GUILTY FL - 17 killed in Stoneman Douglas High School shooting, Parkland, 14 Feb 2018 *shooter Guilty, School officer NG* #5

  • #541
TRIAL HIGHLIGHTS
DAY 8 – 6/21/23

  • Judge Martin Fein narrowly denied the defense’s motion for a judgment of acquittal on all counts after expressing doubt towards the strength of the evidence showing that Scot Peterson caused the vicitms’ injuries — an element of the charge of child neglect.
  • The defense’s case began in earnest with testimony from MSD students and staff who, like Peterson, said that they initially mistook the gunshots for fireworks and could not tell where the loud pops were coming from.
  • Peterson’s supervisor, BSO Sgt. Ryan Miller, said he thought he heard the gunshots coming from the football field, a belief that was affirmed by BSO Dep. Michael Kratz’s (erroneous) radio call that the shots were fired by the football field.
    • Miller said that Peterson was “distraught” when Miller saw him the next day and thanked him for his efforts.
  • Det. John Curcio — the lead detective on the shooting investigation — teared up while describing the goal in an active shooting: “stop [the shooter] from killing people… slowing him down… anything to help kids find safety.”
  • Curcio testified about statements Peterson made to him in an interview that led to Peterson being charged with perjury:
    • He only heard 2-3 shots, while surveillance video shows Peterson outside the 1200 building for more than four minutes while approximately 70 rounds were fired on the second and third floors.
    • He didn’t see anyone leaving the 1200 building before police went in to lead the students out. Multiple witnesses have testified to seeing Peterson outside the building but the timing is not clear.
 
  • #542
Day 9: Live in 65 minutes, 12:30 pm ET

 
  • #543
June 22, 2023, 5:01 PM
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. -- The courtroom battle over whether the sound of gunshots during the Parkland school massacre should have directed a Florida sheriff's deputy to the attacker's location ramped up Thursday as defense testimony showed others also thought the thunderous blasts were coming from elsewhere.

A sheriff's deputy, teachers and students, testifying during the trial of former Broward County Deputy Scot Peterson, gave divergent answers when asked where they thought the shots were coming from during Nikolas Cruz's Feb. 14, 2018, attack at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School. Fourteen students and three staff members died.
[...]
 
  • #544
TRIAL HIGHLIGHTS
DAY 9 – 6/22/23

  • Jurors heard from three students and two teachers at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School who were in the 700 building the day of the shootings.
    • Two sisters in the same theater class had differing descriptions on where they thought the gunshots came from. One thought they came from the senior parking lot, the other thought they came from the football field. Neither sister saw Scot Peterson.
    • Dylan Redshaw became emotional while testifying via Zoom. She described hearing bangs outside the building after she hid.
    • WATCH: Parkland School Cop Trial: Teacher Testifies for Defense
  • Broward County Sheriff’s Office Deputy Brian Goolsby testified that he had to go outside to talk on his radio, because it didn’t work well inside of the building.
  • Goolsby said he heard Peterson’s transmission on the radio of where the shooter was, and described how the news of the shooting overwhelmed him phsyically.
    • Goolsby described tunnel vision, increasing heart rate, a rush of adrenaline, shaking hands and dry mouth.
  • Broward County Director of Regional Communications Angela Mize testified that the Coral Springs Police Department had their own computers, phones and radios because they wanted to be autonomous.
    • All 911 calls made by children from inside the school went to Coral Gables, while calls from landlines would have gone to the Broward County Sheriff’s Office.
    • Coral Gables dispatchers contacted sheriff’s dispatchers 2-3 times telling them there was an incident at the school, but the dispatchers never spoke with the callers.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: IDK
  • #545
June 22, 2023
One after another, the defense called former Marjory Stoneman Douglas students and teachers to testify about the gunshots they heard the day of the 2018 school tragedy, but that they had no clue where they came from.
“I don’t know, I thought it was coming from everywhere around me,” said former student Dylan Redshaw.
[...]
Defense attorneys say they could rest their case as early as Friday.
 
  • #546
JUNE 23, 2023 / 7:23 AM / CBS/AP
FORT LAUDERDALE - Former Broward school resource officer Scot Peterson may take the stand in his own defense on Friday.
[...]
Before the trial, Peterson said he was looking forward to it so the truth could be told. The judge presiding over the trial told him he had to decide Friday whether he would testify or not.
[...]
Sheriff's Sgt. Brian Goolsby, who arrived during the shooting, said he thought the gunfire was coming from a courtyard next to the 1200 building. He said that even when he arrived outside the building and saw the body of a coach outside a door and its damaged windows, he wasn't totally convinced the shots had come from inside - perhaps the shots had struck the coach and windows from a nearby balcony or trees.
[...]
 
  • Like
Reactions: IDK
  • #547
  • Like
Reactions: IDK
  • #548

Scot Peterson defense attorney says school shooting was chaotic, confusing; defense to rest Monday​

June 23, 2023
[...]
Defense attorney Mark Eiglarsh said Friday he plans to rest his case Monday adding the trial is going very well.

“I am glad the world is getting to know what we’ve known for five years,” he said. “The scene at the school was chaotic and my client did his best to secure it. Hundreds of people were there and were confused about where the shots were coming from.”
[...]
 
