Notes: Helpful observations, and information with some official verification that may help toward resolution
Verified: Answered using official verification (may include supplemental evidence)
Value of point/question (by consensus):
A-C, with A being most important;
D = unsleuthable
1. Name and address of the twins’ daycare facility.
A,D
2. Time when MP picked up the twins from daycare on 11/17/11.
B Notes: Picked up sometime between 2:30 and 3:18 PM Unconfirmed witness report places MP on 208 exiting at Alafaya around 3 PM.
3. What time did MP’s Hummer leave DS II’s condo?
A Notes: Hummer left sometime between 3:18 PM and 10:06 PM. Suggestion is that Hummer shown leaving at 5:15 PM may be MP’s Hummer.
4. Eyewitness or video of above?
A (video) C (eyewitness) Notes: Suggestion is that RG’s surveillance vid does show Hummer leaving, perhaps 5:15 PM vehicle
5. When did DS II leave the condo in his own vehicle?
A Notes: Suggestion that we have no evidence of DS II driving his own vehicle at all that day. (andalso, 1/6/12)
6. Did DS II know about RG’s video camera, e.g., did RG ever discuss the camera with DS II?
A Notes: The camera is in plain view on the balcony, as seen in photo taken 12/4 by AlwaysWright http://s1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa378/AlwaysWright01/?action=view¤t=December4822.jpg. (4BB)
7. Did others in DS Sr.’s neighborhood see vehicles arriving and leaving on 11/17/11 afternoon?
A Notes: MN says that someone was a witness to DS II and the twins being at Rose Ave. house “by 4:30.” We do not know the nature of this observation (i.e. what vehicle DS II drove, whether the witness saw only a vehicle with the twins and not DS II, etc.).
8. Location MP’s cell pinged for 4:26 PM “Waterford” text to brother.
A Notes: Phone was said to have pinged in area of S. Orange Ave. and W. Sand Lake Rd, but we know neither the time of that ping, nor whether is was the Waterford text. http://www.cfcrimeline.com/most_recent.htm; Hoffner Rd. moving west of Semoran has been mentioned for MP cell ping at “about 4:30,” but no more specific location, and no confirmation that this was the “Waterford” ping. http://www.myfoxorlando.com/dpp/new...o-of-michelle-parker-from-day-she-disappeared and http://www.clickorlando.com/news/Fa...arker-s-birthday/-/1637132/8455176/-/pj560l/- (captdj, BreathLife21, 1/21/12) See question #170.
9. When was MP supposed to meet boyfriend NM for dinner on 11/17?
Notes: Suggestion is, sometime between about 4 PM and 7:00 PM.
10. Phone calls from MP’s family to DS II: (A) when did MP’s sister LE call DS II on 11/17/11
B-, and (B) what time did YS call DS II 11/17/11 evening?
A
11. Phone numbers (i.e. cell or land line at condo or Rose Ave.) and times for above calls, by (A) Sister LE
B-, and (B) YS ?
A
12. If Mrs. DS Sr. (TS) answered the call from YS, what did she say to YS in reference to why DS II couldn’t come to the phone?
A Notes: Reports state that TS did answer when YS tried to call DS II. Suggestion from unlocated news story that TS told YS that DS II and DS Jr. had gone out back.
13. When did DS II return YS’s call, from what number, and, if his cell, from what location?
A
14. When did LE first contact DS II, and how?
A Notes: We are still awaiting confirmation that LE searched DS II’s condo on 11/17; thus far, the only confirmed date we have for a search is 11/18, and we still don’t know when and how first contact was made.
15. Did LE search DS II’s condo on evening of 11/17/11, and if so, when did DS II return to his condo from Rose Ave. evening of 11/17/11 to meet LE?
A Notes: DS II posted statement on Facebook at 11:08 PM saying that LE had just searched his condo. Presumption is that LE may have made a quick visit to the condo that evening.
16. When he returned, were the twins with him, or did he leave them at DS Sr.’s house?
C
17. Was MP’s cell on the entire time up until it was powered down the evening of 11/17/11, and if it was powered on the entire time, was it moving around constantly (like in a car), or static in one or more locations? What locations have been noted for her cell between 3:18 PM and when it was powered down?
