SIDEBAR #43 - Arias/Alexander forum

[Bernina]

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 23s23 seconds ago
Martinez blasts the PTSD diagnosis. #jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 16s17 seconds ago
Now Martinez ridicules the alleged mitigating factor that #jodiarias was 27 years old. He notes her IQ.

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 31s31 seconds ago
Juan argues that the age factor is irrelevant. #jodiarias

Troy Hayden ‏@troyhaydenfox10 17s17 seconds ago
Juan says sure Jodi was young at the time of the crime, but she was also highly intelligent. "that needs to be considered." #jodiarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 24s25 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez discredits #JodiArias PTSD diagnosis and moves to listing former boyfriends #abc15 #TravisAlexander

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 15s16 seconds ago
Juan reminds jury that Abe told #JodiArias to let Travis Alexander go.

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 41s41 seconds ago
Juan is going over "age" Jodi tested high in intelligence and she understands #jodiarias #3tvarias

Troy Hayden ‏@troyhaydenfox10 30s30 seconds ago
She was mature for her age. Maybe more. Juan on #jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 40s40 seconds ago
Martinez: "Who was attempting to manipulate...?"

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 39s39 seconds ago
"Who was attempting to manipulate who?" Asks Juan. #jodiarias

 

[Bernina]

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 45s46 seconds ago
Juan describes Jodi being a manipulative person...to TA to Hughes...To Experts testing her....#jodiarias #3tvarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 37s38 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez - brings up mitigation factor considering #JodiArias maturity -- had many jobs, so she was mature #abc15

Troy Hayden ‏@troyhaydenfox10 46s47 seconds ago
Age is not a mitigating factor. Juan on #jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 39s40 seconds ago
"So no, age is not a mitigating factor in this case." Martinez on #jodiarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 1m1 minute ago
Juan says, "She was almost 28!" #jodiarias

Monica Lindstrom ‏@monicalindstrom 52s53 seconds ago
JM: #jodiArias never broke the law before...well give her a gold star

Troy Hayden ‏@troyhaydenfox10 47s48 seconds ago
She had no criminal history. That's an expectation of society. You don't give her a gold star. Juan on #jodiarias

 

[Bernina]

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 1m1 minute ago
JM-Jodi doesn't have a criminal record...OK #jodiarias #3tvarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 49s49 seconds ago
Objection "misstates the law) - Sidebar #JodiArias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 59s60 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez on age as mitigating factor: She #JodiArias is 27 not 19 or 20 -- Nurmi objects -- judge overrules. #abc15

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 32s33 seconds ago
JM-Isn't this the minimum that society expects from u...does she need a gold star? This isn't a mitigating circumstance #jodiarias #3tvarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 49s49 seconds ago
Juan says #JodiArais was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder but that doesn't give her the right to murder him. Sidebar

en's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 37s38 seconds ago
JM-Having BPD doesn't give you an excuse.....Nurmi says this misstates the law and we have a sidebar #jodiarias #3tvarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 32s33 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez: borderline personality disorder doesn't give you an excuse -- #JodiArias def atty Kirk Nurmi objects -- bench conf #abc15

 

[Chelly]

Nurmi is cutting into Juan's time. I hope he goes over to tomorrow

 

[Bernina]

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 46s46 seconds ago
My wish of a short recess during that sidebar didn't happen - we're back #JodiArias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 33s34 seconds ago
Juan restates being diagnosed with borderline personality disorder doesn't provide an excuse for what happen. #JodiArias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 18s19 seconds ago
JM-BPD doesn't indicate she doesn't know right from wrong and it's not an excuse #jodiarias #3tvarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 42s42 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez must've won argument bc he came back saying "As I told you borderline personality disorder isn't an excuse" #JodiArias #abc15

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 25s26 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez: Borderline Personality Disorder doesn't speak 2 violence. It doesn't say its an excuse to murder somebody. #JodiArias #abc15

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 25s26 seconds ago
Juan reminds jury that #JodiArias peeked in TA's home after break up, (found him kissing someone else.)

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 48s48 seconds ago
Juan says #JodiArias does know the difference from right and wrong. BPD is a personality trait.

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 45s45 seconds ago
Juan has come back up volume wise, it's not easy to hear in this court room unless people are speaking at louder volumes #JodiArias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 1m1 minute ago
JM-BPD talks about a personality trait....it doesn't give someone an excuse to murder someone #jodiarias #3tvarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 1m1 minute ago
The bailiff is on the main door, I don't think they want anyone moving around after the Alexanders walked out before

 

[Bernina]

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 50s50 seconds ago
Martinez says BPD is not an excuse. Nurmi objects that he misstates the law. Mitigation is not excuses.

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 1m1 minute ago
JM-It's a descriptive term for how she acts..Nurmi is objecting this misrepresents the law #jodiarias #3tvarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 1m1 minute ago
Several objections and sidebars within a matter of minutes. #JodiArias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 1m1 minute ago
And we have another sidebar #jodiarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 1m1 minute ago
#JuanMartinez: BPD describes how someone acts Former BF's said she was clingy - Nurmi objects 3 more x's #JodiArias #abc15

 

[Bernina]

...anyone else have a headache.............?

