CO- Dylan Redwine, 13, Vallecito, 19 November 2012 - #13

[mck16]

Stepbrother? Do you mean the son of Mark's by another woman? He would be a half-brother to Dylan, not stepbrother, if they share the same dad.

Beach, the way I understand it is, Cory and Dylan were born to Mark and Elaine, so they are full brothers. I think Cory's last name is Redwine.

And they all 3 look exactly alike. jmo

 

[Abby Normal Again]

I asked earlier too, and never heard... Can you guys tell me a case where a parent killed a teenage child without being overt about it in the form of murder-suicide or taking the kids off From the other parent overtly and creating some sort of manhunt?

I am not the expert most of you are, and I can't seem to find a case such as that. Most i am finding are to do with kids under the teen years. Honestly asking, I am sure such exists- it's not a sarcastic challenge

 

[TxJan1971]

I have a suspicion they got that from ER's contradictory statements on Nancy Grace.

AFAIK LE has not released the results of any of the lie detector results from either of the parents. That should not be included in the timeline at all.

See Beach post #488. I'm going to leave it in there because it was in the news article with an appropriate link. Thanks for your thoughts!

 

[DylansMom34]

I have a suspicion they got that from ER's contradictory statements on Nancy Grace.

AFAIK LE has not released the results of any of the lie detector results from either of the parents. That should not be included in the timeline at all.

Well, if she says that she took a lie detector test, I think that is relevant to the timeline. Since LE is really not saying hardly anything about anything, we have things included in our timeline that have not been confirmed by LE (pretty much everything Mark Redwine has said).

Maybe without LE or Mark confirming his lie detector test, maybe his shouldn't be included. But again other things that have not been confirmed by LE are in there, so....

 

[Angelonline]

But why would Dylan pack it up and take it with him if it was broken beyond repair?

And if so, wouldnt he use the land line and call his mom and tell her his cell was broken? Or call his dad and say he needed a ride to the radio shack?
Or call his friends to say his cell was broken, he'd catch a ride later after he went to town to get a new battery. He might not know his friends numbers without his cell, but I bet he knew his moms number.

And he had the computer right there too. He could have shot mom an email, to say his cell was dead.

My teens always send me a FB message (rather than email) if their phone is dead.

 

[mmmagique]

This is just the point. The parents had shared custody for years, the divorce was 5 years ago. The custody had changed recently due to the mom moving several hours away. WHY would he have a motive to murder his son? It makes no sense!

All this talk of him having problems dealing with his ex moving on with her life is only speculation, it's not fact. They both admit they don't see eye-to-eye, but how many divorced couples do? If they all got along, they wouldn't be getting a divorce!

There is a history of violence but not towards his kids, only of his older son beating him up. Many men will hit and beat their wives but treat their children very well and would never dream of hurting one.

I don't get why the man would have any motive, that's all. Did he ever pursue getting full custody of Dylan?? Since he works out of town a lot, would he even want to have him there full time? It's not making sense to me.

It's documented that his wife claimed in court papers that MR took a swing at Dylan in 2008.

 

[Tennlyn]

And that is why 300 people turned out to search with MR and his family for his lost son? jmo

300 people turned out to look for Dylan. Period. Not because of his family or in spite of it, but because Dylan is missing and deserves to be found. MOO

 

[mck16]

Well, if she says that she took a lie detector test, I think that is relevant to the timeline. Since LE is really not saying hardly anything about anything, we have things included in our timeline that have not been confirmed by LE (pretty much everything Mark Redwine has said).

Maybe without LE or Mark confirming his lie detector test, maybe his shouldn't be included. But again other things that have not been confirmed by LE are in there, so....

That is what I was afraid of. so how accurate is it.. Is it factual or opinionated? Just asking not trying to be an SA.

 

[shefner]

Maybe they are just trying to say they know more about this case than some people do. We have asked for information and then when they release more, all of a sudden, no one trusts what they are saying. jmo

We have previous quotes where LE has said they do not think Dylan's disappearance was an abduction...now they are saying that it might have been. Just confusing that's all. If it was an abduction, then maybe Dylan has a chance to be alive. That would be wonderful...and a best case scenario in my book.

