Beyond Belief said:
Any chance of finding out what city they were purchased? That would be place to start looking. I checked ancestry.com for people looking for lost relatives. Theres one there lost in Illinois, but didn't give age or anything.
Is there a website for Illinois with missing reports from way back in 1958?
I spoke with the current Case Officer about the contact lenses. They were made in Chicago, and also prescribed for the patient by a doctor there. Unfortunately, by the time cold case investigators tried to find the doctor, they learned that he had died, but they did locate and speak with the doctor's widow. She told them that before her husband had died, he sold his business, and transferred to the new owners all records. Subsequent searching by detectives, however, indicated that none of the doctor's patient records survive today. So Chicago, ILL does play a part in the mystery, but it is not known how long the man was associated with that city.
The brass key was most likely made by the Active Key and Lock company of that address in New York city. The authors of the poetry books also had New York college connections.
According to the Doenetwork and a few other sites, the rifle was sold in Fort Wayne, Indiana in 1939. This, however, could not have been correct information, as the rifle was described to me by the case officer as a Remington Model 721A, which was not made until 1948. It was last manufactured in 1962. So, until that can be cleared up, the information is suspect.
I think the most likely theory is that this man was a college student, who perhaps had studied in New York City. He was most likely traveling west in the spring of 1958 by motorcycle or possibly auto. Police origionally believed that he had been murdered, but some now think that he committed suicide. I have not seen the physical evidence which would support either conclusion.