That detail escaped me. I heard of the SoS sighting, but assumed it was the day of the drive.
Here are revealed Lewisburg sightings:
Lewisburg: 4/15/05 (Prior to 4:00 PM)
Around noon:
Ms. Snyder, saw Mr. Gricar and the Mini across from the Packwood House Museum.
Afternoon (possibly before 1:30 PM):
At least two other witnesses saw Mr. Gricar moving the car across from the Packwood House Museum.
4:00 PM-5:00 PM:
McKnight’s witness saw Mr. Gricar, driving the Mini, on Route 15 near the Country Cupboard.
Circa 5:30 PM:
At least two witnesses saw Mr. Gricar moving the Mini in the parking lot across from the Street of Shops. The Mini was seen parked there later.
At least two people, Mr. Alvey and another person saw Mr. Gricar in the Street of Shops at about the same time; at least one saw him with the “Mystery Woman.”
Lewisburg: 4/16/05
11:00 AM to Noon: Two employees, Mr. Bennett, see Mr. Gricar in Street of Shops.
6:30 PM
State Police Trooper spots the Mini Cooper in the parking lot across from the Street of Shops.
At some point over these two days, an additional witness saw RFG with the "Mystery Woman."
Now, bluntly, I have some problems with the 4/16/05 witnesses. Bennett was 90% sure it was him, but still the possibility they mistook someone else for him.
Note that the "Courthouse Sighting" was at 3:00 PM on 4/15/05.
If he was known to take off alone for days at a time (eg. Cleveland Indians game), he could have traveled for work and pleasure w/ the meeting just happening to be on the second day.
At least 8 people had him in Lewisburg at various points on 4/15/05.