 

[IHAVENOCLUE]

Ten agencies, including the La Plata County Sheriff's Office, the local police departments and the Red Cross gathered to further search with the community. Searchers hiked more than 60 miles of county roads looking for things Dylan may have thrown out of a car window.

They said it's possible he tried to escape or hide in areas of brush to keep warm.

http://www.koat.com/news/new-mexico...17707274/-/pj5977z/-/index.html#ixzz2EaAtTEty

For the tight-knit town that now has posters up everywhere, the thought of an abduction was completely unexpected, yet, investigators told Action 7 News that's exactly what they think happened.

The above article reports:

[Mark]"Redwine took a lie detector test and it was found inconclusive, which could mean a number of things."

If this has been posted before.... Sorry...

But I thought we had not found the answer to this question conclusively...

JMO

 

[Ransom]

It's documented that his wife claimed in court papers that MR took a swing at Dylan in 2008.

It was documented his wife said that. Both RO were dismissed in Dec. 2008.

 

[DylansMom34]

It seems to include everything that has been reported since Dylan went missing. What is opinionated about a document with supporting links, etc.?

 

[mck16]

300 people turned out to look for Dylan. Period. Not because of his family or in spite of it, but because Dylan is missing and deserves to be found. MOO

I absolutely agree with that, but I think the community is supporting the parents as well and that is all I meant. jmo

 

[PaulR]

300 people turned out to look for Dylan. Period. Not because of his family or in spite of it, but because Dylan is missing and deserves to be found. MOO

If LE thinks MR is really a suspect and doesn't want to name him for some reason, do you seriously think they'd let him search and possibly contaminate evidence?

 

[mck16]

It seems to include everything that has been reported since Dylan went missing. What is opinionated about a document with supporting links, etc.?

Did not say it was opinionated. I haven't seen it. I just hope it isn't. That's all on that subject for me. jmo

 

[PlainJaneDoe]

The above article reports:

[Mark]"Redwine took a lie detector test and it was found inconclusive, which could mean a number of things."

If this has been posted before.... Sorry...

But I thought we had not found the answer to this question conclusively...

JMO

I can conclusively agree with your statement.

 

[dlc]

Sorry if this has been clarified already, but where has anything been written about the stepbrother? I haven't even seen him or the stepsister mentioned anywhere. Are you meaning his half-brother? TIA

Dear Confusion,

You are absolutely correct! He would be Dylan's _half-brother_, not step-brother.

Thank you for pointing that out.

I think the article is important, for a number of reasons.

Thanks again. Sorry about that.

 

[TxLady2]

In blue...What the ???? Are they backpeddling much? Maybe trying to make someone feel more comfortable?

Backpedaling from what? They've seemed to be working from that premise from the start, but at the same time, investigating other possibilities. Most LE don't just pursue one theory, they work several different angles all at the same time.

I don't get the "making someone feel more comfortable." IF they suspected Mark had something to do with it, yeah, possibly. But they haven't given much indication that he is a suspect, so I don't think they are playing games.

You know, the search at his house doesn't necessarily have to do with him being the primary suspect. They could also be trying to rule out something happening to Dylan in the hours that Mark was out doing errands.

That's my opinions, anyway, but of course I can't read their minds, so IDK.

 

[shefner]

Thanks, I think I'm going to do that. What time do you need the updated
document by? I need a few more minutes ...

Is this timeline going in the first post of each thread? I need to see a link and check it out.....
Thank you Tx for doing the timeline work!!

 

[mck16]

The above article reports:

[Mark]"Redwine took a lie detector test and it was found inconclusive, which could mean a number of things."

If this has been posted before.... Sorry...

But I thought we had not found the answer to this question conclusively...

JMO

I thought that info came from his X wife. Have not seen it in MSM. Doesn't mean it isn't there, I just haven't seen it. jmo