JudgeJudi
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2014
- Messages
- 10,620
- Reaction score
- 31,357
I agree. Depends what he said. Let's imagine he was two-timing Reeva and the messages were from the other person. He might say to his brother, could you get rid of them as it will look bad and paint him in a bad light. He's done nothing wrong, of course, it was an accident, but you know how it looks ...
Who the other person was or what was being discussed might also have some bearing but I could speculate all night. I'm just trying to figure a plausible scenario for what actually happened that evening that led up to Reeva's death, so am exploring a lot of possibilities. I put them up here to let others put me straight or develop them. It all helps!
I have to ask though, why else did the phone disappear unless Oldwage had it all along!
Possibly Carl had it first and looked back through the messages before handing it over to Oldwage. Perhaps Carl was trying to find out if it was possible to delete the messages without being caught, but if so, I think he would have had to have done it very surreptitiously so suspicions weren't raised. 11 days is a very long time and is more than a little suspicious to me.