VERDICT WATCH VA - Johnny Depp's defamation case against ex Amber Heard, who countersued #10

[makayla]

Smashing kitchen cabinets is not domestic abuse

 

[katydid23]

It is a dumb choice for Rottenborn to show the cabinet video---after we all know she set it up, then secretly sold it to TMZ and gave them the copyright and she lied about it

Then he lies and denies she sold it to them--'but she was on a plane' ....lmao

 

[JackieP]

Did he really just try and say AH didn’t laugh at the end of the cabinet video???

 

[whitelilac]

This is alarming. It's DV if you hit objects in the house.
So when I smacked the radiator with my shoe, I'm considered an abuser? Yikes.

 

[Kiranerys]

She is literally trying to provoke him in that video, she keeps asking him what happened,he doesn't answer so she goes again.
Then she tried to make it about her!.
And yes,Mr Rottenborn I just heard her laugh at the end of the video.

If she was scared of him,why would she provoke him for a reaction?

It's ridiculous!

 

[gloomy]

So she sends the pics to ROCKY her best friend? And they're all living rent free? Ugh despicable.

 

[Aussieboy]

I think this was when his mom died right? The cabinet abuse video?

Yeah, nothing happened to you this morning.

It's taken out of context, he was so violent that AH ran for her life They're making a molehill into a mountain.

 

[MachinaCollecta]

This is alarming. It's DV if you hit objects in the house.

So when I smacked the radiator with my shoe, I'm considered an abuser? Yikes.

I threw a shoe at a spider on my wall once, to my shame. I’m so glad that spider wasn’t AH.

 

[tlcya]

Did he really just try and say AH didn’t laugh at the end of the cabinet video???

indeed, he did

 

[gloomy]

AH and her friends treated JD like they were the children and he was the father they could trick and abuse. MOO

 

[katydid23]

He is blaming her 'for trying to help.'


So they are going to claim she was truly trying to help him?

 

[ar3593]

Two things about JDs closing:
1). Why didn’t they bring up the fact that SHE said the article was about him yesterday? Because they figured jury was smart enough to catch it? I don’t know. I think they were tuning her out anyway.

2). Would have been incredibly powerful if BC had said “Award JD $1 in damages and give him back his $7 million and he will donate it to charity. Give him back his name. He will be happy.” I say that because I believe jury would come back with much greater payout for JD.

As it stands, imo, jury will side with JD but may not award any damages to either. Who knows?

Maybe the attorneys are waiting to bring up AH said the OP-ED was about JD for their rebuttal after Rottenborn finishes? MOO

 

[TexasGiGi]

I had to turn the sound off because I can't listen to the way RB is lecturing the jury and repeating all of her lies while she sits there and looks sad after she just spent 2 hours sneering. It's just really coming off as bad to me and if I were on the jury I wouldn't be able to look at him and I probably would be rolling my eyes.

 

[makayla]

There’s no proof that the cocaine etc in that table is JD’s

 

[katydid23]

There is NO PROOF of most of these abuse allegations by her. Like him holding the doggie out of the window.

 

[wasnt_me]

It is a dumb choice for Rottenborn to show the cabinet video---after we all know she set it up, then secretly sold it to TMZ and gave them the copyright and she lied about it

Then he lies and denies she sold it to them--'but she was win a plane' ....lmao

She was on a plane? How do we know she didn't sell the video BEFORE she got on the plane and then it was sent to the drop box? Sounds to me like the 15 minutes was spent getting the clip ready to publish.

 

[BUF]

You know that staged photo with the coke lines will com up in Depp’s rebuttal closing…

 

[tlcya]

photo of cocaine, tampon applicator, a purse, some booze, and her coffee mug from the kitchen video. hmmm who's coke was that really Mr Rottonborn?

 

[Kiranerys]

Ugh,Wino forever. We are expected to believe that AH heard a non existent rumour about JD pushing KM down some stairs but she didn't know about the much publicised,much talked about,much joked about Wino forever tattoo?
REALLY?????????

 

[makayla]

Objection, Rottenborn, you’re lying