CO- Dylan Redwine, 13, Vallecito, 19 November 2012 - #14

[kkdj]

Well others used past tense too so...

I know.... And I have my thoughts about that.
Either way, it gave me the creeps. While some might suppose and expect, others could know. Imo

 

[cluciano63]

Steven Stayner, Jaycee Dugard........

I guess my original post was really confusing...I was asking how Dylan could feasibly be alive and NOT be a captive of some sick pervert.

 

[oceanblueeyes]

this has probably been posted before but the Nancy Grace transcript and comments by Elaine Redwine confirm that even though cell reception wasn't good around MR's home that texts always came through.

Also, per Elaine Redwine it appears MR's 1st polygraph was inconclusive but he was asked to take a second one.

http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/1212/03/ng.01.html

So, it's very troubling to me that there are no texts by Dylan after 8pm...none/nada/zilch.

Elaine couldnt make up her mind which one it was when she was on NGs show.

She said she didnt know.
She said she thinks he passed.
She said she thinks it was inconclusive.

There is no need for him to take another one.

She said she Passed but yet she nor anyone else has been ruled out either.

 

[imamaze]

Discussing Dylan's mother and family can only be done with what we know in the media and law enforcement. Sleuthing them, including Dylan's other siblings are not allowed.

Ima

 

[cluciano63]

The only reason I didn't care for MR saying that Dylan was his whole world is because he does have other children.

 

[Seajay]

I don't even know how to word this, but the kids your wife/fiancé has from the guy she left you for is very... Well... I've seen it make the sanest man jealous beyond belief.

I assume bc of distance her fiancé is well accounted for. I would assume that would be an important elimination based on what I've seen with this scenario. NOT an accusation, not even a theory, just a hope that he has been well cleared.

That thought occurred to me too but I didn't know how to bring it up without it sounding like an accusation. Good job!!

 

[MrsPC]

Elaine couldnt make up her mind which one it was when she was on NGs show.

She said she didnt know.
She said she thinks he passed.
She said she thinks it was inconclusive.

There is no need for him to take another one.

She said she Passed but yet she nor anyone else has been ruled out either.

that's why I didn't expound on the polygraph....

the main gist of my post was that texts come through even with bad cell reception and ER never had trouble rec'g texts from Dylan when he was at MR's.

I think that's more important.

 

[oceanblueeyes]

I know.... And I have my thoughts about that.
Either way, it gave me the creeps. While some might suppose and expect, others could know. Imo

I would think something of it if I had not heard other innocent parents use past tense.

IMO

 

[Confusion]

Elaine couldnt make up her mind which one it was when she was on NGs show.

She said she didnt know.
She said she thinks he passed.
She said she thinks it was inconclusive.

and...
She didn't know if he took one.
She thought he might have took one.
She really doesn't know about it.
She never said he failed it.
She thinks it was inconclusive.

 

[kkdj]

It has been established in MSM and discussed here at the time that both parents have referred to Dylan in past tense. I think it means nothing. Maybe others think they are in cahoots on Dylan's disappearance since both used the same tense.

Well I would be really amazed if the parents are and therefore were in cahoots!

 

[dlc]

I read the same thing. jmo

Link, please. TIA.


ETA - I now see the posts that occurred in between, explaining what was actually meant by the initial post.

Sorry.

 

[TxLady2]

Off to take a break. This is making my head hurt. Caio.

 

[oceanblueeyes]

that's why I didn't expound on the polygraph....

the main gist of my post was that texts come through even with bad cell reception and ER never had trouble rec'g texts from Dylan when he was at MR's.

I think that's more important.

True but she cant say with certainty that a text will come through everytime. It may or it may not.

Did she try to call Dylan all through the day and Mark when Dylan didnt text her on Monday?

IMO

 

[GateKeeper]

http://www.daily-times.com/ci_22164169/scammer-says-he-kidnapped-dylan-redwine

SCAMMER SAYS HE KIDNAPPED DYLAN

 

[oceanblueeyes]

and...
She didn't know if he took one.
She thought he might have took one.
She really doesn't know about it.
She never said he failed it.
She thinks it was inconclusive.

I know.......she had me quite confused with all the answers........all which were different.

IMO

 

[kkdj]

and...
She didn't know if he took one.
She thought he might have took one.
She really doesn't know about it.
She never said he failed it.
She thinks it was inconclusive.

I watched that NG show and I had the feeling that maybe she had been asked by LE to not discuss the LDT, didn't know how to answer or avoid some of the questions, and also tell the public she passed and dads was inconclusive.
Jmo

 

[beach]

(I don't think we are supposed to be investigating Mom's past...) JMO

I just got direction from the owners.

Elaine Redwine is not sleuthable. HOWEVER, you guys can sleuth to find out if the man Elaine is married to now is the same man she was married to prior to Mark Redwine. That is relevant.

PLEASE BE CAREFUL. If in doubt, do not post it. We do not want to expose an innocent man with the same name who has absolutley nothing to do with ER or MR.


No bashing of Elaine or her current husband or prior husband. (Hope that makes sense because this is getting confusing and I feel like I'm talking in circles here. lol) And no sleuthing further than determining if her ex and current husband are the same man.

 

[DylansMom34]

So rediculous that several days after the fact, the 30 second question and answer between NG & Elaine regarding Mark's lie detector test get hashed and rehashed over and over and over.

 

[Abby Normal Again]

I guess my original post was really confusing...I was asking how Dylan could feasibly be alive and NOT be a captive of some sick pervert.

Probably we just read it too fast.

 

[GateKeeper]

FARMINGTON — A man said he kidnapped Dylan Redwine and is asking for money for the 13-year-old’s release.

But the man is lying.

“This is a scam,” La Plata County Sheriff’s Office Capt. Jim Ezzell said in a statement. “Do not send him money.”

http://www.daily-times.com/ci_22164169/scammer-says-he-kidnapped-dylan-redwine