Gilgo Beach LISK Serial Killer, Rex Heuermann, charged with 3 murders, July 2023

[faithx]

If this is 17 Dec 2024 - most recent photo - there is a lot to unpack:

View attachment 552690

Gilgo Beach suspect Rex Heuermann charged with seventh murder

Rex Heuermann, a New York architect, is accused of killing Valerie Mack, who was last seen by her family in New Jersey in 2000.

www.bbc.com

Media keep referring RH to be 61yo (DOB 12 Feb 1964) which makes RH 60yo.

According to his inmate record on VINELink, his DOB is September 13, 1963.

 

[CuriousCricket]

He’s scary…. That look he has.. just plain scary.

Plus to think of a man his size picking on tiny women . . .

 

[Just K]

The Rubbermaid tub is a dime a dozen. That’s no smoking gun. Why wouldn’t they charge Rex right now if he was responsible?

I read as many news stories as I could find, going back a far as I could to the original events. I’ve noticed there is kind of a telephone effect as the years progress and bad information can become a crazy fact…. So I like to go back to the source. I never saw it except for the wiki. However, when reading about other dismembered victims, some articles suggest their death was by dismemberment since the act of dismemberment hid the actual cause of death. Does that make sense? It’s possible this could have been one of those situations.

About the green Rubbermaid container. I did some research after the crime scene pictures became public. Green was not the most commonly sold color for those containers.

 

[Just K]

What's with the red marks all over his face?

Some of speculated that he might have Rosacea.

 

[Izzylizzy]

IMO:
Where does AE think the media gets their information from?
They're called indictments and bail applications and she needs to read them.
Macedonio chimes in on behalf of AE with his go-to laughable and offensive AE defense.

Alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer charged in 7th death

The suspect, a New York architect, was already accused of killing 6 other women, including Megan Waterman of Scarborough.

www.pressherald.com

 

[Just K]

But we had Costilla from 1993... and who knows where he killed her but obviously wasn't in his future

Why is everyone so convinced that he killed Peaches? It’s the hill many will die on that she was his victim! To me, her case doesn’t fit at all. She was black, had a child, was found with jewelry a towel, a pillow case and…. Had a child! She was also found in a completely different place. So you mean to tell me he dumps Sandra on one side of Long Island, then dumps peaches completely on the other side….then dumps Jessica and Valerie back where he dumped Sandra? (Not exactly but closer). Then he’s going to write his little killer to do list looking for a second dumpsite which he had already chosen if he killed peaches….you see that? That’s exactly why I don’t think he killed her. Because he hadn’t chosen Oak Beach yet. He chose Oak Beach with Valerie….and honestly, he was probably just driving around looking for a good spot. It was just a coincidence Peaches and her child happened to be there. It’s a good spot…..
I’ve even read some articles that say the police don’t think she’s one of his victims.she was most likely a domestic altercation.
I’ll admit I was wrong if I’m wrong…..but she just doesn’t fit to me.

Why is everyone so convinced that he killed Peaches? It’s the hill many will die on that she was his victim! To me, her case doesn’t fit at all. She was black, had a child, was found with jewelry a towel, a pillow case and…. Had a child! She was also found in a completely different place. So you mean to tell me he dumps Sandra on one side of Long Island, then dumps peaches completely on the other side….then dumps Jessica and Valerie back where he dumped Sandra? (Not exactly but closer). Then he’s going to write his little killer to do list looking for a second dumpsite which he had already chosen if he killed peaches….you see that? That’s exactly why I don’t think he killed her. Because he hadn’t chosen Oak Beach yet. He chose Oak Beach with Valerie….and honestly, he was probably just driving around looking for a good spot. It was just a coincidence Peaches and her child happened to be there. It’s a good spot…..
I’ve even read some articles that say the police don’t think she’s one of his victims.she was most likely a domestic altercation.
I’ll admit I was wrong if I’m wrong…..but she just doesn’t fit to me.

