CA CA - Karlie Lain Gusé, 16, Mono County, 13 Oct 2018 #2

[bwt42]

DBM

 

[Knox]

Then Haileys case bares similarities to another ongoing case... Alisha Lynn Blair Ivy. The last person to see her alive is also the one responsible for her death. Crazy. Bogus friends, bogus witnesses.
Has Haileys case been closed/solved, cold, or still open?

Cold, still open.

 

[gitana1]

If I remember correctly, the witnesses didn't say "yes I saw Karlie", they said they saw a young female walking around and described and outfit that did not match the description of the outfit Karlie was wearing. I don't believe these witnesses saw Karlie.

And if you go on YouTube and see the step mom's videos posted in the hours after Karlie disappeared she may be wearing what the witnesses reportedly saw.

 

[claudianunes]

And if you go on YouTube and see the step mom's videos posted in the hours after Karlie disappeared she may be wearing what the witnesses reportedly saw.

I can't even bring myself to watch or read anything from her. But I do remember that the clothing description changed out of the blue, and it was pretty obvious that it changed to match what that other person was wearing.

 

[Knox]

So is the consensus that Karlie left her house under her own steam, or ....

 

[Roxxi3535]

So is the consensus that Karlie left her house under her own steam, or ....

I dont think she ever left, let alone had the choice to leave her house that morning.

 

[insearchoflight]

It will be interesting to hear what her siblings have to say one day maybe when they are adults. Poor Karlie

 

[claudianunes]

So is the consensus that Karlie left her house under her own steam, or ....

No, the exact opposite.

 

[SuziQ]

I dont think she ever left, let alone had the choice to leave her house that morning.

Remind me about those kids and that morning. Didn't SM suddenly get them out of the house? Then there was the unexplained damage to the car. Didn't the undercarriage need repair?

 

[jenn83]

Remind me about those kids and that morning. Didn't SM suddenly get them out of the house? Then there was the unexplained damage to the car. Didn't the undercarriage need repair?

I believe SM said she took them to a relative's house very early that morning, never gave a reason why. And yes, in her videos, she said she had to have the car repaired because of damage it got from looking for Karlie in the rough terrain.

 

[jenn83]

That article was written by a fraud. His name is Damion Moore and he acts like a journalist but hes actually a liar and an amateur. His articles are just long ramblings from his own personal views of the case. He has been bad mouthing Lindsay yet doesnt even know her. Hes not an honest man. All he does is start drama.

I glad you said this because I don't know the author, but when I read the article, it said a whole lot of nothing.

 

[bwt42]

I believe LE is convinced Karlie was seen by the three witnesses. I will believe them over those that hate the SM & will do everything possible to make her look bad. jmo

 

[SAMS]

I believe LE is convinced Karlie was seen by the three witnesses. I will believe them over those that hate the SM & will do everything possible to make her look bad. jmo

I dont think anyone here "hates" SM, and she's done a great job of making herself look bad.
MOO-IBM

 

[Knox]

I dont think anyone here "hates" SM, and she's done a great job of making herself look bad.
MOO-IBM

I'd never intentionally make someone look bad, hate is a pretty strong emotion. My comments about SM are merely questions regarding what I consider to be odd behavior.

So unless her odd behavior is to cover up something unrelated to Karlie, I'm thinking she's lying about the events that occurred. Pretty straightforward in my book.

 

[bwt42]

I'd never intentionally make someone look bad, hate is a pretty strong emotion. My comments about SM are merely questions regarding what I consider to be odd behavior.

So unless her odd behavior is to cover up something unrelated to Karlie, I'm thinking she's lying about the events that occurred. Pretty straightforward in my book.

I didn't say all posters hate her. As a matter of fact I didn't mention posters at all.

 

[SuziQ]

I believe LE is convinced Karlie was seen by the three witnesses. I will believe them over those that hate the SM & will do everything possible to make her look bad. jmo

I haven't read social media. The SM has made herself look bad on SM. So???

 

[insearchoflight]

Let’s say for a moment the three witness did see Karlie that morning. Karlie could have very well left on her own accord and then was tracked down by someone enraged that she left.

Not my top theory, but plausible nonetheless.

 

[bwt42]

I haven't read social media. The SM has made herself look bad on SM. So???

She made some mistakes. Doesn't make her responsible for her disappearance. If you haven't read social media, how do you know she made herself look bad. tia

 

[bwt42]

Let’s say for a moment the three witness did see Karlie that morning. Karlie could have very well left on her own accord and then was tracked down by someone enraged that she left.

Not my top theory, but plausible nonetheless.

Imo, there is an underlying current on this thread that the dad & sm are responsible for her disappearance. I know the last people to see her are often the prime suspects. They are the low hanging fruit. There are valid criticisms of all the parties in this case. I just don't think its fair to choose one & claim everything they have done is evil, a lie or sociopathic. Or to discount any report that would point away from that person as written by a fraud. jmo

 

[jenn83]

Imo, there is an underlying current on this thread that the dad & sm are responsible for her disappearance. I know the last people to see her are often the prime suspects. They are the low hanging fruit. There are valid criticisms of all the parties in this case. I just don't think its fair to choose one & claim everything they have done is evil, a lie or sociopathic. Or to discount any report that would point away from that person as written by a fraud. jmo

These aren't just claims. SM has admitted to lying about multiple things involving that night/morning.