 

[Chelly]

I do not like Nurms

 

[Chelly]

...anyone else have a headache.............?

Yes and stiff neck and sore jaw from clenching teeth and a sugar high.

 

[YESorNO]

...anyone else have a headache.............?

Want me to take over?

 

[Bernina]

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 37s37 seconds ago
#joidarias talks to Maria during sidebar #3tvarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 12s12 seconds ago
Jury either looks down or at the bench during this sidebar #JodiArias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 57s57 seconds ago
I may be having #JodiArias "objection" nightmares tonight. #abc15

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 48s48 seconds ago
We're sizzling so I'm reading Kiefer's text messages over his shoulder. #jodiarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 57s58 seconds ago
Very large IMO - I believe there's 80 seats for fam/friends/press etc...

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 37s37 seconds ago
Juan says BPD is NOT a mitigating factor because it does not have anything to do with his murder. #JodiArias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 48s49 seconds ago
Jodi is finally looking up. Looks like she's got her eyes on the back of Juan #JodiArias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 38s39 seconds ago
Male jurors taking notes as Juan says BPD doesn't justify murder. #jodiarias

 

[Chelly]

someone just tweeted. You can't do objection and sidebar drinking game during this one.

 

[Bernina]

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 58s59 seconds ago
JM-PTSD isn't a mitigating factor in this case. It doesn't have anything to do with her murdering Travis #jodiarias #3tvarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 52s53 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez won again:"As I said b4 BPO isn't a mitigating facto -- it talks about fear of abandonment not about murder #JodiArias #abc15

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 46s47 seconds ago
Martinez says BPD has nothing to do with the murder and doesn't count as a mitigating circumstance. #jodiarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 55s55 seconds ago
#JodiArias has a fear of abandonment. There was no physical or emotional abuse with Travis. They both enjoyed relationship.

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 15s15 seconds ago
#JodiArias looked up for a second. Looked pathetic, not in a mean way. Meaning defeated.

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 34s35 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez brings up #JodiArias "tumulteous relationship" as a mitigating factor: What tumulteous relationship? They had sex. #abc15

 

[Bernina]

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 21s22 seconds ago
I'm curious to see how much Juan goes back to the murder before he's done #JodiArias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 35s35 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez brings up that age is not a factor -- you don't have to be a certain age to commit a crime #JodiArias #abc15

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 34s34 seconds ago
JM telling jury JA drove from Yreka to Mesa to see TA after all these alleged acts, They engaged in a sex call...they enjoyed it #jodiarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 33s33 seconds ago
You don't have to be a certain age to commit a crime. That's not a mitigating factor. #JodiArias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 1m1 minute ago
Juan says #JodiArias being 27 doesn't justify murder or we could all get away with it.

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 29s30 seconds ago
Ok her head is back down #JodiArias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 52s52 seconds ago
Juan says #JodiArias left house because she was grounded, not abused.

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 37s38 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez moves 2 #JodiArias childhood abuse as mitigating factor-She didn't leave the house bc of abuse, but bc she was grounded #abc15

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 43s43 seconds ago
Juan says the records show Jodi was a spoiled child...he will leave it to jury to see if she was an abused child #jodiarias #3tvarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 28s28 seconds ago
Juan is talking about remorse now. This should be good. #JodiArias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 13s13 seconds ago
#JodiArias is talking out of both sides of her mouth.

 

[Bernina]

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 23s24 seconds ago
Martine now going through the list of mitigators and knocking each one down. #jodiarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 38s38 seconds ago
Kiefer is about to misspell Martinez I can see it over his shoulder #jodiarias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 37s37 seconds ago
JM-Jodi was grounded when she was caught cutting class and she moved out of her parents house and in with Bobby #jodiarias #3tvarias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 19s20 seconds ago
JM saying Jodi isn't remorseful #jodiarias #3tvarias

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 7s7 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez: #JodiArias is so remorseful she can say she is sorry at the same time say -- (make up stories about #TravisAlexander) #abc15

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 16s16 seconds ago
Still a bit of note taking going on amongst the jurors #JodiArias

 

[Chelly]

Hope Juan uses same line as at first trial. "Don't carry Jodi's gas cans for her"

 

[Bernina]

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 36s36 seconds ago
someones iPhone alarm is going off, bailiff can't figure it out - turns out it's his, quick laugh #JodiArias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 44s44 seconds ago
Cell phone went off and people were about to get a pat down when all the sudden the bailiff realized it was his...lol #jodiarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 43s44 seconds ago
Juan says have we forgot why we are here as he holds up graphic, autopsy photos. #JodiArias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 31s32 seconds ago
Juan goes from different picture of TA's neck wound to childhood photo to neck wound. #jodiarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 59s60 seconds ago
Juan went back and fourth between Jodi pic and autopsy pic #jodiarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 39s40 seconds ago
Sisters look down as neck wound on the screen. #jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 1m1 minute ago
Martinez juxtaposes a Travis Alexander slit-throat photo with one of the photos of #jodiarias as a child.