Peaches, just like JT and VM, was dismembered and parts of her body were found several miles from the other parts found on the Ocean Pkwy. Karen Vegata was also dismembered and her body parts were also found in two separate locations. It’s also possible that RH may have had a relationship with Peaches. Some of the victims he is charged with killing had African American or Hispanic backgrounds. RH searched the internet for men, women, homosexual and transvestites of all types of heritage. Eliminating Peaches based on race would be premature.

 

[Just K]

duplicate post

 

[Mr.Dandy]

About the green Rubbermaid container. I did some research after the crime scene pictures became public. Green was not the most commonly sold color for those containers.

Consider this….if it was a color that would go on clearance, that might make it more popular….like a Christmas color….

 

[Mr.Dandy]

According to his inmate record on VINELink, his DOB is September 13, 1963.

Weird. Why the mistake?

 

[TOMBISHOP]

Hi everyone..
I took the liberty of making a quick hypothetical list based on the year of disappearance (therefore perhaps of death) and in case the year of disappearance was not known, I put the year of discovery of the body or discovery of the first parts of the body in the second bracket .
Looking at this and perhaps comparing with a list in which the wife was absent or/and in any case looking year by year it seems clear to me that for being so brutal and complacent in his perverse game there are holes with victims still out there attribute to him.
(I know everyone will not agree with all those names on the list but please scroll to the next name and let's look at the whole together...there are probably even some names missing I believe in research more than just talking and you all are amazing, sorry for my english and please correct if I made mistakes).
...than:
Sandra Costilla (11-93)
Karen Vergata (02-96)
Peaches (?)(97)
Baby Peaches (?)(97)
Jacqueline Ashley Smith (08-99)
Valerie Mack (?-00)
Jessica Taylor (07-03)
Jamie Seymour (07-05) not found
Cherries (?)(03/07)
Maureen Brainard-Barnes (07-07)
Tanya Rush (06-08)
Melissa Barthelemy (07-09)
Shannan Gilbert (05-10)
Megan Waterman (06-10)
Amber Costello (09-10)
Asian male (?)(11)
Jane Doe Lattingtown (?)(13) asiatic, Pig necklace

 

[SimsGuy67]

Consider this….if it was a color that would go on clearance, that might make it more popular….like a Christmas color….

I'm not really sure if green Rubbermaid containers would be in higher demand on Christmas just because they're green. Do you expect green plant pots or rakes to go on sale during Christmas?

 

[NoSpoonFeeding]

I'm not really sure if green Rubbermaid containers would be in higher demand on Christmas just because they're green. Do you expect green plant pots or rakes to go on sale during Christmas?

All of my many large Christmas storage totes are green, so are my daughter's and my mother's. We have enough to fill a small warehouse. Half of them have red lids. Look on Amazon, there are many varieties and brands of large green storage containers, available year round. It makes it easy to know which totes are for Christmas if you have a lot of other storage too. And they are in the stores right now.

 

[Mr.Dandy]

I'm not really sure if green Rubbermaid containers would be in higher demand on Christmas just because they're green. Do you expect green plant pots or rakes to go on sale during Christmas?

I have a bunch of green totes… 75% after Christmas. I’m cheap and totes are expensive.

 

[SimsGuy67]

I have a bunch of green totes… 75% after Christmas. I’m cheap and totes are expensive.

Either way, I do hope Peaches' killer is caught and justice can be given to her and her family. I do think RH is her killer, but either one of us could be wrong. We'll just have to wait and see if LE can find enough evidence to charge him or not.

 

[whiterhino]

All of my many large Christmas storage totes are green, so are my daughter's and my mother's. We have enough to fill a small warehouse. Half of them have red lids. Look on Amazon, there are many varieties and brands of large green storage containers, available year round. It makes it easy to know which totes are for Christmas if you have a lot of other storage too. And they are in the stores right now.

I think Rubbermaid had a collection specifically for Christmas at one time? Containers for storing wrapping paper, wreaths etc. I used to have one that was red and green too, the lid was red like yours. Looking at an older one right now, it's dusty blue from the 90's.