  • #549
  • Wow
Reactions: IDK
  • #550

Defense rests in trial of Scot Peterson, deputy charged with failing to confront Parkland shooter​

Story by NBC6 and AP
June 23, 2023
Jurors are set to begin deliberations next week in the trial of a former Broward Sheriff's deputy accused of failing to confront the Parkland school gunman after his attorneys rested their case Friday.
[...]
Broward Circuit Judge Martin Fein said closing arguments will be delivered Monday before the jury begins deliberations.
[...]
 
  • Like
Reactions: IDK
  • #551
TRIAL HIGHLIGHTS
DAY 10 – 6/23/23

  • The defense rested its case after calling 20 witnesses.
  • Parkland resource officer took the stand and testified he did not know where the shots were coming from, and that communication between the departments was insufficient.
    • On cross, prosecutors implied the officer was testifying to protect his friend.
  • A former student testified, saying they could not tell where shots were coming from.
  • A communications officer testified to the breakdown in communication, saying that deputies had trouble communicating and that communication was never patched.
    • Once dispatchers heard shots fired, backup was sent immediately.
  • WATCH: Scot Peterson Will Not Testify in Parkland School Cop Trial
 
  • #552
  • #553
  • #554
Updated: June 26, 2023 at 5:19 PM
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. – It is now verdict watch in the trial of a former Broward Sheriff’s Office deputy accused of failing to confront the shooter who murdered 14 students and three staff members at a Parkland high school five years ago. After a day of closing arguments, the judge sent the six-member jury at 4:34 p.m. to deliberate.
 
  • #555
BY CNN, 7 NEWS WHDH
JUNE 26, 2023
(CNN) — Jurors have ended their first day of deliberations in the trial of a former school resource officer who stayed outside during the February 2018 mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School.

The jury is set to continue deliberating Tuesday morning.

Earlier Monday, prosecutors urged the group to find Scot Peterson guilty on all counts, contending his alleged inaction contributed to the deaths of six victims and the injuries of four others in the attack. His attorneys have contended the former deputy did nothing wrong and couldn’t tell where the shots were coming from. Seventeen people died in the shooting.

Both prosecutors and Peterson’s attorneys agreed to remove a juror who, according to the state, had attended the penalty phase in the trial of convicted Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz and knew victims’ advocates in the prosecution’s office. The juror was replaced by an alternate.
[...]
 
  • #556
  • #557
  • #558
Published June 27, 2023 at 6:09 AM EDT
[...]
Peterson, 60, is the first U.S. law enforcement officer prosecuted for his alleged actions and inaction during a mass shooting at a school.
[...]
The central question of the case was what Peterson heard and knew during the shooting. His lawyer argued that he did not know exactly where the shots were coming from or how many shooters there were.

"He doesn't know that there's one shooter. Nobody knows that. We have the luxury in this courtroom of hindsight. Hindsight is 20/20," Mark Eiglarsh told jurors during his two-hour long closing argument.
[...]
"He was sacrificed. He was thrown under the bus," Eiglarsh said of Peterson, who was retroactively fired from the Broward Sheriff's Office after he resigned following the shooting. Peterson would have been blamed even if he left his "tactical position of cover" outside of the building, Eiglarsh said.
[...]
 
  • #559
TRIAL HIGHLIGHTS
DAY 11 – 6/26/23

  • Judge Martin Fein dismissed the jury for the day at 6 p.m. after 90 minutes of deliberations.
  • The jury began deliberating after hearing four hours of closing arguments and an hour of jury instructions.
  • Peterson shook his head in disgust at various points during the prosecution’s closing arguments.
  • Assistant State Attorney Kristen Gomes delivered the first closing for the prosecution:
    • By choosing to “run away” from the 1200 building, Scot Peterson left a “predator unchecked” and an “unrestricted killer” wandering the third floor for four minutes when Peterson should have intervened.
    • His job didn’t require him to go on a “suicide mission,” but it did call for him disrupt the shooter with his “mere presence” and force a different outcome.
    • Instead, he prioritized his life over those of the victims by staying outside for 40 minutes, violating his duty as their caregiver.
    • WATCH: Parkland School Cop Trial: Prosecution Closing Argument
  • Defense lawyer Mark Eiglarsh ran out of time delivering his closing argument:
    • The state’s case hinges on an “erroneous belief” that Peterson knew kids were being shot inside the 1200 building, but neither he or witnesses who testified could say for sure where the gunfire was coming from.
    • The evidence shows that multiple people failed to share with Peterson critical real time intelligence that would have sent him into the building.
    • Peterson is a hero who risked his life doing everything he could to protect people, from announcing “shots fired” and ordering a code red to making himself “vulnerable” by holding his position without donning a bulletproof vest. Instead of thanking him… we’re prosecuting him.
    • WATCH: Parkland School Cop Trial: Defense Closing Argument
  • Assistant State Attorney Chris Killoran invoked the Nike catchphrase “Just do it” to describe all the things Peterson should have done: If you can’t hear, you move. If you can’t see, you move… you don’t just stand there.
  • A juror who is a victim advocate in the Broward State Attorney’s office was excused after it came out that she attended the Parkland school shooter’s penalty phase and was more involved in the case than she previously disclosed.
  • READ MORE: Prosecutor: Cop fled during massacre, put own life ahead of students’
 
  • #560

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
71
Guests online
2,241
Total visitors
2,312

Forum statistics

Threads
633,225
Messages
18,638,196
Members
243,452
Latest member
odettee
Back
Top