Discussion Thread #61 ~ the appeal~

[aftermath]

.....where do get this stuff from.....i only agreed with your post ....you're making a real mockery of yourself....

Ah....and your post has changed again... ! Unsurprisingly, to slip in another snarky comment! I am not making a mockery of myself. And you are not engaging in meaningful discussion.

 

[GR_Turner]

LOL. I don't need to look it up!

IMO this was however DD ie. with intent ( remember "pre-med" does not exist in SA law and even over here is an abused term) - but no way that DD could be proved. So never expected that verdict.

On Masipa. :thinking: You keep repeating this same point.


As i recall well, lots of posters had faith, oops lots of top SA barristers had faith, quite a few posters were entirely cynical due to her approach, others had concerns due to her lack of experience to be given a position at that level. Concerns were soothed with reasoning re. different approaches in SA law. Research was done- little info. was available because it was true - she had little experience. The back story was good, the oft quoted harsh sentence in a DV case was clung to. That's it. I personally was totally naive in my faith that she would reach the correct verdict. I said so then, said it 30 pages ago - it's not a big deal to me, on any level. I think you're clutching at the wrong straws.

Verdict was delivered . More legal EXPERTS ( remember, not me and you as I said 30 or so pages ago) were confounded , described themselves as "stunned", "embarassed", "disquieted". They are trying to describe extreme surprise and shock at a miscarriage. They're not like little kiddies in the playground pretending that they never thought differently, secure as they are, in their own expertise, Ms. Turner.

Maybe they are right and maybe they are wrong. They expressed surprise about DE of the intruder and there are others who say Masipa got it right. I'm sure they are secure in their own expertise, and they disagreed with each about so many things so I guess their sense of security isn't always justified. We'll have to wait for the Heads to hear the arguments fully.

 

[aftermath]

....well i'm sorry to hear that FromGermany has quit hopefully those amongst us can convince her to come back i'm sure she's watching .......as for "give over" i took it off as i didn't want to upset the trolls......

Trolls?

 

[cottonweaver]

....well i'm sorry to hear that FromGermany has quit hopefully those amongst us can convince her to come back i'm sure she's watching .......as for "give over" i took it off as i didn't want to upset the trolls......

Sorry - I did not mean literally that FG has quit - I doubt that for one minute - a poster with stamina. And there's nothing rude about "Give Over".

 

[Colin de France]

Ah....and your post has changed again... ! Unsurprisingly, to slip in another snarky comment! I am not making a mockery of myself. And you are not engaging in meaningful discussion.

Give over............i simply replied to your post...i wish you would stop being so hysteric.....if i change my post's it's for the greater good ....

 

[GR_Turner]

BIB not sure which quote but anyway a couple of posters incl JJudi did the full number on Masipa and analysed the findings. You see, we are not experts on that, that's why it sounded impressive but it actually meant very little.

I meant 'post'.

 

[Colin de France]

Sorry - I did not mean literally that FG has quit - I doubt that for one minute - a poster with stamina. And there's nothing rude about "Give Over".

....there's nothing rude about "give over"....then in that case i know just the place ......

 

[aftermath]

...i simply replied to your post...i wish you would stop being so hysteric.....if i change my post's it's for the greater good ....

Yes- you simply changed your reply three times. Hardy hysterical- just pointing out that it is tricky to respond if the post you are responding to keeps changing. Perhaps try having the courage of your conviction and try standing by your original posts instead of doctoring them afterwards?

 

[aftermath]

Give over............i simply replied to your post...i wish you would stop being so hysteric.....if i change my post's it's for the greater good ....

Yay! The 'give over' is back again!

 

[Colin de France]

Yes- you simply changed your reply three times. Hardy hysterical- just pointing out that it is tricky to respond if the post you are responding to keeps changing. Perhaps try having the courage of your conviction and try standing by your original posts instead of doctoring them afterwards?

........i'd like to see you write in French at the same speed as i write in English......if i change my post's it's out of respect for those who might read them.....

 

[Colin de France]

Yay! The 'give over' is back again!

....as long as it's not rude, i don't want you to keep hanging on that triangle button ......

 

[Trotterly]

....as long as it's not rude, i don't want you to keep hanging on that triangle button ......

Then try and remain polite then.

 

[Colin de France]

Yes- you simply changed your reply three times. Hardy hysterical- just pointing out that it is tricky to respond if the post you are responding to keeps changing. Perhaps try having the courage of your conviction and try standing by your original posts instead of doctoring them afterwards?

....the best thing to do then is to give me a little time, instead of constantly hanging over my shoulder....i promise you that i won't let you down ......

 

[Colin de France]

Then try and remain polite then.

.......polite....you won't find anyone more polite than me .........

 

[Trotterly]

....the best thing to do then is to give me a little time, instead of constantly hanging over my shoulder....i promise you that i won't let you down ......

It's okay to keep changing your version then?

 

[Colin de France]

It's okay to keep changing your version then?

......i try to react as quickly as possible before someone else sends a post.......

 

[cottonweaver]

Maybe they are right and maybe they are wrong. They expressed surprise about DE of the intruder and there are others who say Masipa got it right. I'm sure they are secure in their own expertise, and they disagreed with each about so many things so I guess their sense of security isn't always justified. We'll have to wait for the Heads to hear the arguments fully.

Those think that Masipa got it right - there weren't many. Hence the academics could only name a few - Burchell & Taitz. Drop in the ocean. Oh wait let's throw in the top flight Kelly Phelps.:drumroll:

Drop in the ocean ie. Equivalent to a couple hundred? "Pistorians " (not incl their aliases) across the globe who think the world is made of green cheese......

I need to edit my post to make clear that I genuinely adore green and blue cheese

 

[GR_Turner]

Those think that Masipa got it right - there weren't many. Hence the academics could only name a few - Burchell & Taitz. Drop in the ocean. Oh wait let's throw in the top flight Kelly Phelps.:drumroll:

Drop in the ocean ie. Equivalent to a couple hundred? "Pistorians " (not incl their aliases) across the globe who think the world is made of green cheese......

Let's also throw in Callie Snyman.

 

[Colin de France]

...this discussion used to be really interesting it's now being ruined on purpose...............

 

[Trotterly]

...this discussion used to be really interesting it's now being ruined on purpose...............

By anyone who does not share your opinion right?