 

[Mr.Dandy]

Hi everyone..
I took the liberty of making a quick hypothetical list based on the year of disappearance (therefore perhaps of death) and in case the year of disappearance was not known, I put the year of discovery of the body or discovery of the first parts of the body in the second bracket .
Looking at this and perhaps comparing with a list in which the wife was absent or/and in any case looking year by year it seems clear to me that for being so brutal and complacent in his perverse game there are holes with victims still out there attribute to him.
(I know everyone will not agree with all those names on the list but please scroll to the next name and let's look at the whole together...there are probably even some names missing I believe in research more than just talking and you all are amazing, sorry for my english and please correct if I made mistakes).
...than:
Sandra Costilla (11-93)
Karen Vergata (02-96)
Peaches (?)(97)
Baby Peaches (?)(97)
Jacqueline Ashley Smith (08-99)
Valerie Mack (?-00)
Jessica Taylor (07-03)
Jamie Seymour (07-05) not found
Cherries (?)(03/07)
Maureen Brainard-Barnes (07-07)
Tanya Rush (06-08)
Melissa Barthelemy (07-09)
Shannan Gilbert (05-10)
Megan Waterman (06-10)
Amber Costello (09-10)
Asian male (?)(11)
Jane Doe Lattingtown (?)(13) asiatic, Pig necklace

There are men you could add. Andre Isaac(Sugar bear) 2002, Erika McDaniel 2012?2013?, Tina Foglia 1982, Carmen Vargas 1989, numerous Manorville Does, and for kicks, Victoria Camera, Jessie Foster, and Lindsay Marie Harris all missing or murdered in Nevada but all from New York. They’re pretty weird cases that may or may not be LISK. There was another serial killer that may have attributed to their deaths.

 

[Eaglette]

Sandra Costilla (11-93)
Karen Vergata (02-96)
Peaches (?)(97)
Baby Peaches (?)(97)
Jacqueline Ashley Smith (08-99)
Valerie Mack (?-00)
Jessica Taylor (07-03)
Jamie Seymour (07-05) not found
Cherries (?)(03/07)
Maureen Brainard-Barnes (07-07)
Tanya Rush (06-08)
Melissa Barthelemy (07-09)
Shannan Gilbert (05-10)
Megan Waterman (06-10)
Amber Costello (09-10)
Asian male (?)(11)
Jane Doe Lattingtown (?)(13) asiatic, Pig necklace

Can someone please clean this up ? Eg word doc/excel list - in a "table" format

Surely we already have a list in a previous thread ?
Perhaps it could be pinned to the top ?
Thanks in Advance (I don't have access to Word/Excel as I'm on holidays ATM)
Surely the media have done a list of missing fear murdered ?

eg:

NAME - AGE - YEAR MISSING - YEAR FOUND (PARTIAL) - YEAR FOUND (TOTAL)

*Red is clear = RH is charged with the murder of those in red
Maureen Brainard-Barnes (07-07) - what does 07-07 mean ? Im totally confused.
? Is what is in the brackets indeed correct ?

+ add in the men ? Andre Isaac(Sugar bear) 2002, Erika McDaniel 2012?2013?, Tina Foglia 1982, Carmen Vargas 1989, numerous Manorville Does, and for kicks, Victoria Camera, Jessie Foster, and Lindsay Marie Harris all missing or murdered

 

[SimsGuy67]

Can someone please clean this up ? Eg word doc/excel list - in a "table" format

Surely we already have a list in a previous thread ?
Perhaps it could be pinned to the top ?
Thanks in Advance (I don't have access to Word/Excel as I'm on holidays ATM)
Surely the media have done a list of missing fear murdered ?

eg:

NAME - AGE - YEAR MISSING - YEAR FOUND (PARTIAL) - YEAR FOUND (TOTAL)

*Red is clear = RH is charged with the murder of those in red
Maureen Brainard-Barnes (07-07) - what does 07-07 mean ? Im totally confused.
? Is what is in the brackets indeed correct ?

+ add in the men ? Andre Isaac(Sugar bear) 2002, Erika McDaniel 2012?2013?, Tina Foglia 1982, Carmen Vargas 1989, numerous Manorville Does, and for kicks, Victoria Camera, Jessie Foster, and Lindsay Marie Harris all missing or murdered

Sure, but I can actually do it right here on WS!

