I don't mean to sound dumb but could he have used a chain saw to start a hole in the ice? Most of us have those in the garage/shed. He could have explained the noise to the boys by saying that he needed to go cut some wood for the fire to make s'mores?
I HATE the idea that he may have done that to her. Don't some ice fisherman use the same holes that others have already made? (I guess if you can see them through the snow) If someone uses the hole he made, then she may be found sooner than spring. Poor Susan.
Great idea, Breathe! Much lighter and so much easier to transport than an auger and a generator. He still would have been exposed enough to get frostbitten. I have been sitting here mulling the coordination of a heavy generator and an auger.
How far would he have had to schlep the generator from the car to the dig sight?
How far would he have had to schlep the auger from the car to the dig site.
Then there is the schlepping of both items back to the van after he was done with the disposal.
Course, if he had the van and generator in one area, he'd still need considerable cordage for power to drill through the ice. Can't imagine it was cold enough the ice would've been thick enough to support a van, is where I'm going with this.
There is also a possiblity he lied and said 'generator' when indeed all he really had was just a gas powered auger, or perhaps even a chainsaw. Maybe he thought mentioning a generator in this kind of weather outdoors is 'general' enough of an excuse to not raise suspicion (generator tied in to power outage and so on), whereas au auger might be more quickly connected to his ill deeds. And a chain saw could just as easily be used, I would imagine.
For me, I take what he says with a grain of salt; I keep remembering that Jovanna said Susan wasn't feeling well and went to lie down. When Josh returned with the rental and the reporter went to him as he got out of the car, he said in that interview that, no, Susan was not ill and that she was feeling fine. Its really hard to know what, if anything, he's been truthful about.
Againk, he's not a bright bulb.