Since we lost a lot of the Topix thread online (many people did copy it before it disappeared!), here is the timeline I've gathered so far. Please feel free to add or correct it anytime! This information was gathered from comments made at the old Topix thread:
August 2003 – Jennifer and Adrianna moved to Joey B’s barn (per Joe B Sr.)
Fall 2003 – Jennifer and Adrianna moved into apartment with Jenn’s mom (per Kathy H)
Mid-Dec 2003 – Jennifer beaten and Adrianna kept by Jenn’s sister. Joey kicked in a door and was arrested. (Joey cleared of charges later) (per Joe B Sr.)
Dec 21, 2003 – Jennifer and Adrianna moved back to Joey B’s barn (per Kathy H)
Dec 25, 2003 – Joey made Adrianna (aka Nina) a rocking horse and playhouse for Christmas (per Carrole B)
Jan 15, 2003 – Jennifer (Jenn) had birthday party for Nina at B’s house with Jenn’s family in attendance (per Carrole B)
January 2004 – Jennifer and Adrianna moved into Joey’s parent’s home from the barn because it was cold. Jenn and Joey began to argue because Jenn wanted to move back into the barn (per Carrole B) Jenn wanted to move back into the barn because she and Joey’s parents didn’t get along (per Kathy H)
March 24, 2004 – Jenn calls her mom and is upset about the situation where she was living (per Kathy H) Jenn calls her mom (per Joe B Sr)
March 25, 2004 – Jenn calls her dad and her aunt voicing concerns about her living conditions (per Kathy H) Jenn tells Joey that she has a plan to leave and calls her dad and her aunt (per Joe B Sr) "YOU MAY FOOL SOME PEOPLE JOE, BUT I WAS THERE. JENNIFER TOLD ME PERSONALLY THE DAY SHE DISAPPEARED AT A LITTLE AFTER 1 PM THAT SHE WAS HOME ALONE WITH YOU AND WAS AFRAID TO COME OUT OF HER ROOM. SHE HAD SPOKEN WITH ME EVERY FEW MINUTES FOR THAT ENTIRE WEEK THAT I WAS ON VACATION. SHE TOLD ME IN OUR LAST CONVERSATION THAT SHE WOULD CALL ME BACK IN A FEW MINUTES. YOU DID WHATEVER YOU DID TO THEM SHORTLY AFTER 1 PM THEN CALLED YOUR SON HOME TO HELP YOU CLEAN UP YOUR MESS. YOU CAN LIE ALL YOU WANT TO WHOEVER IS STUPID ENOUGH TO LISTEN BUT I KNOW THE TRUTH AS WELL AS YOU DO.. SO WHAT'S WRONG WITH TELLING THE TRUTH IS THAT IT LANDS YOUR SORRY *advertiser censored* IN PRISON WHERE YOU BELONG. AND WE ALL KNOW THAT U CALLED JOEY HOME FROM WORK EARLY THAT DAY AND INSTRUCTED HIM ON WHO NOT TO RIDE HOME WITH. IRONICALLY MY BEAUTIFUL HUGE HEARTED NEICE THOUGHT THAT JOEY WOULD KEEP HER AND THE BABY SAFE. GUESS HE JUST DIDN'T GET THERE IN TIME." (per aunt Lisa)
Quote From Jenn's Beloved Aunt Lisa (Post #3214
March 25, 2004 – (evening) Jenn asks Joey to take her and Nina to I-65 N exit 112. Joey watches as they get into the back seat of a white 4 door car. (per Joey)
March 26, 2004 – Jenn went to Joey’s house without Nina in the white car he’d seen her in the night before. She wanted to pick up her tax return, but it was not there. This was the last time he saw her. (per Joey) The Bentons had a huge bonfire and partied it up. (Per Lucy) Joe and Joey helped look for the girls with Lisa. They said she was with some people that lived in a trailer. (they were out of town) – per Lucy
March 27, 2004 – LE came to Joe’s home (per Joe B Sr)
March 28, 2004 – Police searched Joe’s home (per Joe B Sr)
March 30, 2004 – Cadaver dogs searched Joe’s land and his father’s and brother’s properties (per Joe B Sr)
April 1, 2004 – TBI took the Bs computer, phone records and asked for polygraphs of which they agreed (per Joe Sr) Joey passed polygraph (per Kathy H)
Oct 21, 2005 – Girls featured on Montel (no leads)
Jan 28, 2006 – Girls were on America’s Most Wanted (no leads)
March 2006 – LE searched property with sonar equipment? (unverified)
March 2008 – Gunfire at memorial for girls. Tombstones defaced. Witness saw Joey jump over a fence (media and memorial attendee reports)