CO- Dylan Redwine's case discussed on Dr. Phil ONLY!- 2/26/13 ***SPOILERS***

[katydid23]

ER asks MR directly "Did you hurt him?" and [my note: OMG!!!] MR's reply "what kind of mother are you to even think I was capable or doing something like that?"

CLASSIC answer for someone who is not telling the truth, IMOO

Seriously. Why would it mean she was a 'bad' mother if she questioned her ex-husbands story about their missing child?

 

[nikb]

I was just reading back though the thread . Mark said "we" picked him up . So who is "we"?

That was one of my first questions too.

 

[raine1212]

Didn't MB say it was inconclusive because that is what MR told her? AFAIK, LE has only confirmed that tests were administered. All MOO

I was going off Dr. Phil and the MR videos.

 

[eileenhawkeye]

What is up with Dr. Phil putting an old picture of Dylan on his FB page which has 1.6 million likes?!

 

[deoneta]

What is this about the mail carrier seeing Dylan walking? Wasn't that eventually figured out as NOT being Dylan, but being a similar looking local kid?

Several news reports have read earlier "sightings" have been discounted. When Bender made the announcement that they no longer were considering runaway as a possibility, he cited "no sightings" as one of the reasons. All MOO

 

[*Lash*]

Mark alone with his coffee.

 

[JustJeannie]

Just a quick thanks to all who have reported what was on. I am at work, (I'm a CPA so I'm working 12 hour days now,) and probably won't be able to watch my dvr recordings until Sunday. So I really appreciate the input from those who are viewing.

AZGrandma, I also want to thank you for being here and putting yourself out there like you have. I know it hasn't been easy, but I really appreciate it, and I am sure ER and CR do as well. Your strength and support for Dylan and his family is amazing. And having read your post last night, I am so glad you were able to get yourself and your children to safety. I know that's not an easy thing to do. I hope that all of you can get the answers you want and deserve soon.

 

[nikb]

totally agree. he prepped for the show by finding new accusations and ways to blame ER, and throw suspicion on her and depict her in a bad light. <modsnip> MOO IMO JMO

I definitely agree. Some of it was so out of left field IMO! Interestingly ER added a tiny bit to her story too, saying that Dylan didn't like going to his Dad's because his Dad didn't do stuff with him. Dr. Phil picked up on it right away and kind of called her on it, said that she had never mentioned MR not doing things with Dylan before. I don't think this was a big deal whatsoever, but I thought it was good that Dr. Phil picked up on it and treated ER and MR equally in terms of pointing out inconsistencies. He had quite a few more to point out for one of them vs. the other, but he was fair IMO and paid close attention to details like that.

 

[eileenhawkeye]

I'm reading the comments on Dr. Phil's FB page. There are many that say Mark is suspicious/guilty, and also many that criticize both parents for their arguing.

<Mod Snip>
Some dude from Zimbabwe commented...except he called the parents "stupid".

 

[azgrandma]

Azgrandma do you know anything about Mark picking Dylan up with somebody else in the car or is it just the way Mark talks do you know ?

I never bothered to ask, I just thought it was him.

 

[Kamille]

I'm watching right now and I'm honestly speechless. I don't even know what to say. :what:

I'm only a half hour in.

MOO

 

[eileenhawkeye]

Cory commented on the Dr. Phil page: He basically said that it's sad that the Dr. Phil people picked such a young picture of Dylan to use his name/face for their (the show's) gain.

Seems a bit ungrateful. They just put your family on TV in front of 4.2 million people. While I agree that they should use a better picture, it seems weird to accuse them of using a young picture for "their gain". People are going to see his picture on their newsfeed no matter what picture they use.

 

[TxJan1971]

MINI CLIP - TRANSCRIPT - Map of Where Mark Traveled

(See clip with Dr. Phil in front of map at bottom of page)

http://www.drphil.com/shows/show/1988/


MR: She never called me. She not one time ever called me.

Dr.Phil: Why would she lie about that?

MR: Well, that&#8217;s what&#8230; that&#8217;s a good question. She ever tried to call me.
She has never picked up the phone and tried to call me.

Dr. Phil: So you&#8217;re telling me the truth. She did not call you?

MR: Absolutely she did not call me. At any point. From&#8230;

ER: Why didn&#8217;t you call ME? You lost him.

MR: I lost him&#8230;

ER: Where is he??? He&#8217;s not here. You were the last one to see him. Why didn&#8217;t you call ME? Why do I have to call you when you lost our son? That doesn&#8217;t make sense.

MR: And this is exactly why I wouldn&#8217;t want to communicate to you because YOU can&#8217;t sit here and have a civil conversation with me &#8216;cos you wanna&#8217; be &#8230; (interrupted)

ER: Because I&#8217;m angry with you.