Notes: cell is said to have pinged in the vicinity of Sand Lake Rd and Orange Ave., time unknown, and source unverified; cell was reportedly found under Nela bridge. A report on 11/18/11 stated that LE had said the cell phone was turned off manually after MP had seen DS II, but did not indicate a specific time http://www.wdbo.com/news/news/local/police-search-missing-woman-car-found/nFhJ6/ (pias, 2/4/12); see question #8 for more ping location information.
18. Additional unreleased videos or other electronic evidence to track the route of MP’s Hummer after 3:18 PM on 11/17/11 (including OnStar, even if it was inactive).
Notes: Helpful information and links explaining EPass--http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7430815&postcount=400 (Sparky, 12/12/11); there is a traffic cam at or near the intersection of Goldenrod and Lee Vista. http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news/2011/january/199877
19. Additional unreleased eyewitness accounts of Hummer movements around town after 3:18 PM.
20. Details of search warrant for DS Sr.'s house on Rose Ave (i.e. probable cause, etc).
Notes: Speculation that reason given for raid was marijuana cultivation on the property.
21. Relative to MP’s boyfriend NM: (A) What is NM’s alibi for 11/17/11 afternoon, and where was he during the times in question? (B) Where does he live/work?
Notes: According to Facebook, he works at United Rentals as a field service tech. in Orlando. He was lives in Deltona.
22. Who else called or texted MP on 11/17/11 between 2:30 PM and 3:18 PM?
23. Did MP send or receive any texts or make or receive any calls to/from DS II on 11/16 or on 11/17/11 before 3:18 PM?
24. Was DS II’s cell on the entire time, and if it was, what locations have been noted for his cell after 3:18 PM on 11/17/11?
25. Does DS Sr. own a cell? If so, was his cell on the entire time, and what locations have been noted for his cell after 3:18 PM on 11/17/11?
26. What if any evidence did LE find in and on the Hummer?
27. What fingerprints were on MP's Hummer and her purse and belongings, and where were these located in and on the Hummer when it was found?
28. If Dale's prints were found in her Hummer, does he frequently get in her car?
29. Was the Hummer driver's seat set for MP or someone taller?
30. (A) Were all the Hummer mirrors adjusted to the seat level? (B) Whose fingerprints were on the mirror(s)?
31. Was the Hummer recently washed?
32. Did the floor mats and wheel wells of the Hummer or other DS II/Sr. vehicles have any type of dirt, mud, or material that would possibly match up with a body of water, woods, or overgrown areas?
33. What if any evidence did LE find at the Rose Ave. house and in any vehicles at the house?
34. Did LE search DS II’s work van, truck, and any other of his vehicles?
35. Did LE check DS II’s trash inside and out?
36. For assumed 11/17/11 search of DS II’s condo, who arrived at the condo for the search first: LE or DS II?
37. If LE was there first, did DS II arrive in his truck & pull into the garage or did someone else drive him, and who?
38. If DS II was already there when LE arrived, (A) were there any other vehicles or persons there with him, and (B) did LE check the hood temps of vehicles parked at the condo?
39. Does DS II own a bicycle, or have access to one at the Rose Avenue house?
40. Confirm ownership of various white vans that appear in RG’s video, in TP’s later interview with RG, in AlwaysWright’s photos, and in survey photos from the tax appraiser website.
NOTES: Interview shows larger white van in DS II’s driveway (Chevy?), white van shown in RG’s video appears to be different make (Dodge?) (Cerebellum, 12/4); the taillights and door handles are different (Kimb103, 12/4) Pictures comparing DS II’s van and van parked on street in RG’s vid show door handle difference Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #16 (Sparky, 12/29/11); DS II’s van has taillights on the upper rear, van parked on street has taillights on lower half of rear Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #16 (captdj, TexasLil 1/5/12); suggestion that the van arriving at 3:18 PM and parked on the street could be an older model Chevy cargo van Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #16 Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #16 (Kamille, 1/9/12) Survey picture and AlwaysWright’s picture show what appear to be two different white vans parked in the right side of DS II’s driveway. Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #16 (Lark2, 1/7/12); more ideas about the makes and models of the white vans: van parked on street in surveillance vid is Dodge Ram, van parked in DS II’s driveway in AlwaysWright’s photos is GMC Savannah. (?) Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #16 (Sleuth Decay, 1/9/12).Lower left timestamp for the RG surveillance camera image is 16:25 according to TP Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #9
41. (A) Did DS II have his own car seats for the twins, or did DS II and MP share car seats? (B) Did LE account for all child car seats owned by the families on both sides?
