:cow:
How could a not-so-strong 9yo boy possess the physical ability to dress a body of dead weight in order to maneuver a pair of panties and the leggings onto the naked body of his dead sister? I don't think BR could nor would construct then pull the garrote hard enough to do the damages that were done during the strangulation.
Do you think BR placed duct tape over her mouth and used piece of a sharp toy train part or a stun gun to harm his own sister's face? Had the same thing happened to BR in the past?
Did BR lure JBR, who detested the basement, down into the unpleasant basement for his own selfish purpose? To assault his 6yo sister? Or to kill her intentionally?
Why was going into the basement so important to BR? Had he schemed and developed this plan or game with his sister for a long time?
How would the ruse of searching the unopened gifts lead to a severe head bash while hanging then the final garroting?
I admit that I don't understand the BDI theory so these are sincere queries. otg has meticulously explained the best BDI theory to date and it still doesn't hold water for me mostly due to his young age with the tiredness he must have felt from a month of festivities coupled with JBR not willing to be being cooperative. She was zonked after the Ws party.
I don't think BR was sexually active with his sister. Sadly, someone else was molesting JBR.
DeDee,
With BDI the common error people make is to mix up likely staging with JonBenet's original assault.
Here are some common sense BDI assumptions:
1. It all started upstairs, say in JonBenet's bedroom or the breakfast bar?
2. After being sexually assaulted and whacked on the head someone moved JonBenet down to the basement. She may have been dragged from the breakfast bar, consider the abrasions on her body?
Here are some common sense staging assumptions:
3. JonBenet was cleaned up, removing most external blood-stains and redressed in the size-12's, the white long johns, and the white gap top.
4. She was then turned onto her stomach and ligature asphyxiated, then the paintbrush was broken and fashioned as seen in the autopsy photographs.
5. At some point, either stage 3. or stage 4. JonBenet may have been internally assaulted with the paintbrush, as staging this has never officially been confirmed and a piece of the paintbrush is missing.
6. JonBenet is wrapped in the blanket, and hidden away somewhere in the basement.
7. The bloodstained pink barbie nightgown is placed into the wine-cellar along with the partially opened Christmas gifts and the barbie doll, i.e. relocating and hiding forensic evidence.
Some points to consider: both PR and JR are directly linked to the wine-cellar via forensic evidence, PR's fibers are on items that could
not have arrived accidentally, similarly with JR. The pink barbie nightgown has JonBenet's blood on it along with BR's touch-dna, this links BR to the crime-scene.
If the case is IDI then none of the R's should have related forensic evidence at the crime-scene.
Since all three R's have forensic evidence located on wine-cellar items, then the case is RDI.
Furthermore the forensic evidence suggests all three R's undertook various parts in the death and staging of JonBenet.
The Grand Jury charged the parents with assisting an offender and committing child abuse.
That leaves one unnamed R as the person in receipt of the parents assistance.
.