MaryEllen Resendez ‏@maryellenabc15 37s37 seconds ago
#JuanMartinez says he will leave it up to the jury to decide if #JodiArias was abused or a spoiled child #abc15

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 19s19 seconds ago
Juan puts up pic of TA's neck almost cut off. Then puts up Jodi's pic as a child. #jodiarias #3tvarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 26s26 seconds ago
Juan reminds jury of Tanisha saying she just wishes she could hear TA's voice. Juan says she can't bc of #JodiArias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 14s14 seconds ago
JM is talking about impact statements by family wanting to hear TA's voice but can only see the pics of him murdered #jodiarias #3tvarias

 

[Bernina]

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 28s29 seconds ago
More graphic, autopsy photos are being displayed. States position is there are no mitigating factors. #JodiArias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 48s48 seconds ago
Sounds like Martinez is winding down. He is quoting jury instructions. #jodiarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 14s15 seconds ago
Wilmott looks to be watching the jury, Nurmi on Juan, Jodi head down #JodiArias

Cathy ‏@courtchatter 30s31 seconds ago
Tanisha wants to hear travis's voice but can't, Juan puts up slit throat pic. #jodiarias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 22s22 seconds ago
Seems like Juan is coming to an end, going over jury instructions around mitigation #JodiArias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 10s10 seconds ago
Juan tells jury It tells you to return a verdict of death. #JodiArias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 2m2 minutes ago
JM-If you agree there is no mitigation you shall return a verdict of death #jodiarias #3tvarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 1m1 minute ago
Juan reads jury instructions to jury and stresses how important it is that they follow the rules #jodiarias

Jeffrey Evan Gold ‏@jeffgoldesq 45s46 seconds ago
#JodiArias Juan puts up bobby juarez photo objection sidebar

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 35s35 seconds ago
Looking at photographs you see a living individual....Juan puts up Jodi's pic's..smiling Objection #jodiarias #3tvarias

 

[Bernina]

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 22s23 seconds ago
he's using the same pics nurmi did #CalledIt #JodiArias

Jeffrey Evan Gold ‏@jeffgoldesq 31s32 seconds ago
Juan putting up defense photos of smiling jodi then back to slashed neck in #JodiArias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 28s29 seconds ago
Juan putting up all the pic's Nurmi did of Jodi Now putting up autopsy pic's of TA #jodiarias #3tvarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 31s32 seconds ago
The sister that looks the most like Travis leaves sobbing uncontrollably, hard to witness. #jodiarias

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 40s40 seconds ago
I'm asking you apply these jury instructions and do your duty. #JodiArias The bell now tolls for each and every one of you.

Tammy Rose ‏@News20Chopper 31s32 seconds ago
Juan ends with I'm asking you to remember the victim. #JodiArias

Jeffrey Evan Gold ‏@jeffgoldesq 39s39 seconds ago
Do your duty, asks Juan to jury, and return a verdict of death to #JodiArias

Jarrett Seltzer ‏@JarrettSeltzer 48s48 seconds ago
After a few pics of jodi he put up the autopsy picture and said "look at that smile" - pretty impactful - Juans done - Sidebar #JodiArias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 41s41 seconds ago
Juan ends in a whisper. I couldn't hear his final words.

#jodiarias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 1m1 minute ago
One of the sister's (Natile??) ran out crying #jodiarias #3tvarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 1m1 minute ago
Martinez juxtaposes a photo of #jodiarias and Alexander with another slit-throat photo. One of Alexander sisters runs crying from the room.

Cathy ‏@courtchatter 1m1 minute ago
Hillary ran from the room. She's sobbing outside #jodiarias

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 1m1 minute ago
You can still hear TA's sister crying from courtroom.

#jodiarias

Beth Karas ‏@BethKaras 48s48 seconds ago
The state's summation in #jodiarias is finished. Court is adjourned until tomorrow. Emotional afternoon for the victim's family.

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 35s35 seconds ago
Juan asks for a sentence of death and we are done for the day....jury is goneI can hear the sisters crying in the victim room #jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 54s55 seconds ago
Martinez asked the jury for death. Stephens calls it a night. Alexander's sister can still be heard sobbing violently in the victims' room.

Troy Hayden ‏@troyhaydenfox10 44s45 seconds ago
#jodiarias done for day. Rebuttal by Nurmi tomorrow, then jury gets case.

Wild About Trial 2 ‏@WildaboutTrial2 1m1 minute ago
Jury exits. Tanisha crying. Siblings rushing to check on their sister. #jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 1m1 minute ago
Other family members crying as they leave the courtroom. #jodiarias

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 40s41 seconds ago
Horrible to hear them crying! I feel so bad.....#jodiarias

Michael Kiefer ‏@michaelbkiefer 11s12 seconds ago
Defense gets one more shot tomorrow morning. Then Stephens will read final instructions, pick alternates and send the jury to deliberate.

 

[Bernina]

Jen's Trial Diaries ‏@TrialDiariesJ 27s28 seconds ago
Return tomorrow at 9:30am MST for Nurmi #jodiarias #3tvarias