42. Did the Hummer have child car seats when found?
43. Did/will LE search bodies of water near the parking lot where the Hummer was found?
44. Would it be possible and effective for LE to use heat sensors from helicopters, at night, to help in searches?
45.
Has LE used or will they use metal detectors to aid in finding the cell phone during searches? Notes: LE located cell; see #78 for new questions
46. Where is DS II’s unit located within the condo, especially with respect to his neighbor RG’s camera?
Verified: Orange County property records http://www.ocpafl.org/ indicate address as 6598 S. Goldenrod unit 97C, photos of DS II’s condo http://s1194.photobucket.com/albums/aa378/AlwaysWright01/ show that unit C (DS II’s unit) is the right hand unit, RG lives on the left side unit, and RG’s camera captures his parking area and a portion of the street to the northeast of his side of the unit (AlwaysWright, 12/4)
47. If Carter Glen (DS II’s condo complex) has cameras or other devices at the north and south entrances and exits to the complex, did one or more capture any images or records of MP’s Hummer arriving and/or leaving on 11/17/11, along with time of arrival and departure?
NOTES: The gates to the complex are closed and require one of the following: (1) Enter a specific code to open gate (Guests given code by Homeowner); (2) Card or Gate Opener to open gate (Homeowner); (3) Use the directory to contact Homeowner so they can buzz you in using phone; (4) Follow a car that has been granted access. (AlwaysWright, 12/5) Carter Glen resident said that cameras at entrance to condos had captured an image of the Hummer leaving—time unknown—without the decals. Always Wright visited the condos and noted a stand for a video camera at the entrances along with signage in the complex that the area is under surveillance. Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #14 (AlwaysWright, 12/15)
48. Did Carter Glen cameras or other devices capture any images or records of DS II’s vehicles arriving or leaving on 11/17/11 and 18, along with time of arrival and departure?
Notes: See comments to #47
49. Did Carter Glen cameras or other devices capture any images or records of DS II’s family's or friends' vehicles arriving or leaving on 11/17/11?
Notes: See comments to #47
50. Does DS Sr. have restrictions or physical disabilities that prevent him from being able to drive?
51. Did DS II spend the night of 11/17/11, after the supposed LE search, at his condo?
52. What time did DS II leave his condo for work on Friday, 11/18/11?
53. What vehicle was he driving from his condo on 11/18/11 AM?
54. Did he make any stops to load work materials, change vehicles, etc. before leaving Orlando area, and if so, where?
55. What route did he take to reach
Titusville Palm Bay?
Notes: Updated information that DS II had a job in Palm Bay instead of Titusville on Friday, 11/18/11.
56. What time did he arrive at his work destination in
Titusville Palm Bay?
57. Address of work destination in
Titusville Palm Bay? See #163 for suggested work area for DS II on November 18.
58. What evidence has LE found at any warehouses, storage facilities, or other properties to which DS II or Sr. has access?
Notes: Some properties owned by DS Jr. and Sr. now or in the past include 1982 Rose Blvd Home; 1984 Allied Roofing bORN - Listed as Rose Blvd Address; 2002 Lot & Unit at Sky Lake; 2005 Property off of Church St. no address just legal desc; 2005 Property at Pineway Drive - Sold the same year as acquired; 2007 Another property and unit on Sky Lake ; 2008 Condo in Carter Glen (Angelonline, 12/04, per Orange Co Comptroller Records); http://paarcgis2.ocpafl.org/ObliqueView/default.aspx?pid=292229000000174 property at S. Mission Rd. off 526 belonging to DS Sr. (Cerebellum, 12/7); LE search canal behind house owned by DS Sr. at 6806 Chaucer Ln. (occupied by DS Sr’s sister according to neighbors) on 12/9. Map of parcels owned by DS Sr. http://paarcgis.ocpafl.org/Webmap2/...2322620803130|292326808707920|302323120597030 (Coldpizza, 12/9)
59. In the days or weeks prior to 11/17/11, did MP express to friends or family members any apprehension about or annoyance with someone she encountered at her workplace or elsewhere? Any evidence of a “secret admirer”?
