Clipped from the article:
City police Chief Timothy J. Longo has asked the council for more than $725,000 to fund additional officers to work the mall, but to no avail. He offered a scaled-back version of the plan costing less than $500,000, but still did not get the money. Instead, the City Council in 2012 approved the Downtown Mall ambassadors program, made up of part-time liaisons who help visitors navigate the mall and act as “eyes and ears” for police.
I wonder if the WG was one of the ambassadors hired to help the police. It would explain a lot.
The argument is basically predicated on believing what the doorperson claims she saw.
If she was manning the door she would see who was going in. She claimed that JM was behaving in such a way outside that she took notice of him, so much so that she claimed to remember him when she saw him walk by with HG. And she said she saw him leave earlier, but no mention of him returning. So, if she remembered him from his behavior outside earlier, why would she not have remembered him coming back in if she still remembered him when he left? That does not make sense and suggests that parts of the story are not credible. The question is which parts?
We know that drinks were bought with JM's credit card at around 1:10, but it is also possible that he gave the card to a friend and never actually returned to the restaurant at all.
Alternatively, his car was parked nearby, and he went there to retrieve something before returning to the bar. That would be a reasonable explanation for leaving and then returning shortly afterwards. If that happened then we would have to discount the story told by the doorperson, since he apparently come back past her to get in.
What bothers me is that the time between encountering HG and him returning to the bar is relatively short. It does not leave a whole lot of time for conversation with a stranger, which you would expect to take a decent chunk of time if he somehow befriended her. But there is literally a couple of minutes at most for them to become best buds after being complete strangers. This does not seem very realistic to me unless he already knew her.Taken all together I am inclined to discount the eye witness accounts. Which would imply that other than passing in the street, the two of them never met or communicated, and that HG never went into or around the restaurant. In that scenario she would have just continued on her way.
I agree....wondering could JM have let HG in the side door once he was in??? Then they both exit the side door.
He said the witness contacted police through a hotline, on which police had received 100 tips. He did not release the name of the witness, who he said played phone tag with investigators before voluntarily coming to the police department around 10 p.m. Wednesday.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/local...662674-3f42-11e4-9587-5dafd96295f0_story.html
After police released the surveillance footage, the witness came forward to report that he was the man seen following Graham in downtown Charlottesville.
snip
Pleasants said the surveillance videos released by police do not show the unidentified man.
Was that the police interpretation of the video or what the WG told them? If WG saw the video, it seems to me he'd recognize JLM as he's passing directly in front of the camera. He's pretty damned hard to miss.
View attachment 60144
The side door is on the left in this image, and the main entrance door is where you see the sidewalk sign. I imagine that's where Abby the ID Checker was standing, and the side door is where she says she saw JL exiting. Both entrances face 5th Street. Behind this is a narrow alley way with dumpsters, so the smoking section must've been right here in front of the building. If HG was hanging outside waiting for JL, she most likely would've been standing right here in this area. I see no reason for her to be around the corner on Water St. I wonder how many people were outside mingling that night.
Do we know what section of 4th St. JL parked his car on? Was it 4th and Water St.? If so, why did he and HG walk back towards the Mall? I think it would've been faster to walk to the corner of Water St. and then walk one block down.
Cant help but notice thats one hell of a blind spot in that alcove. Unless the door person were standing in the middle of the sidewalk and scanning both directions, JLM could have easily let HG in without it being seen.
Didn't someone post a photo above of the interior of the restaurant that showed (for lack of a better term) glass paneled garage doors that lead out to a patio? Were they up that night?
I found this image on Google image search:
http://www.c-ville.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/062113_EATS_0396-1024x682.jpg
It's from this page:
http://www.c-ville.com/photos-of-charlottesville-restaurant-week/#.VCgmBOdflLU
They don't lead to a patio however, just the sidewalk.
I think regardless of what happened BEFORE JM and Hannah disappeared from any eye witnesses and cameras is not the focus as much as what happened AFTERWARDS.
It's pretty clear Hannah was going willingly with JM Drunk and confused, but not fighting him. In fact so agreeable, that those who noticed her being distressed, backed off when JM was in the picture and walked off with her No one is saying that Hannah was being dragged off.
There is one story that she was so out of it that he was carrying her. That she could barely stand on her own. That hits me as odd, since she is seen very much able to walk on her own, even run. If that could be substantiated, it is possible that she was slipped something that is very fast acting --one beer, JM supposedly bought 2, isn't going to do that so quickly even on top of what she'd had. Not unless something else was added to it Then he just had to help her to his car, which allegedly was parked very near Tempo, and off he'd go.
The other reason, I think this might have happened is because JM's face has no marks on it If Hannah was attacked, coerced, it's likely he'd have marks on his face. I'm sure LE is checking out other body parts too, but I'm betting there was no fight since the face,neck area is usually the target. She's a big strong,young woman and would have fought if he went after her unwanted.
<modsnip>
As to the quoted post (BBM):
Evidence of force is force.
Absence of evidence of force is not force.
Her poor judgement is not evidence of force.
Lack of information of her whereabouts is not evidence of force, it isn't even circumstantial evidence of force. It is just absence of information.
Prosecutors lose jurors to reasonable doubt when they say something exists but don't provide evidence, or when they say something is evidence of something else (but it really isn't).
I think it is fine to acknowledge that during all of the visible portions of her time with JM, that HG agreed to be with him. That concept should not be offensive, it should be informative and invoke discussion. Why did she not leave while she could? (Discussing the answer to this question could help prevent loss of other daughters, and no I don't have a personal interest in JM's "innocence.")
I have personally wondered what JM could have offered to make HG choose to stick around. Some have suggested protection, familiarity, a promised ride.
I wonder if it was need, if she stayed to help HIM with something, as was her nature. Did he say he lost something, or was lost himself, or was depressed?
It is just a question of whether her personality was shining through her intoxication (at whatever level that might have been.)
Apparently a common tactic of child predators is to ask for help finding a missing dog. What was JM's strategy, besides removing socks?
Was that the police interpretation of the video or what the WG told them? If WG saw the video, it seems to me he'd recognize JLM as he's passing directly in front of the camera. He's pretty damned hard to miss.
Clipped from the article:
City police Chief Timothy J. Longo has asked the council for more than $725,000 to fund additional officers to work the mall, but to no avail. He offered a scaled-back version of the plan costing less than $500,000, but still did not get the money. Instead, the City Council in 2012 approved the Downtown Mall ambassadors program, made up of part-time liaisons who help visitors navigate the mall and act as eyes and ears for police.
I wonder if the WG was one of the ambassadors hired to help the police. It would explain a lot.