. Kerry Neumann, who oversees the homicide unit, said the case remains "very much an active investigation."

Because of the ongoing investigation, Neumann declined to discuss many details of the case, including possible suspects and leads still being pursued. However, he said he does not consider the slayings to be a cold case.

"I have got my best people working on this thing. Sometimes these investigations take awhile before they are solved," he said. "This is still a workable case."

The FBI is assisting in the investigation, and a $25,000 reward has been offered for information that leads to an arrest.

Neumann said the Hunter family has been extremely cooperative, and no family members are considered suspects.

He said a big obstacle for detectives has been an inability to locate a man whom neighbors reported seeing outside the Hunter home on the afternoon of the slayings. The man reportedly was driving a sport utility vehicle with no front license plate.

A neighbor reported that the vehicle moved conspicuously down the street, starting and stopping as if the driver were looking for an address.

Because no neighbor wrote down the rear license plate number or called 911 when they saw the car, finding the vehicle has been difficult, Neumann said.

"Where do you start without a license plate?" he asked. "It's a general vehicle, and there are literally thousands of those."

Neumann said it remains important to locate and question the man.

"It is never too late to give information. We are following up on all leads," he said. "There is a very dangerous person still out there."

Hunter has spent the past 11 months trying to figure out who that dangerous person is. He remains baffled why anyone would want to kill his son.

He said no valuables were taken from the home. Sherman's purse was on the kitchen counter with $800 cash inside - money her family believes was from her cleaning business and a rental property. A new digital camera and lenses were in the living room, Hunter said.

"Was (Tom) in the wrong place or was it deliberate?" he asked. He also asks himself whether Sherman was the target.

"It's just devastated us. We're not sure what happened. Both Claire and I had a very uneventful, good life until this."

Hunter said Omaha detectives told him that they have found no evidence that the family was targeted. The Hunters also have three adult sons, ages 26, 23 and 21.

"We don't have gambling debts," Hunter said. "We have not been the targets of any threats."

Bill Hunter is a professor and the residency program director for Creighton University Medical Center's department of pathology. Claire Hunter is an associate professor of medicine and director of Creighton's cardiovascular fellowship training program.

Claire Hunter was in Hawaii for a conference when she heard from a friend that police were at her house. She reached her husband on his cell phone as he met with detectives. Bill Hunter gave his wife the dreadful news, and she immediately caught a flight to Omaha.

Bill Hunter said investigators probed his family's financial records, computers, e-mail accounts and phone records.

The Hunters and other Creighton faculty provided detectives with the names of a half dozen former medical residents and students who may have left the university disgruntled, Bill Hunter said. Police tracked residents to locations as far away as Mexico and Canada, he said.

Police identified the people who played online video games with Tom and checked on his school bus drivers.

Detectives reviewed delivery drivers and workers who had done remodeling or repairs to the family's house.

None of the leads panned out, Hunter said.

"Everyone, from the school principals to the teachers to the police . . . everyone says there was no reason to harm Tom," he said.

Brad Waite of Omaha, one of Sherman's brothers, said detectives also looked into Sherman's background.

Police questioned several of her relatives and acquaintances, according to Waite, but detectives told him nothing had come of those interviews.

In recent months, detectives inquired about possible romances in Sherman's life, Waite said. But Sherman, who was divorced, had not dated for more than 10 years, he said.

Sherman's family asked for a meeting with Omaha police last week. They, too, want to see more attention put on the case and asked if there was more they could do.

"We're obviously discouraged," said Dan Waite, another of Sherman's brothers. "Shirlee didn't have any enemies."

With more questions than answers, the Hunters still struggle to come home to the house they have lived in for 25 years. Still, they have no intention of moving.

"Even though they desecrated the house we loved, I am not afraid of living there," Bill Hunter said. "We have a lot of good memories of the house and our neighborhood. What do we do? Just disappear?"

As they try to move forward, Hunter said, family, neighbors and colleagues are a source of strength.

Hunter said he thinks the homicide unit is doing everything possible to solve the slayings.

"I trust them. They've been very kind and supportive and done a good job," he said. "As each month goes by, it gets more frustrating. Obviously, we are desperately seeking closure. Maybe a motive would go a long way in closure. I don't want it to be just random, but I know things like that happen."

Hunter said he misses terribly the life he shared with his youngest son.

The parents no longer have their son's beloved pet rabbit, Mopsy. One of his classmates agreed to take the pet after Tom's death.

On Saturday mornings, Hunter liked to watch Tom shoot baskets in YMCA basketball games. Afterward, father and son often went to Arby's or another restaurant for lunch.