60. Does MP have a storage unit, and has this been checked for evidence by LE?
61. Stills from RG’s video show two different dark SUV vehicles leaving at two different times on 11/17/11, ie 17:17 and 16:40 (5:17 PM and 4:40 PM). LE has reported that the Hummer leaving on the video at 16:40 belongs to a neighbor on the street, not MP. Is the other departing vehicle a Hummer, and does it belong to MP or to yet another neighbor?
NOTES: Hummer leaving at 16:40 appears to be a dark grey color (notmissing, 12/04) Black SUV leaving at 17:17 has a license plate centered on the back, which is different license plate placement than MP’s Hummer, which is left rear (SmoothOperator, 12/6) Photos of 08 Hummers confirm the plates to be on the left rear. MP’s Hummer is thought to be an 08. (Taagean & SmoothOperator 12/6); Original video Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #15 and correction statement by MSN Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #15 (Sparky, 12/29/11); Post by Tony Pipitone about correction Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #4 Suggestion that what appears to be a centered plate on :the vehicle departing at 17:17 may actually be the road between left back and left front tires. (4BB, 1/3/12)
62. Activities, times, locations and other details, including calls and texts, demeanor, conversation topics, etc., of MP’s day on 11/17/11, beginning when she arises and ending with 3:18 PM arrival at DS II’s condo.
Notes: SmoothOperator’s most recent timeline Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #17 12:22 video of MP at KFC drivethru at 12:22 on 11/17/11 http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news...parker-missing-video-20120120,0,6141764.story. YS told ABC News that when MP had returned from taping PC in the summer, she described it as “The most humiliating experience of my life” that she wouldn’t ever want to see the episode and regretted having gone. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/11/22/idUS47066531120111122; the following clip indicates Lauren and Michelle talked about the show before she left the salon on 11/17. Geraldo quotes sister LE as telling him 20 mins before going on air that they were in the salon together, and MP started getting text messages. That is when sister LE started expressing her concern to MP: "I told her she's a pretty girl, a head turner, and what if someone watches and stalks you? I definitely worried about Michelle's safety around Dale, the husband, because he was malicious and violent when he got drunk. He's the last one to see her alive. He knows more than he is telling, but someone other than Dale must have been involved.” [December 7, 2011 Geraldo show on Fox News]
63. In the video of the condo search, DS II’s truck is in the garage. Where is DS II's work van at that time?
64. When did MP and NM meet face to face on 11/17/11, and when did they talk or text one another on their cells that day, other than the 3:15 text?
Notes: NM and MP met for coffee in AM, time unknown.
65. When did NM try to contact MP (text or call her cell) after 3:18 PM on 11/17/11?
66. If incoming white van as recorded by RG’s video, (subsequently parked on the street) is that of a neighbor or visitor to the condos, what did the driver of that van observe relative to MP, DS II, the twins, MP’s Hummer?
67. Did MP have any mobile tanning appointments on 11/17/11, and when? With new or established customers?
68. DS II’s visitation with the twins: (A) Did DS II have regularly scheduled visitation? (B) Was 11/17/11 a scheduled visitation day for him to take the twins? (C) If not, what are the details of how and when this visitation was arranged?
69. Where did MP park the Hummer when she was dropping off the twins at DS II’s?
Notes: RG's vid indicates that the incoming Hummer was driving in middle of road (perhaps to avoid the red car parked at the north curb), and may not have been able to pull into the garage driveway. Suggestion is that she may have parked to the west of the condo.
70. Was DS II’s garage open, or did MP go to the front door of the condo?
71. What vehicles were parked inside or in the driveway of DS II’s garage, or at the curb, when MP arrived to drop off the twins?
72. Has LE searched or will they search (A)
Titusville Palm Bay areas, and (B)possible route(s) from Orlando to
Titusville Palm Bay, and what evidence was found, if any?
