This is a clever analogy--makes me smirk a little every time I read it.
The cell phone belonged to Travis. He was and is, I guess, a longtime friend of Logan and Jennifer. Actually, he is referred to as a "Kesse family" friend. He stayed in Jenn's condo with Logan the whole time Jenn was in St. Croix with her boyfriend, Rob. I think it is also important to note Travis returned to Jennifer's condo with Logan on the 24th--so it's unlikely he lived in Orlando.
I hope someone jumps in to correct me if I am wrong, but I believe Logan stated on one of the mini-documentaries on Jenn's case that he and Travis were both investigated and polygraphed.
Travis is not the male friend that Jenn had formerly dated and who purportedly still carried a torch for her. (And got "stinking drunk per Mr. Kesse" at the Blue Martini on the evening of the 23rd). This person did live in Orlando at the time. It came out through the current podcast that an "unnamed source" stated this person had only joined Logan and Travis at Jennifer's condo for "drinks" one evening. He offered to take a poly but LE failed to follow-up on it. It is said his alibi checked out. Again, these last bits of information come only from an "unnamed podcast source".
This seems to be the theory du jour. One theory is as good another, so I hope I'm not hurting anyone's feelings when I say that I don't personally subscribe to it.
I try not to put Jennifer on a pedestal, but I do believe that she was a sincere, hard-working, and loyal individual. I don't believe she would have told Rob she was in bed for the night and then gone out on him. Jennifer loved Rob and wanted to spend the rest of her life with him. I feel it's unlikely she would have lied to him in such a blatant, disrespectful manner.
What if the knock had occurred during the approximate two-hour conversation (?) Jenn had with her girlfriend since the 2nd grade? Keep in mind that if we believe the ping study, she was most likely only at her condo for about three/three and a half hours before whatever happened, happened--so possibly two out of the approximate three hours, Jennifer had talked to her girlfriend.
All we really know is that a knock occurred on her door at an unknown time during the evening of the 23rd and for some reason Jennifer "believed" it was her male, upstairs neighbor. We are told she did not answer. Did she look out through her peephole? Did she assume it was the male, upstairs neighbor because he had a habit of knocking on her door in the evening?
What if she didn't have her car parked in its normal spot with her condo number on it and this (plus the unanswered knock) lead someone to believe she still was not home from vacation? What if they came back a little later with a key--by this time Jennifer had finished her conversations with Travis, her girlfriend, and Rob and was in bed beginning to fall asleep. Had she been so exhausted that evening she hadn't placed the chairs under her doorknobs?
I dunno. I don't really favor a surprise attack because this whole thing seems too well planned to me. I'm just sitting here wasting my time, I guess.
The more workable theories the better. One thing I've observed since becoming a member here : it's common for posters to come to believe that they "know" a missing person because we delve into their lives. I've noticed that we don't really "know" them at all. I wasn't suggesting anything nefarious on JK's part when I wrote that she may have gone out that night. JK was a grown woman, living alone. Nothing wrong with going out, say for a drink, with an old friend, or someone from work. And why tell her BF ? perhaps she believed it would upset him for no cause, and didn't want to do that. She was single, and not engaged. I have never heard about her work phone calls from that last day she was there. Or any info about earlier cell phone calls or texts. She could have been contacted during the day, and agreed to meet someone later that evening.
I do buy the ping movements of the phones. jmo, though.