2010.07.02 Actual Emergency Hearing Thread

[TotallyObsessed]

I think JB had a mini-breakdown in open court. Agreed?

 

[Texas Mist]

Now JB wants his $260!!

 

[Curious Me]

"All you have to do is go pick it up", the judge said to JB.

 

[strawberry]

WHOA!!! JB is such a crier!!! HHJP was not happy to have to be there and did not appreciate having to rush into a hearing after having a long day!!

 

[JSR]

Where was Cindy sitting?

 

[beach]

HHJP's decision on the evidence inspection was brilliant. Excellent outside-the-box solution.

I was trying to keep up with exactly why he ruled the way he did -

Was his decision based primarily on the fact that there are no other prior rulings in Florida supporting the same?

 

[Aedrys]

I think JB had a mini-breakdown in open court. Agreed?

That is exactly what it seems to be. I can't see this, but I'm picturing him stomping his feet and throwing a hissy fit that he just can't get his way! Good Lord!

If he plans to argue at trial like this, it's going to be a very short trial. I think even HHJP has his hissy fit limits. Sheesh.

But GO HHJP for continuing to lay the SMACKDOWN on Baez! Woot!

 

[LindseyLou]

Someone needs to WD40 that darn courtroom door! LOL

 

[A_News_Junkie]

JB LOOKED TICKED and then when LB was talking to him after court he was even turning his back to her while she was speaking. Have at it Lillian Glass!

 

[strawberry]

The camera is hoping to catch a cat fight! JB is really really unhappy about the letters being released. Wonder why? Not.

 

[Bree0372]

I was trying to keep up with exactly why he ruled the way he did -

Was his decision based primarily on the fact that there are no other prior rulings in Florida supporting the same?

That is pretty much what he said that he could not locate any case in FL where this had been granted. He reminded JB that KC is just like all the others that have been accused -- no special treatment. (paraphrased)

 

[JSR]

The camera is hoping to catch a cat fight! JB is really really unhappy about the letters being released. Wonder why? Not.

Because he didn't want the public to see GA's "why" letter.

 

[MvD]

I LOVE this judge!!!
I think Baez needs to heed the old adage "it is better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt"

 

[Gypsy Road]

I can not believe that Casey picked THIS attorney to defend her. HOLY CARP.

 

[strawberry]

What was LDB saying at the end? At the end of the hearing, not afterwords?

 

[TotallyObsessed]

That is exactly what it seems to be. I can't see this, but I'm picturing him stomping his feet and throwing a hissy fit that he just can't get his way! Good Lord!

If he plans to argue at trial like this, it's going to be a very short trial. I think even HHJP has his hissy fit limits. Sheesh.

But GO HHJP for continuing to lay the SMACKDOWN on Baez! Woot!

No...it was just a rush of gush. He could not shut up with his "wah wah wahing" I'm telling I'm telling I'm telling

Seriously, that is exactly what he did and Judge P was PIZZED TO THE MAX. He did a wonderful job of holding back....but he got his point across big time.

 

[JDzWife]

ICA seemed very upset after a brief, intimate conversation with JB.

 

[strawberry]

Well that was very entertaining.

ETA: I may just have to put a flag on and rewatch it to celebrate the 4th!

 

[AZlawyer]

I was trying to keep up with exactly why he ruled the way he did -

Was his decision based primarily on the fact that there are no other prior rulings in Florida supporting the same?

I think his point was that the SA has a legitimate interest in preserving the integrity of the evidence, and that the defense may have a legitimate interest in talking to their experts outside the hearing of the state. However, the interests are not necessarily in conflict, so absent any controlling law on point he was not REQUIRED to choose between them. The defense and their experts can just keep their mouths shut while LOOKING at the evidence, and then go into another room to TALK about it.

 

[TotallyObsessed]

About half way through that diatribe, my judge would have said "ENOUGH"....she recognizes that sometimes all they want to do is tell on each other, seriously like school kids, but she will let it go on for only so far and then WHAM.....the hammer comes down!