Notes: See #165 for (A)
73. What time did MP’s 11 year old son arrive home from school on 11/17/11? Notes: MP’s sister LE said that the child usually got off the bus at around 3:30 PM
74. Did he try calling his mom, and what time(s) did he try calling her?
Notes: MP’s sister LE said that the child usually called his mother when he got off the school bus.
75. Did anyone attempt to call or text MP between 3:18 and 4:26 on 11/17/11?
76. DS II’s neighbor with the cam, RG, was not home when MP arrived, and says he saw nothing when he did arrive home. What time did RG arrive home?
77. Other than DS II’s mother and father, who else received subpoenas as of 12/6?
78. Where, when and how was MP’s cell found?
NOTES: On 12/7, LE released news that MP’s cell was found, thrown in the water near Lake Conway from a bridge, although which of two possible bridges is uncertain at this time; Bob Kealing identifies correct bridge as on Nela 12/9 ( ?) News report suggests that cell wasn’t found due to one specific tip Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #13 (JerseyGirl, 12/13) and at end of video: http://www.myfoxorlando.com/dpp/news/loc....ichelle-parker; Photos of both bridges, with Nela Bridge brush appearing more disturbed Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #14 (AlwaysWright); cell may have been in the brush, not the water. Posting on Marinade Dave’s journal where he tells of YS pointing out on a map where the phone was found. Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #17 (captdj, Kamille, 1/12/12). BP said on NG show 1/23/12 that phone was found simply by searching bodies of water along route DS II may have taken to Rose Ave. house
79. On which side of the bridge was the cell found, to help determine direction car was traveling?
NOTES: May be difficult to determine no matter the direction of the vehicle, since driver could toss out of driver's side window, or driver or passenger could toss out of passenger window. The phone was found on the northwest side of the bridge Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community - View Single Post - FL FL - Michelle Parker, 33, Orlando, 17 Nov 2011 - #17 (captdj, Kamille, 1/12/12).
80. What, if any, is the forensic evidence recovered from the cell?
81. What data, if any, was recovered from the cell?
82. Did MP attempt to call eleven y o son around 3:30 on, on 11/17/11?
83. Details of dumpster trash collection (ie, days and times) for dumpsters along the known or assumed route of the perp and/or accomplices, including significant locations such as Jesse Black’s Saloon, Carter Glen Condos, etc. Have the associated landfills been searched, and evidence found?
84. In respect to DS II’s reported presence at the Rose Ave. house: (A) did DS II take the twins to DS Sr.’s house on 11/17/11, (B) at what time and in what vehicle did he leave his condo with the twins and arrive at the Rose Ave. house, (C) who was the witness who confirmed he arrived “by” 4:30, and (D) what did this witness actually observe about the arrival?
Notes: MN, attorney for DS II and DS Sr., said that a witness can verify that DS II had arrived at the Rose Ave. house by 4:30 PM. http://www.wesh.com/r/29958175/detail.html (Analyze This).
85. Did DS II have a standard routine when he had the twins, and if so, did his actions/movement on 11/17/11 afternoon vary from that routine?
86. Will or have the twins been interviewed by LE, and if interviewed, what observations did they offer about what they remember from 11/17/11?
Notes: The Today Show reports twins removed from DS II’s home, questioned by LE, spent the night with Parker’s mom and were returned to DS II the following day after the hearing about custody. http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/45490...-dad-tv-show-disappearance-case/#.Tw3kQfkrc7l (Pias, 12/30/11).
87. Did LE search DS II’s condo on evening of 11/18/11 (Fri). If so, details of search.
Notes: MSM states that they were present and filming at the 11/18/11 search of DS II’s condo.
88. Details of where and when cadaver dogs have been used in this case, with evidence obtained.
Notes: MP’s father, when talking about the raid on the Rose Ave. house, mentioned that dogs were used, and “they didn’t come up with nothing,” but there’s no indication these were cadaver dogs http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news...ovember/349745 (TexasLil, 1/11/12)
89. Was the spare tire cover gone when the Hummer was found by LE?
90. Does DS II have a current girlfriend?
lease:
