- Joined
- Jul 8, 2008
- Messages
- 18,286
- Reaction score
- 51,424
I still can't understand why a plea was accepted.
I still can't understand why a plea was accepted.
Im not sure how to interpret her not showing up.And where is Jen Soto... She couldn't manage to attend a plea hearing for her daughter's rape and murder?
Her and Sterns are both cowards.
Stephan Sterns deserves something more sustained than a shank. He needs to be looking over his shoulder in terror every day for many years. He needs some hefty street guys to get his attention because I’m pretty sure he wasn’t listening to the victims in court today.If Florida prisons are like Louisiana’s Angola, tons of prisoners have shanks.
Thank you for suggesting I reword it. I went and did that.Maybe re-word it? I get that you didn't mean that Maddie didn't start it, but the comment can be taken that way. IMO.
ETA my opinion
Actually? I don't think there is a single thing she could have said that would change anything about how people think about her. It has been very obvious that she allowed a grown man to sleep with her daughter. Nothing will ever change that. She is guilty of something in the eyes of the public and always will be, she deserves it.What does that tell you? How do you interpret that?
I understand she was in a no win situation, whether she showed up or not.
but now she lives as though she is guilty of something in the eyes of the public, maybe she doesnt care.
That was a missed opportunity, for her to say something that might change how people react to her, but she chose not to. What does that tell us?
yeah youre probably right, she could feel guilty for that part alone, but it does make me wonder how much more there is that we dont know.Actually? I don't think there is a single thing she could have said that would change anything about how people think about her. It has been very obvious that she allowed a grown man to sleep with her daughter. Nothing will ever change that. She is guilty of something in the eyes of the public and always will be, she deserves it.
Why did the State acquiesce?
Any chance that debacle with the sheriff posting a photo of corpse on SM would have brought questions about honesty among LE the investigation? It’s about the only thing I can think of as to why this plea was almost a giveaway. MOOPhone records were in. They could have held the irons to the fire. He pleads guilty and allocates or it's DP. He was in no position to bargain.
(Trial) cost analysis maybe. But that isn't satisfying. Why why why did they let him off easy? He should have been forced to say guilty, say whether he acted alone. Otherwise DP stays.
Maybe everyone is gunshy after Caylee but this was solid.
The State caved.
SS brought NOTHING to the negotiations table.
No contest.
That is not right.
JMO
Why should she care on this day of all days what people think of her? (I'm not directing that question at you, but in general.)Im not sure how to interpret her not showing up.
I understand she was in a no win situation, whether she showed up or not.
but now she lives as though she is guilty of something in the eyes of the public, maybe she doesnt care.
That was a missed opportunity, for her to say something that might change how people react to her, but she chose not to. What does that tell us?
What was that big huddle about with the judge?Did anyone get a breakdown on what he did plead actual 'guilty' to?
I was so upset over the 'no contest' chorus, I missed it.
Ive followed your posts for a long time, I knew what you meant. it was a tongue in cheek response. I know you didnt believe it was her fault and were just reiterating him saying to his parents " I didnt start it" I remember that call very well.Thank you for suggesting I reword it. I went and did that.
At first I had no idea how someone could come to that conclusion (because I knew what I meant), but reading my post thru someone else's eyes made me see how what I was trying to say could be totally misconstrued. My point (that I failed to get across) was that I didn't think it was JS that started it (the post I was quoting was saying that), and that to SS, he was thinking Maddie started it cuz that's just the way he is. Nothing is his fault, even things that was WAY smaller than what he did to that poor child. He's a very flawed human being in that regard.
I agree with the plea, although he soooo deserves PD. I just thought the terms weren’t tough enough and what was said to and required of the perv in court was very lacking. Contrast this plea hearing to the sicko murderer’s in Idaho.I get it, Rio, but it just seems so unfinished and almost like a "win" for this perv/killer.
It's also very gross that he was able to make a statement, but we've seen that before, too.
I'm not going back to re-watch, but did the judge say anything to his crimes? Anything about him being the worst of the worst?
Maddie's case will haunt me for a very long time.
IMO.
so true, I have to process this part a little more because Im not sure what to think about it, if its shame that made her not show up or if its guilt.Why should she care on this day of all days what people think of her? (I'm not directing that question at you, but in general.)
I would think a mother would be thinking of her daughter, not herself, on this day. As a mom, she could have been there to represent her daughter who was used, injured, and murdered by the man in court. Even if she didn't say anything, she could have the decency to be there in place of her daughter to witness justice happen.
But, she's never stood by Maddie, imo. Maybe she didn't want to "take sides" against SS, for all we know.
Nothing but cowards, both of them.
jmopinion
I get what you are laying down. It would have been a huge opportunity for her to give a strong statement about her daughter FINALLY. That could have went a long way towards people having at least some goodwill towards her.so true, I have to process this part a little more because Im not sure what to think about it, if its shame that made her not show up or if its guilt.
Yes thank you, Thats exactly what I meant.I get what you are laying down. It would have been a huge opportunity for her to give a strong statement about her daughter FINALLY. That could have went a long way towards people having at least some goodwill towards her.
No, it wasn't even tongue in cheek. It was bad wording on my part and it failed to get my point across. I took the good advice and reworded it cuz I'd hate to think someone could think I meant it was Maddie's fault, when nothing is further than the truth. That fault lays squarely on JS for turning a blind eye and sending her daughter to bed with a grown man, and SS's fault for being a disgusting human being and doing unspeakable things to a little girl. Absolutely no fault at all of Maddie's.Ive followed your posts for a long time, I knew what you meant. it was a tongue in cheek response. I know you didnt believe it was her fault and were just reiterating him saying to his parents " I didnt start it" I remember that call very well.
I get what you are laying down. It would have been a huge opportunity for her to give a strong statement about her daughter FINALLY. That could have went a long way towards people having at least some goodwill towards her.
I get it, someone new may misinterpret, its all good now tho.No, it wasn't even tongue in cheek. It was bad wording on my part and it failed to get my point across. I took the good advice and reworded it cuz I'd hate to think someone could think I meant it was Maddie's fault, when nothing is further than the truth. That fault lays squarely on JS for turning a blind eye and sending her daughter to bed with a grown man, and SS's fault for being a disgusting human being and doing unspeakable things to a little girl. Absolutely no fault at all of Maddie's.