I agree - although I must say that I had to smile at IE's attempt to suggest that Suzanne gave as good as she got physically. It was about as plausible as a plot in which Emiko attacks Godzilla....True. And while there were "hints" in documents from the first trial attempt that they had physical altercations (both of them) I think it would be a desperation attempt to try and besmirch for lack of a better word Suzanne. Plus it's also known that when they did argue Barry left sometimes for days which does not work in favor of crime of passion because it shows he had the control to leave often in the heat of an argument before the weekend in question.