VA VA - Mamta Kafle Bhatt, 28, mom & pediatric nurse, 'involuntary missing,' husband reported her missing Aug 5, Manassas Park, 31 July 2024 *Arrest*

[iamshadow21]

This reminded me of a story. I had a friend who'd lived in the U.S. for quite a while and spoke excellent English with only a trace of an accent.

He was once watching a tv show and the cop told the bad guy, "You have the right to counsel." He wanted to know if it was really true that when you're arrested you can ask to speak with a therapist.

My late stepfather, who was a Cook Islander who spoke English his whole life (though it wasn't his first language) used to use gender pronouns interchangeably. Especially with pets. Other things, he'd mix up, too. My mum's best friend who is Aboriginal was removed from her parents and institutionalised at a very young age due to governmental policies of cultural genocide and has the same quirks of language, even though the institution punished speaking anything else but English. Her first language was Kriol, and always will be.

Equal access in the court systems and other areas cannot be understated as to its importance. Just because you can order a coffee and chat with your colleagues does not mean you understand the quirks of jargon specific to legal settings.

MOO

 

[?!?]

My late stepfather, who was a Cook Islander who spoke English his whole life (though it wasn't his first language) used to use gender pronouns interchangeably. Especially with pets. Other things, he'd mix up, too. My mum's best friend who is Aboriginal was removed from her parents and institutionalised at a very young age due to governmental policies of cultural genocide and has the same quirks of language, even though the institution punished speaking anything else but English. Her first language was Kriol, and always will be.

Equal access in the court systems and other areas cannot be understated as to its importance. Just because you can order a coffee and chat with your colleagues does not mean you understand the quirks of jargon specific to legal settings.

MOO

Agreed -- also applies to many of us fluent in English....

 

[CeciliaLizeth]

SEP 5, 2024

UPDATE: Police chief says 'nothing of evidentiary value' located during Thursday's searches in the Mamta Bhatt case

Police conducted several searches on Thursday based on new evidence in the Mamta Kafle Bhatt case.

www.insidenova.com

The Manassas Park police chief said Thursday’s searches across the city in the Mamta Kafle Bhatt case “resulted in nothing of evidentiary value being located.”

“The Manassas Park Police Department would like to thank the community for being patient and allowing our officers to conduct these searches,” Chief Mario Lugo said in a two-sentence update around 4:20 p.m.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/09/05/mamta-kafle-bhatt-missing-woman-virginia/4de20038-6bd1-11ef-86b4-58b1d68922fb_story.html

“We have multiple agencies, multiple witnesses who are out of the state — out of the country — that we have to prepare for,” Sweet said in court.

Chief Public Defender Tracey Lenox argued that Bhatt was still entitled to a speedy trial, despite prosecutors’ wish for more time, adding that his defense couldn’t control whether the arrest was premature.

“They chose to charge in this,” Lenox said, adding: “I understand the inconvenience to the Commonwealth, but this is where we are.”

 

[CeciliaLizeth]

I wonder if the PD is playing it safe by not stating they found something of "evidentiary value" to through NB off their scent. What do you all think?

 

[acutename]

It's about equal access for all to participate in their defense. Court language is complicated and completely different to conversational English. Nobody should be at a disadvantage in a courtroom because of their ESL status or sensory disability.

MOO

If he had not been in the US Army, I would be OK with this but....

 

[swanniee11]

I am trying to catch up on this case, I'm a few pages behind ( busy day) I just want to say my heart goes out to the searchers. GOD LOVE THEM! Also, having an interpreter is so important so that there is no misunderstanding or reason to say he isn't being treated fairly or didn't know what was being said. IMO. I'm back to reading. Great job everyone for all for the info.

 

[LifeIsAMystery]

If he had not been in the US Army, I would be OK with this but....

Not worth risking an appealable issue. Protects the case.

 

[Charlot123]

I can’t imagine he did that. We haven’t heard of anything being found in a fireplace or anything, and burning in an area like that would risk discovery.

Not fireplace. If the season is hazardous for fires outside, which is probably the case in MD/VA, then NB might really hack into pieces, sorry to say.

 

[FromGermany1]

I have a special dumpster at a hospital in mind (MB's place of work?), where the husband could have disposed of his wife (or parts, sorry). Is it possible?

 

[acutename]

Not worth risking an appealable issue. Protects the case.

I completely understand but I do wonder what he was doing at his employment- maybe it was more numerical tasks and less subject to lingustic shades of meaning.

 

[acutename]

I have a special dumpster at a hospital in mind (MB's place of work?), where the husband could have disposed of his wife (or parts, sorry). Is it possible?

should be security and special provisions for "hospital waste" IMO

 

[lesleyNOPE]

I have a special dumpster at a hospital in mind (MB's place of work?), where the husband could have disposed of his wife (or parts, sorry). Is it possible?

The hospital likely has cameras on every inch of their property

 

[PommyMommy]

SEP 8, 2024

Husband of missing Manassas Park mom due back in court this week

As police continue investigating the disappearance of Manassas Park mother Mamta Kafle Bhatt, her husband's public defender is seeking a speedy trial.

www.wjla.com

[...]

