They've only lived there 4-6 mos. I think, and dad made it sound like he never spent any time in the back yard (except twice to take vacuum down ramp to vacuum car). Neighbors reported Haleigh, her brother and their own kids playing outdoors after dad left for work, presumably that eve. So where outside were they playing outside? In neighbors' yard? In Cummings' front yard, back yard? More importantly, was Haleigh seen afterwards? When did someone ELSE see Haleigh, (ie after dad said bye and left for work). Exactly what time was that, and when can anyone last place Haleigh after seen playing outdoors w neighbor kids? Maybe she disappeared earlier but wasn't reported missing? Just an idea, sorry if mentioned these are fast moving threads!! JMO