In 2007, Tom vacationed with his parents in Europe. Family snapshots capture Tom smiling with his mother in England at the Tower of London and standing outside Edinburgh Castle in Scotland.

In between homework and video games, Tom rifled through the family's pantry for snacks.

"He was a junk food junkie," his father said. "He loved Doritos and Froot Loops."

Gone are the days of Tom peppering his parents with questions about his homework. Science was his favorite subject.

"Our house was hopping all the time," Hunter said. "Now it's just quiet."


• Contact the writer: 444-1056, john.ferak@owh.com
 
God Bless John Ferak!! He is so good at giving media attention to the cases in NE that are not receiving what they deserve. I think a national spotlight on this case and the Wood case is just what NE needs!!!

I am also curious who did the autopsy on the victims. Are they also void of medical abilities???
 
"God Bless John Ferak!! He is so good at giving media attention to the cases in NE that are not receiving what they deserve. I think a national spotlight on this case and the Wood case is just what NE needs!!!

I am also curious who did the autopsy on the victims. Are they also void of medical abilities???"

NSC, thanks for posting. I also feel a debt of appreciation to John for this very good story. I am sure it may be shaking things up a bit at OPD- they need to be.
What did you mean about the autopsies? To my knowledge nothing was released. Any coments would be appreciated.
 
That was an interesting article. Since robbery was not the motive, this case becomes even more baffling. I still can not understand why, with all the computer technology out there, that a make of auto located in a certain area cannot be easily narrowed down. If it was a Honda CRV, there cannot be thousands of them in the Omaha area. If there are, those Honda dealers must be living "high on the hog". I realize most searches on automobiles are done by tag numbers, but computer programs can be set up to search much deeper than a number only. Why can't they be set to search by color, make, model, age, etc., etc.? Can some computer genius fill me in please?
 
I feel bad even mentioning this but what kind of relationship did the older brothers have with the boy? Was there any jealousy or anything that could have caused any rage?
 
Peachy- that has been noted since the getgo as a posible factor. Do the math, Dr Hunter per the article in the WH is 64, his eldest son is 26 so he was 38 when his eldest was born. Was he married before, or for that matter was his wife? Any half siblings? No one seems to know.
I cannot seem to shake the feeling that the guy they saw may not be the killer. Maybe just a friend of Ms Shermans or someone looking for contracting or yard work, if illegal he may have skipped out right after to avoid immigration issues. I also have the feeling there is more going on here than meets the eye. Publishing this article now may be a ploy to get more evidence from the public to back up an arrest of someone they are 90% sure did this.
This may have been an issue between the killer and Ms Sherman and the boy simply came upstairs for munchies and saw too much. Just a few random thoughts.
 
That was a good article. I'm reading this thread for the first time. How frustrating. And how heartbreaking for the families.
The only thing that struck me is that the two were stabbed in the neck. It seems easier to stab someone in the torso. But maybe a medical student would go for the carotid. Although the article makes that sound like a dead end.
 
I just noticed today the Forensic Astrology forum on this site. Strange I never saw it before.
Anyone know how this works, can someone post details of a crime and get the take of someone versed in this or do they just post stories for comments.
I'd love to see what a good astrologer could say on this case. We know about when the murders happened, I do not know the victims' DOB but can try to get them from SS death index. Heck it's worth a try.
 
KETV, the Omaha ABC affiliate, had the murder as their top story tonight. Hopefully most of us locally got to see it. Currently there is no story on their webpage (ketv.com), but maybe they will post it when the newscast is over.
It was basically a recap of the OWH article yesterday, but it was nice to see the story heading up the news. They did show the suspect sketch at the end, we can only hope it will bring the lead they need.
 
This is a very strange case. It doesn't seem random but there doesn't seem to be any motive. The man in the CRV is almost certainly the killer. If he was just an innocent bystander, he would have come forward. The description of his driving through the neighborhood is very suggestive of someone looking for a specific address. It does seem to be a planned assasination.

If William were the target, say by a disgruntled Med student, afternoon (when he would be expected to be working) would be an odd time to go to his home. The same logic would apply to the wife who would not have normally been home at that time either. The son may have been targeted as "revenge" to get even with a parent. Either of the two victims could have been the intended target unrelated to the parents but it would probably be a "bizzare" motive that would involve mental illness. Such motives would be hard to anticipate. Of course, he could have gotten the wrong house. But, even if this were just a wrong victim "mistake", it would still be a very strange assasination.

Something that has occured to me is the possibility that this case is related to the bombing in West Memphis. The method of killing was obviously totally different, but they both appear to be "motiveless" assasinations against high profile Physicians. I wonder if LE has considered any connections?
 
