Coronavirus COVID-19 - Global Health Pandemic #100

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • #821
  • #822
How COVID-19 hybrid immunity could be a potential pandemic game-changer
More at link
With the FDA gearing up to decide if all Americans need booster shots, some researchers are pointing to preliminary data suggesting that mixing different vaccines could offer an even stronger immune boost.

For now, data is too sparse to support a mix-and-match strategy, experts say. But scientists are learning more about just how strong the immune response can be for someone who has previously been infected with COVID-19 then gets the vaccine -- a phenomenon called "hybrid immunity."
 
  • #823
  • #824
  • #825
One recent study claimed that natural immunity is actually better than the vaccines.

Do you have a link for that?
 
  • #826
  • #827
"So, the emerging science suggests that natural immunity is as good as or better than vaccine-induced immunity."
Natural immunity to covid is powerful. Policymakers seem afraid to say so. - The Washington Post

T
"So, the emerging science suggests that natural immunity is as good as or better than vaccine-induced immunity."
Natural immunity to covid is powerful. Policymakers seem afraid to say so. - The Washington Post

That presupposes you survive
 
  • #828
  • #829
Well, obviously you have to survive covid to get natural immunity. But those who are already infected are going to have natural immunity if they survive it, so getting them vaccinated is no longer the priority. Or at least shouldn't be. Based on more recent studies, natural immunity appears to be much better than what we were originally told.
 
  • #830
That is ridiculous
Why? I mean, I get the sentiment because it was my first reaction. However, I’m one who believes it’s reasonable, all other things being equal, to offer an ICU bed or ECMO treatment to someone who is vaccinated over someone who is not because the vaccinated are more likely to survive. That’s what happens when you are in a place that rationing care is necessary. This idea of rationing antibodies with a preference for those who are not vaccinated makes sense medically as those who are vaccinated are far less likely to have a severe case of covid.
 
  • #831
Well, obviously you have to survive covid to get natural immunity. But those who are already infected are going to have natural immunity if they survive it, so getting them vaccinated is no longer the priority. Or at least shouldn't be. Based on more recent studies, natural immunity appears to be much better than what we were originally told.

I can hear anti vaxxers using this as a way to rationalize not getting Vaccinated-
they will say see, I will have great immunity if I get the virus-- tbat is if
they survive, which lots of people havent ---
 
  • #832
Dbm
 
Last edited:
  • #833
I can hear anti vaxxers using this as a way to rationalize not getting Vaccinated-
they will say see, I will have great immunity if I get the virus-- tbat is if
they survive, which lots of people havent ---

On the flip side of this, why do people who have had documented cases of Covid, with a medically approved "Positive" Covid-19 test, why is it mandatory for these folks to be vaccinated? They already have antibodies, and natural immunity.

So, when proof of vaccines are "mandatory", to go to work, activities...why do people who already had Covid have to be vaccinated?
 
  • #834
Hello Knitty, let me ask you and everyone else this question...
Will you be going to restaurants, where you will eat inside with large groups of laughing, happy people?
Our customers want to eat outside on our open patio.
I, myself, only go to to restaurants where I can eat outside. Period.
There is not a meal on this planet that would entice me to dine inside a closed room with lots of people.
I pray that we can conquer this virus.
As a restaurant owner. The upcoming winter worries me.
I very much hope that I am worrying for no reason.
Question to members, will you be dinning indoors this winter?






I'm so sorry your business is still struggling. I thought that California had removed restrictions for restaurants, but that a few cities (or maybe counties) were continuing to require some restrictions. What are the rules affecting you now?
 
  • #835
What is strange to me is, I was only six years old when we were given the Salk vaccine at school. It was very new, but no one was saying how new it was and how we needed to know what was in it or how it contained stuff to control us, it did however, stop the cruel disease of polio.
I sure remember going to Sunday mass as a family, walking to the public school and waiting for the polio vaccine administered on a sugar cube. What a glorious day. Same with the small pox vaccine.
 
