Thanks I think everyone on the forum is free to put forward their theories - that’s what being a ‘sleuth’ is all about and is what makes this platform interesting. I’m not wildly speculating about the couple having financial difficulties - I know first hand the cost of living in France, I believe that house-sitting doesn’t produce an income as it’s offered unpaid in return for the accommodation, I know that self published books rarely make any money, I’m aware that renting out a property to pay the mortgage rarely makes a profit after costs are taken into consideration. When additional unexpected lifestyle expenses above the norm are taken into account, like having to pay for dental treatment, dog sickness or having to pay for travel to the UK for any reason, these costs add up MASSIVELY. Also, ED apparently had little food, had queried the cost of one purchase... If you were to produce a factual breakdown of Income/Expenditure related to this couple’s lifestyle then the document would most probably show they were in severe dire straits.
Just to counterbalance your experience, having spent the last 6 years travelling around Europe, 3 to 5 months at a time, I can absolutely confirm that it's cheaper than living at home in England. We usually stay on campsites and always self cater.
In those 6 years we have been to France 10 times, the last trip was in July, August & September last year - totally legally.
Fuel costs are cheaper everywhere in Europe, with the exception of Italy and Scandinavia. Food in supermarkets can be expensive, however if you plan ahead and shop in Lidl or Aldi, prices are much the same as the the UK - except for meat which is a little more expensive. However in the mountains the shop are of the 7-11 type - poor choice\quality and price. This will be the case in Benasque, which is literally at the end of the road.