MR: Because you want to be accusing me&#8230; (interrupted)&#8230;. and pointing &#8230;

ER: for losing our son&#8230; I&#8217;m angry with you&#8230;

MR: You&#8217;ve said that&#8230; several times&#8230;

ER: It&#8217;s true&#8230;.

Dr. Phil: Well, I&#8217;m not angry with you&#8230;I&#8217;m just asking you questions to try to get information. You think he walked away from the house&#8230;

MR: One of his friends lives up at the lake where I live, and it&#8217;s right across from the marina, so it&#8217;s not a very far distance for him have&#8230;to try to reach out to his friend who lives up at the lake.

Dr. Phil: Okay&#8230;

ER: 6 miles

MR: It&#8217;s NOT six miles!

ER: It is too far for Dylan, and there was no indica&#8230;.

MR: It&#8217;s not 6 miles from my house to the end of the road.

ER: He would have texted somebody and had somebody come get him.

Dr. Phil: Okay&#8230;well, let me&#8230; help me out here. See if I have this uhhh correct. (Dr. Phile walks up to screen/map). This is your house, right here.

MR: That&#8217;s correct

Dr. Phil: And this is his friends house &#8211; uhhh&#8230; would this be Tristan&#8217;s house here?

MR: That would be Tristan&#8217;s ]

Dr. Phil: This is his friend&#8217;s house&#8230;

MR: Right in front of the lake&#8230;

Dr. Phil: and,&#8230; we did go to Google maps and that&#8217;s 5.9 miles.

ER: Yeaaaahhhhhh

(Sounds like audience laughter)

Dr. Phil: From here to here&#8230;

MR: Well, now she said to the end of the road&#8230;.

Dr. Phil: Well, I don&#8217;t know where&#8230; about the end of the road
But this is 5.9 miles which Doesn&#8217;t seem like all that far to me I don&#8217;t know if that&#8217; suphill or downhill, but&#8230;

MR: It&#8217;s pretty flat &#8211; it&#8217;s a little windy.

Dr. Phil: So you can walk from there to there. And So then we say Dylan&#8217;s friend, 2nd house, this is his grandmothers&#8230;

ER: His friend&#8217;s grandmother, yes&#8230;

Dr. Phil: And so&#8230;

MR: And that was the only place I knew to go&#8230;and when I &#8230;

Dr. Phil: Those are the only two that he could go&#8230;

MR: There was more than just the two, but those are the only two where I knew where they lived.

Dr. Phil: And that morning, you got up and you went here &#8211; first to the payroll office

MR: To my company&#8217;s office

Dr. Phil: Right, Then you went to the attorney&#8217;s office,

MR: Correct

Dr. Phil: Then you made this kind of circuit uhhh here, then this whole circuit that you went around was about &#8211; you were gone for about 4 hours

MR: I was gone for about 4 hours

Dr. Phil: So you saw him before you left.

MR: I did, yes&#8230;

 

[scorekeeper]

Again, he turns it back on Elaine. Can't he answer a freaking question without deflecting it over to her? Did you hurt him? It's a yes or no question!

he should hook up with Jodi Arias.....what a conversation that would be

(you need to watch her trial.....unbelievable...)

 

[SuperMom1995]

Several new reports have read earlier "sightings" have been discounted. When Bender made the announcement that they no longer were considering runaway as a possibility, he cited "no sightings" as one of the reasons. All MOO

and very interesting, IMO, that LE tells DP that they have considered this a criminal investigation since the first night. IMO, that tells me that LE was suspicious of him from the beginning.

 

[Eileen730]

I'm reading the comments on Dr. Phil's FB page. There are many that say Mark is suspicious/guilty, and also many that criticize both parents for their arguing.

ETA: Some idiot thinks Elaine is "the guilty one".

Some dude from Zimbabwe commented...except he called the parents "stupid".

Well as I see it they would not be ARGUING if he would answer questions.
He answers questions with questions.

This all could have been avoided if he spoke to them from day one!

 

[asyousay]

I am still not feeling any distress or true emotion off Mark when you consider his 14 year old son is missing . I feel empathy towards Elaine as the distress she is in is clear to see and it's written all over her .

Yet with Mark I'm not feeling it ...:cow:

 

[cluciano63]

But they should have used a current photo. I agree with Cory that they chose this one for the wrong reasons. It is adorable and eye-catching, but it does not look like him now.

 

[SuperMom1995]

I never bothered to ask, I just thought it was him.

For those who believe in language analysis, you will notice when MR is asked a potentially sensitive question he answers with "we" and "you" and "us" and many investigators believe that is an indication that the person is attempting to share guilt or responsibility and deflect from their wrong doing.

 

[Eileen730]

I am still not feeling any distress or true emotion off Mark when you consider his 14 year old son is missing . I feel empathy towards Elaine as the distress she is in is clear to see and it's written all over her .

Yet with Mark I'm not feeling it ...:cow:

I think the distress comes tomorrow!