NAME	AGE	DLC	1st Discovery	2nd Discovery	3rd Discovery
Tina Foglia	19	February 1, 1982	February 3, 1982	N/A	N/A
Carmen Vargas	29	1989	September 11, 1989	N/A	N/A
Sandra Costilla	28	November 19-20, 1993	November 20, 1993	N/A	N/A
Karen Vergata	34	February 14, 1996	April 20, 1996	April 12, 2011	N/A
Peaches	16 - 30	N/A	June 28, 1997	April 11, 2011	N/A
Baby Doe	1 - 4	N/A	April 4, 2011	N/A	N/A
Jacqueline Smith	16	August 12, 1999	June 20, 2000	N/A	N/A
Valerie Mack	24	Spring/Summer 2000	November 19, 2000	April 4, 2011	N/A
Manorville John Doe	30 - 45	N/A	November 23, 2002	N/A	N/A
Andre Isaac	25	November 2002	December 17, 2002	January 25, 2003	April 10, 2004
Jessica Taylor	20	July 21, 2003	July 26, 2003	March 29, 2011	N/A
Jamie Seymour	21	July 22, 2005	N/A	N/A	N/A
Cherries	35 - 50	N/A	March 3, 2007	March 21, 2007	March 22, 2007
Maureen Brainard-Barnes	25	July 9, 2007	December 13, 2010	N/A	N/A
Tanya Rush	39	c. June 22, 2008	June 27, 2008	N/A	N/A
Melissa Barthelemy	24	July 12, 2009	December 11, 2010	N/A	N/A
Shannan Gilbert	24	May 2, 2010	December 13, 2011	N/A	N./A
Megan Waterman	22	June 6, 2010	December 13, 2010	N/A	N/A
Amber Costello	27	September 2, 2010	December 13, 2010	N/A	N/A
Erica McDaniel	30	c. 2011	March 23, 2013
Asian Male	17 - 23	N/A	April 4, 2011	N/A	N/A
Lattingtown Jane Doe	20 - 50	N/A	January 21, 2013	N/A	N/A

 

[TOMBISHOP]

It was not my intention to cause confusion and I apologize for this if I did.
I didn't specify some things like: I only placed victims at NY/LI...
I was undecided whether to include men or not because it creates even more doubts in me, we are in doubt about RH's alleged bisexuality and I preferred not to load the theoretical list too much with men too (I have a list with men too which would actually fill in the gaps but I wanted to hear first your opinions).
secondly true i forgot some girls out there please feel free to take this list and add names if you wish.
I explained the parentheses in the post, it seems clear to me and the dates should be correct, I repeat I only put the year of disappearance and if this unknown date I put the year the body or body parts were found in second parentheses, all this to highlight RH's alleged murderous rampage year after year, this is intended to highlight essential information and better understand where to look... for example 2010 seems like a year where RH really wanted to "play his game".

 

[Mr.Dandy]

It was not my intention to cause confusion and I apologize for this if I did.
I didn't specify some things like: I only placed victims at NY/LI...
I was undecided whether to include men or not because it creates even more doubts in me, we are in doubt about RH's alleged bisexuality and I preferred not to load the theoretical list too much with men too (I have a list with men too which would actually fill in the gaps but I wanted to hear first your opinions).
secondly true i forgot some girls out there please feel free to take this list and add names if you wish.
I explained the parentheses in the post, it seems clear to me and the dates should be correct, I repeat I only put the year of disappearance and if this unknown date I put the year the body or body parts were found in second parentheses, all this to highlight RH's alleged murderous rampage year after year, this is intended to highlight essential information and better understand where to look... for example 2010 seems like a year where RH really wanted to "play his game".

I completely agree about men. I don’t think they are part of his victim list but….. it does prove that there were other killers using parts of Long Island as their dumping ground. I don’t know if that fact alone muddies the waters but it is true. It could see doubt about some of the other estranged victims.