Lots of local media involved now- link to WOWT:

http://www.wowt.com/home/headlines/39695952.html

They have a video of the coverage from last night with an interview by phone with Dr Hunter. There is a comment board- warning, be careful what you say if you post. They don't like 'speculation'.

KETV:

http://www.ketv.com/news/18726316/detail.html

That one has a slide show with family pictures of Tommy and his parents.

KMTV has a video:

http://www.kmtv.com/

The family appears to be finally realizing they need to be proactive and not depend on OPD to dig out what happened.

In the WOWT interview Dr Hunter mentions something not heard before- the suspect was seen in the yard next door before crossing over the lawn and up to their door. He seemed confused as to where he was going.
 
I just noticed today the Forensic Astrology forum on this site. Strange I never saw it before.
Anyone know how this works, can someone post details of a crime and get the take of someone versed in this or do they just post stories for comments.
I'd love to see what a good astrologer could say on this case. We know about when the murders happened, I do not know the victims' DOB but can try to get them from SS death index. Heck it's worth a try.


I have emailed the woman who runs this site a few times and she has done readings on two cases I suggested and is working on a third.

The site is ran by just one woman, Caroline, and she does all the readings herself and is very open to receiving suggestions from the public. Everytime I have emailed her she has responded. She needs to know the time the crime occured, the date and if you have the birthdays of the victims that could help her develop their chart more accurately but she doesn't need them.

Her email address is on the website. I would love to see her do a chart on this case and it certainly sounds like one she would be interested in especially since a child is involved. Good Luck!
 
In that article, the father states the boy's body was in the dining room. In the very next paragraph, the writer of the article says it was in the living room??????

Do you think that's just a typo?

I noticed that too. I'm not sure what to make of it.

The other thing I noticed is that last year all of the coverage said that Tom was upstairs playing video games and last night Dr Hunter said he was downstairs in the family room.
 
Lots of local media involved now- link to WOWT:

http://www.wowt.com/home/headlines/39695952.html

They have a video of the coverage from last night with an interview by phone with Dr Hunter. There is a comment board- warning, be careful what you say if you post. They don't like 'speculation'.

KETV:

http://www.ketv.com/news/18726316/detail.html

That one has a slide show with family pictures of Tommy and his parents.

KMTV has a video:

http://www.kmtv.com/

The family appears to be finally realizing they need to be proactive and not depend on OPD to dig out what happened.

In the WOWT interview Dr Hunter mentions something not heard before- the suspect was seen in the yard next door before crossing over the lawn and up to their door. He seemed confused as to where he was going.

Thanks for sharing that Snick (and thanks for always sharing and keeping this thread alive!), I didnt realize all of the stations were covering the story. It is interesting that it is getting so much coverage now. I wonder if it is the bandwagon effect, or if there was something specific that got all of the Omaha media interested. I was really shocked to see it as the lead in on 7 last night.

That is really interesting about the neighbors yard. That brings up a lot more questions for me....was it the wrong house? If he was having trouble finding the address I dont think he was local, I think its common knowlege how the addresses in Omaha are laid out (maybe thats just me though). Was he trying to get a better view of the house by going through the neighbors yard? Was he trying to make it look like he was going house to house, especially with that briefcase, maybe looking like a door to door salesman? So many questions! I will be happy when this is solved!
 
I would be interested to know if this housekeeper was out driving at all that afternoon. Did she pick the son up from school somewhere???

If she had been driving with Thomas in the car or not in the car. She COULD have had a run in of road rage of some type. The person could have followed her back to the house which would explain why her car was in a place that it was normally NOT. (father said he thought it was strange where her car was) -also seen was person walking between yards which could have indicated he was looking for the car to verify the house...- The person could have driven off and gathered knives (not sure what type) and gone back looking for the house he followed her to. It would make sense considering he was seen driving slowly like he didn't know what he was looking for type of scenario...having not been familiar this would make complete sense. It would also make sense why the murder weapons were left behind because he had NEVER had a personal link with the house or the victims. I do not think under any circumstance this was a professional hit, it doesn't add up. Way to sloppy and way to sloppy doing this during the daytime in the house.

I guess the other thing...being that there was an out of state plate -- could this indicate a student who was mentally unstable??? If someone was competant they most likely would have stalked out this house beforehand and been more familiar with the layout.

I also have to wonder…what types of surveillance videos are around town – even if the guy went to the local target to buy some knives would be interested If LE tapped all sources just to see if they could located this car in town that day. I know time consuming but they still have a chance to see videos if they archive for a year!!!! But that is going to expire and soon!!!!


What do you think???
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
109
Guests online
220
Total visitors
329

Forum statistics

Threads
608,996
Messages
18,248,334
Members
234,523
Latest member
MN-Girl
Back
Top