  • #836
Hello Knitty, let me ask you and everyone else this question...
Will you be going to restaurants, where you will eat inside with large groups of laughing, happy people?
Our customers want to eat outside on our open patio.
I, myself, only go to to restaurants where I can eat outside. Period.
There is not a meal on this planet that would entice me to dine inside a closed room with lots of people.
I pray that we can conquer this virus.
As a restaurant owner. The upcoming winter worries me.
I very much hope that I am worrying for no reason.
Question to members, will you be dinning indoors this winter?

I have not dined in any restaurant since early March 2020
and have no plans to change that any time soon and I hate
not going out for breakfast or dinner
 
  • #837
"So, the emerging science suggests that natural immunity is as good as or better than vaccine-induced immunity."
Natural immunity to covid is powerful. Policymakers seem afraid to say so. - The Washington Post

Another link:
Having SARS-CoV-2 once confers much greater immunity than a vaccine—but vaccination remains vital
Israelis who had an infection were more protected against the Delta coronavirus variant than those who had an already highly effective COVID-19 vaccine
 
  • #838
Why? I mean, I get the sentiment because it was my first reaction. However, I’m one who believes it’s reasonable, all other things being equal, to offer an ICU bed or ECMO treatment to someone who is vaccinated over someone who is not because the vaccinated are more likely to survive. That’s what happens when you are in a place that rationing care is necessary. This idea of rationing antibodies with a preference for those who are not vaccinated makes sense medically as those who are vaccinated are far less likely to have a severe case of covid.

Unless, for example, they are elderly (like me) and with underlying health conditions (like me). If I get a breakthrough case of Covid and am sick enough to need medical care, I would like antibody treatment, please.
 
  • #839
Hello Knitty, let me ask you and everyone else this question...
Will you be going to restaurants, where you will eat inside with large groups of laughing, happy people?
Our customers want to eat outside on our open patio.
I, myself, only go to restaurants where I can eat outside. Period.
There is not a meal on this planet that would entice me to dine inside a closed room with lots of people.
I pray that we can conquer this virus.
As a restaurant owner. The upcoming winter worries me.
I very much hope that I am worrying for no reason.
Question to members, will you be dining indoors this winter?
I live in Louisiana early in the pandemic, our governor closed down restaurants and bars to help curb the pandemic. Food orders could be picked up but not eaten inside. Later on, as our numbers improved, bars and restaurants were allowed to inside dining and drinking. My husband and I are fully vaccinated and have only eaten in a restaurant with our vaccinated family while on vacation. I was uncomfortable. We went after lunch and the large restaurant had a few tables with guests. I have no desire to eat at a restaurant until times get better. However, we order out from local restaurants a couple of times a week. We tip the curbside delivery and drive-thru person the same as though we ate inside. Many of the restaurants have adapted to outdoor dining. We’ve even seen people arriving in their pickup truck, set up a folding table and chairs to enjoy their meal while listening to the band playing on the restaurant patio. There are a few restaurants that now have food trucks that advertise the menu, date, time, and location where they set up.
 
  • #840
Hello Knitty, let me ask you and everyone else this question...
Will you be going to restaurants, where you will eat inside with large groups of laughing, happy people?
Our customers want to eat outside on our open patio.
I, myself, only go to to restaurants where I can eat outside. Period.
There is not a meal on this planet that would entice me to dine inside a closed room with lots of people.
I pray that we can conquer this virus.
As a restaurant owner. The upcoming winter worries me.
I very much hope that I am worrying for no reason.
Question to members, will you be dinning indoors this winter?

I’m not even going to eat outside at restaurants and it saddens and frustrates me to say that, both for you @KALI and for me. Our last restaurant meal was outside at our favorite restaurant in late October 2020. We were making plans to go there with friends after being vaxxed in late May, but Delta came along before we could. We are a cautious bunch here on this thread, so I guess you can hope that the risk-taker types we see filling bars and restaurants in our area will come to your restaurant. I’m so sorry. :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
60
Guests online
2,438
Total visitors
2,498

Forum statistics

Threads
632,801
Messages
18,631,890
Members
243,295
Latest member
holtc157@
Back
Top