Something extremely important that I have not heard or seen discussed so far just hit me like a ton of bricks. Has ANYONE who has conducted an analysis of existing information (including Riibe’s general narrative, certain features of his transcribed interview that are problematic, detailed data on sea conditions during the relevant date and time, failure to recover a body after this many days in spite of massive mobilization of resources which seem to have contributed to a timely and thorough search effort) considered the huge height difference between JR and SK? Like Konanki, I am a 5’3” woman. In the video of the group heading to the beach, much attention has been paid to SK’s level of intoxication, but what struck me is how small she looks, standing or clinging to JR in those moments, because JR is clearly much taller. I was raised on the coast of the Pacific Ocean in a city where surfing is a ubiquitous pastime. When you are 5’3”, being in any ocean with a group of friends can be tricky business. A very short wave that hits you in water that barely hits your knees is a submersible event. Your feet lose contact with the sandy bottom a lot sooner than other people, so while your friends may continue to laugh and splash around with ease, you have begun to tred water. What matters to me is this- the depth at which Josh Riibe would be “waist deep” in water would put Konanki in water above her chest level. Here is what I hope all you sleuths can help me consider: how does this significant difference in height play into Riibe’s description of events? If he almost drowned himself (“nearly lost consciousness”) and essentially began puking up seawater before collapsing out of exhaustion as soon as his feet hit the sand, or as soon as he was out of the surf enough to be totally in control and out of danger, how deep was that water? How deep was the water for Konanki? One does NOT travel fast or far without quite a bit of exertion when one is 5’3” and knee deep in the ocean. The discrepancy between their sizes, especially height but absolutely also general frame, would have impacted their experience that night so much that, we’re his story coming from real, unedited memory, there would have been evidence of it. The discrepancies in their sizes, fitness levels, and experience swimming (one had worked for three years as a lifeguard and was a strong swimmer) should have manifested in all sorts of subtle or obvious aspects of his story. IMO, the story he describes rings very true in a ton of ways IF you imagine that once a largewave hit, he immediately let go of SK and then needed every bit of his strength to fight for his own life and get to shore. I believe a lot of the details his shares are true— he was waist deep, a wave that was “big” by his standards hit (data says waves were around 5’ at that time in that location, and that he was pulled very quickly out to sea, causing him to start fighting against the rip current to survive, being so much in danger that he swallowed enormous amounts of water, almost lost consciousness, and barely avoided drowning. Vomiting up seawater and collapsing on the shore and passing out the way he describes is totally consistent with a near drowning experience. The parts of his story that make no sense are those parts where Konanki is supposedly present. Thoughts???