Things that have me puzzled.
Brother looks out window and thinks its her b/f so thinks nothing of it. He doesnt see the b/f's vehicle???
Blood is supposedly found.'
If you were just hit or wounded would you still hold on to your lunch box?? Would you be "just walking" with the attacker???
If a perp had an abducted female, in the vehicle, while fleeing down a road, why would they be throwing items of the abducted females out the window like a lunch box??? If you think as to not have any evidence in the vehicle, well, theory is she is in the vehicle herself.
How did the perp get to the house?? If by foot or 4 wheeler, he lived very very close. If by vehicle, and then walked thru the woods, he had to know the area veryyy good, meaning, he lives close or hunts there. Brother never said he saw a vehicle or heard one that has been reported. Also, as much rain as that area has gottten lately, it would be easy to see their tracks. In areas as that, you expect to see "boot" tracks. I wouldnt think she had boots on.