Naresh is due back in court Sept. 13 for a motion hearing. A Sept. 16 hearing was previously scheduled to set a trial start date.

[...]

Authorities spent around five hours Thursday searching areas deemed "locations of interest" upon review of recently obtained records, according to Manassas Park Police. The search locations were within a mile from the Bhatt’s house. The searches didn't yield any evidence, according to police.

[...]

 

[LifeIsAMystery]

I had really hoped the Tesla data would be more helpful. MOOO.

 

[PommyMommy]

SEP 9, 2O24

Husband of missing woman files motion saying prosecutors can’t prove his guilt

It’s clear that Naresh Bhatt, who has been charged with concealing a dead body in connection with the disappearance of his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, wants to go to trial as soon as possible. On Friday, he filed a motion saying prosecutors can't prove he's guilty.

www.princewilliamtimes.com

[...]

Naresh Bhatt asks the court to order prosecutors to turn over “vitally crucial” evidence because “all of the information would go to Mr. Bhatt’s innocence,” the motion states.

[...]

Naresh Bhatt “needs to explore and figure out where Mamta went on various days leading up to her disappearance, as it could show that Mr. Bhatt was in fact not with her when she went missing,” the motion states. “Finding the driver of the vehicle that picked up Mamta Bhatt is also vitally important as they might have information that would lead us to the discovery of where Mamta Bhatt is and has been.”

[...]

 

[VAres67]

SEP 9, 2O24

Husband of missing woman files motion saying prosecutors can’t prove his guilt

It’s clear that Naresh Bhatt, who has been charged with concealing a dead body in connection with the disappearance of his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, wants to go to trial as soon as possible. On Friday, he filed a motion saying prosecutors can't prove he's guilty.

www.princewilliamtimes.com

[...]

Naresh Bhatt asks the court to order prosecutors to turn over “vitally crucial” evidence because “all of the information would go to Mr. Bhatt’s innocence,” the motion states.

[...]

Naresh Bhatt “needs to explore and figure out where Mamta went on various days leading up to her disappearance, as it could show that Mr. Bhatt was in fact not with her when she went missing,” the motion states. “Finding the driver of the vehicle that picked up Mamta Bhatt is also vitally important as they might have information that would lead us to the discovery of where Mamta Bhatt is and has been.”

[...]

I knew as soon as that mystery vehicle was mentioned that it could be a way out for Naresh :/ Hopefully the police have the details of the driver, etc sorted.

 

[MassGuy]

I knew as soon as that mystery vehicle was mentioned that it could be a way out for Naresh :/ Hopefully the police have the details of the driver, etc sorted.

Lol, I just find this so funny.

Naresh Bhatt “needs to explore and figure out where Mamta went on various days leading up to her disappearance, as it could show that Mr. Bhatt was in fact not with her when she went missing.

Regardless of who she was with or where she went, she was with Naresh after that event (for up to a few days).

His bedroom was a bloody mess. The bathroom was a bloody mess. There were bloody drag marks between the two. He bought knives and cleaning supplies. He lied about where she was. He had her cell phone after he claimed she destroyed it. He googled the death of his wife, was liquidating assets and preparing to flee.

Etc etc etc.

I’d like to know the identity of the driver because it could factor into motive, but this defense idea that it could absolve him of murder is hilarious.

The motion makes no logical argument, and is very poorly written.

 

[Kittybunny]

SEP 9, 2O24

Husband of missing woman files motion saying prosecutors can’t prove his guilt

It’s clear that Naresh Bhatt, who has been charged with concealing a dead body in connection with the disappearance of his wife, Mamta Kafle Bhatt, wants to go to trial as soon as possible. On Friday, he filed a motion saying prosecutors can't prove he's guilty.

www.princewilliamtimes.com

[...]

Naresh Bhatt asks the court to order prosecutors to turn over “vitally crucial” evidence because “all of the information would go to Mr. Bhatt’s innocence,” the motion states.

[...]

Naresh Bhatt “needs to explore and figure out where Mamta went on various days leading up to her disappearance, as it could show that Mr. Bhatt was in fact not with her when she went missing,” the motion states. “Finding the driver of the vehicle that picked up Mamta Bhatt is also vitally important as they might have information that would lead us to the discovery of where Mamta Bhatt is and has been.”

[...]

Is he seriously trying to pull a ‘Gone Girl’ scenario here and imply that Mamta is still out there and ran away? At least in the Barry Morphew case, her body hadn’t been found either, but there wasn’t a preponderance of LOTS OF BLOOD IN THE HOUSE!

This guy…SMH!

I truly hope they find Mamta soon, but there’s no statute of limitations on murder.

 

[Inthedetails]

His bedroom was a bloody mess. The bathroom was a bloody mess. There were bloody drag marks between the two. He bought knives and cleaning supplies. He lied about where she was. He had her cell phone after he claimed she destroyed it. He googled the death of his wife, was liquidating assets and preparing to flee.

sbm

Oh the bloody irony of someone who wanted his wife to sleep in the garage during her period.

jmo