CO- Dylan Redwine, 13, Vallecito, 19 November 2012 - #21

[Angelonline]

Nice new hairdo.

Umm its down out of the ponytail. That's about how mine looks in a ponytail and then after I take it down and wash it, it looks like pic 2. Two days after Christmas a coworker said wow, did you color your hair, I replied no I washed it this morning. Lol

I'm not going to condemn her for showering.

 

[PaulR]

take into consideration the lighting differences

her smile looks forced

and yes she looks like she has lost a little weight which would be natural.


whereas the comment about MR's weight was

He said Dylan's dejected-appearing father Mark Redwine occasionally comes in to buy cigarettes.

"He's lost a lot of weight," Schank said.



Read more: Dylan Redwine search in Colorado goes on month after his disappearance - The Denver Post http://www.denverpost.com/recommended/ci_22217778#ixzz2GbeqTKTN
Read The Denver Post's Terms of Use of its content: http://www.denverpost.com/termsofuse

A few pages ago, some "hinky meters" were going off because MR lost weight and someone said that John Douglas stated that one sign of a suspect is that they lose weight.

ER loses weight but that's natural because her child is missing. MR loses weight but... not because his child is missing.

 

[mck16]

Help me out! What poster? The missing poster? A specific person posting a comment? HELP!

On the FB page for the link of the picture of ER. First comment. Personally didn't see any difference. But, I am not going to be rude. You really couldn't tell much from the picture. jmo

 

[Kmonci]

Umm its down out of the ponytail. That's about how mine looks in a ponytail and then after I take it down and wash it, it looks like pic 2. Two days after Christmas a coworker said wow, did you color your hair, I replied no I washed it this morning. Lol

I'm not going to condemn her for showering.

Me neither. I have seen other pictures/interviews with ER and I think she has had the same hairstyle for a while. I am not going to read much into weight loss by parents of a missing child. I would expect neither one of them is eating much at the moment.

 

[Angelonline]

Concerning MR vs ER weight loss, ER isn't allowed to be discussed as a POI unless rules have changed. Also I missed the posts commenting on his weight loss I guess.

 

[sleuthin4fun]

In Durango spending the holiday with family. Have not read much about Dylan before. Came to websleuths this evening after seeing missing posters of Dylan all over town.

 

[Angelonline]

On the FB page for the link of the picture of ER. First comment. Personally didn't see any difference. But, I am not going to be rude. You really couldn't tell much from the picture. jmo

Her arms look very thin to me as does her face compared to other pics I saw of her in Nov (not just this one). But that's JMOO.

 

[catswhiskers]

Help me out! What poster? The missing poster? A specific person posting a comment? HELP!

I could be wrong, but the linked fb pic above seemed to suddenly appear as the weight loss/guilt notion was being discussed here ....
I assume the fb poster who said they didn't get the point made that comment as they were seeing the pic out of context.
But I kind of don't get the point either :moo:

 

[PaulR]

Well ER isn't allowed to be discussed as a POI unless rules have changed.

I have never said or implied ER is a POI. <modsnip>.

 

[Kmonci]

I've said it before, but I really admire the women who are administering the FMDR page on behalf of Dylan's family, and keeping such a tight rein on what stays on their page. they have a goal in mind and they are sticking to it - bless them for all the time it must take them on top of their other efforts, as well as getting on with their own lives as well. There are enough sites you can visit to discuss theories and suspicions. At least they know Dylan and all his immediate family personally, and it's commendable that they aren't letting their page turn into something ugly. JMO but I'd actually be darn ticked off to the point of seeking legal advice if someone set up a page using my name or that of a family member without consent. Not that I know if that's the case with any other fb pages, just having a wild guess.

Whoever created the new page mentioned that they have been asked to remove it or face legal action.

 

[PaulR]

Whoever created the new page mentioned that they have been asked to remove it or face legal action.

Why? I know there was a page where someone was claiming to raise funds on his behalf and wasn't, but assuming that isn't the case here, what kind of legal action can they take? "Don't start a webpage publicizing our missing son"?

 

[Simply Caustic]

Perhaps, instead of discussing ER's weight, hairstyle, etc. (in a derogatory sense) we should branch out into another topic.
IMO It's in poor taste to make thinly-veiled comments about her coloring her hair/styling it...a missing child is not tantamount to a complete breakdown of hygiene.....JMO, of course.

 

[mck16]

I could be wrong, but the linked fb pic above seemed to suddenly appear as the weight loss/guilt notion was being discussed here ....
I assume the fb poster who said they didn't get the point made that comment as they were seeing the pic out of context.
But I kind of don't get the point either :moo:

I noticed that too. Wasn't me. But, I agree with the post. I didn't see any difference and the dates on the photo were wrong. What I noticed was the big smile that wasn't in the other picture. I probably started the weight loss issue but I had thought that before and is something I notice in all the cases I have followed. My point was not to cast any thing negative toward ER. I don't think she is involved at all. And that is all I have to say about her. jmo

 

[Angelonline]

I have never said or implied ER is a POI. <modsnip>.

<modsnip> was just explaining the difference in general. Also I'm afraid I missed the posts about MRs weight being an indicator of guilt. <modsnip>

 

[catswhiskers]

Why? I know there was a page where someone was claiming to raise funds on his behalf and wasn't, but assuming that isn't the case here, what kind of legal action can they take? "Don't start a webpage publicizing our missing son"?

Could have something to do with MarkRedwineGuiltyorInnocent portion of the page's url.
The page has gone now ...

 

[aust amateur slueth]

A few pages ago, some "hinky meters" were going off because MR lost weight and someone said that John Douglas stated that one sign of a suspect is that they lose weight.

ER loses weight but that's natural because her child is missing. MR loses weight but... not because his child is missing.

ER has lost a little weight, which would be natural in the circumstances


on the other hand its reported that MR has lost a lot of weight


my comment is my opinion <mod snip>

 

[MsFacetious]

Desiree also lost A LOT of weight after Kyron went missing.
I do not think that is abnormal.

 

[TxJan1971]

Well one thing that kind of peaked my curiosity is since they have a real nice photo of Elaine before/after, so where's the real nice before/after -- side by side of MR? And then there's a really nice ER "Family" photo.... where's the "family" photo for MR? Or doesn't he have any family? I'm confused.... And I'm fairly certain that if ER/CR wanted their "family" photo posted they would have it posted on the official FDR FB page.

I would have thought that this new FB page that wants all the information out there for discussion -- I would think they would want to show both sides.... for "discussion"... but that may not be their intent since the page is called MR Guilty or Innocent.

The things that make you go hmmmmm...

 

[JBean]

Let's move on past physical appearance please. I am not here much so I am not sure which comments are passive aggressive attacks and which are genuine curiosity. but the authors know- so please stop.

Let's get to more constructive discussion please.
Thanks.

 

[Angelonline]

Goodnight all. I'm praying for a New Years miracle. You all certainly know where my suspicions lie, however, I'm still hoping for a live Dylan home with his family for 2013.